Idk if he had possession when the first foot was down and then it was definitely out

Once he secures the catch, only one foot is down, and the other comes down on the line with a bobble. That's no catch.

Just now, jmac+djaxallday said:

I thought he might've got that first foot down.

That’s what the challenge is arguing.

Feet were good but I think he bobbled it.

Just now, Southparkeagles said:

I dont like this challenge.

Why not? It's close

He caught it with feet in, then bobbled it.

Just now, EagleJoe8 said:

Once he secures the catch, only one foot is down, and the other comes down on the line with a bobble. That's no catch.

He had a foot in before that

Aren't you supposed to make a football move for it to be a catch now? I don't think it's officially a catch at that moment. Wouldn't have challenged that

Man I dunno. That last slo mo before the break looked like his heel was inbounds before the front of his foot landed out.

Had the 1st foot down but not sure he had complete control of the ball.

We gotta get one of these replays eventually

Just now, Uscg-green said:

He had a foot in before that

But I don't think he secured it.

Of course. 🙄

Barkley for 2.

1 minute ago, Portyansky said:

He caught it with feet in, then bobbled it.

Yeah the bobble is where it was lost.

2 minutes ago, kiwinavega said:

Needed to challenge that Dotson catch. His first foot was down, second was fine. Actually, he is challenging it...

Are they saying he bobbled it after the first foot came down?

1 minute ago, Uscg-green said:

Why not? It's close

Close, but not enough to overturn it.

When's the last time we got one of those could go either way calls?

Good challenge even though they lost it. Was close enough for a doubt and that timeout isn't much use as they want to close the half, especially as they get the ball to start the second half

Seriously how do you false start out the gate?

Just now, Southparkeagles said:

Close, but not enough to overturn it.

And all it cost was a timeout. No big deal.

Is Jim trying to be cute ? Siri-Annie? (Cam) jerkins? Lol

Just now, Uscg-green said:

When's the last time we got one of those could go either way calls?

Doesn’t happen. It’s Philly.

Just now, jmac+djaxallday said:

Are they saying he bobbled it after the first foot came down?

Not sure, on GamePass we were in an ad break in the stream when the decision came in

Remember when they didn't go directly to commercial and instead viewed all of the replays to analyze the play about the challenge

Those were the golden days