December 10, 2025Dec 10 10 hours ago, scottr@pictips.com said:Just stop, we all know he is not being benched.Jalen Hurts is considered untouchable, so you're probably right.
December 10, 2025Dec 10 16 hours ago, EagleMatt said:Jalen Hurts = Russel WilsonYou've been listening to Giglio.
December 10, 2025Dec 10 He will be benched week 18 when we have the NFCE wrapped up. Every time gameshow makes a thread like this it back fires. I want you to say this to yourself... we should bench the SB MVP... some of you seriously are crazy. Only fan base in history that always likes the backup over the starting QB.
December 10, 2025Dec 10 23 minutes ago, Portyansky said:He will be benched week 18 when we have the NFCE wrapped up. Everything gameshow makes a thread a like this it back fires. I want you to say this to yourself... we should bench the SB MVP... some of you seriously are crazy. Only fan base in history that always likes the backup over the starting QB.The defense was the SB MVP
December 10, 2025Dec 10 27 minutes ago, Portyansky said:He will be benched week 18 when we have the NFCE wrapped up. Everything gameshow makes a thread a like this it back fires. I want you to say this to yourself... we should bench the SB MVP... some of you seriously are crazy. Only fan base in history that always likes the backup over the starting QB.I actually don't want him benched yet, I want to see if he can bounce back after 2 miserable weeks. Let's see how much adversity he can handle and if he can't get back on track this week and ends up playing like has been? Yes then bench him.
December 10, 2025Dec 10 21 hours ago, EagleMatt said:Jalen Hurts = Russel WilsonI don't know about you but I would love for Jalen to have Russel's passing numbers
December 10, 2025Dec 10 1 hour ago, Bwestbrook36 said:I actually don't want him benched yet, I want to see if he can bounce back after 2 miserable weeks. Let's see how much adversity he can handle and if he can't get back on track this week and ends up playing like has been? Yes then bench him.Think of his career since College. Dude's whole career has been adversity and at the highest point of adversity he shows up. I hate what I've seen, but he deserves the benefit of the doubt.
December 10, 2025Dec 10 1 hour ago, Mike030270 said:The defense was the SB MVPYea, but someone had to throw AJ and Smitty the TDs, right? Saquan was bottled up all game. Hurts used his legs. 77% completion %. Dude played lights out.
December 10, 2025Dec 10 2 minutes ago, Portyansky said:Think of his career since College. Dude's whole career has been adversity and at the highest point of adversity he shows up. I hate what I've seen, but he deserves the benefit of the doubt.Fair enough and good point. I never thought it was a possibility but, I'm sure it's a thought that crossed their minds . I think he bounces back
December 10, 2025Dec 10 15 minutes ago, Bwestbrook36 said:Fair enough and good point. I never thought it was a possibility but, I'm sure it's a thought that crossed their minds . I think he bounces backSome fans, yes. Sirianni, not a chance. He's an idiot, but not like that lol
December 10, 2025Dec 10 Benching Hurts is not going to fix Patullo.Hurts is doing exactly what a leader does.....he's taking responsibility and he's pressing to try to jumpstart things. He's trying to overcome the lousy play calling and lousy game plan but forcing things. Calling for Hurts to be benched is flat out IDIOTIC. But there is no shortage of idiots in eagles fans and the media.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 12 hours ago, time2rock said:You've been listening to Giglio.I dont know who that is
December 11, 2025Dec 11 I think its fair to bench Hurts, AJ, and Mailata for their sloppy play on MNF. Not this week though. Lets do it in Buffalo.No need to see if McKee is a scrub who can beat hideous Cancun teams in Philly in December, we already know he is at least as good as a scrub.Make sure that Patullo calls the bad plays in nice and late as usual and Steen tips the snap on every play.Remember, without the AJ drops and the Mailata hold, Hurts and the Eagles likely beat the Chargers by 10+ with the 4 turnovers.It would have been a really bizarre game with AJ havingAJ - 67 yard TD pass --- he drops it. (totally different game if its 7-0 Eagles on the first play)AJ - 25 yard TD pass --- he drops itAJ - 12 yard pass at the hash marks that are so important to the haters. AJ deflects it off his hands.Wait, did you say it was thrown to fast? Hurts does not have a Josh Allen arm. How could he ever throw a ball too fast?AJ is a 25+ million WR. He has to catch that ball.AJ - 2 yard TD pass --- Mailata can't block someone for 2 1/2 seconds so he grabs (doesn't get called often when its not Philly but he did grab)Mailata is a 22 million dollar LT. He has to block people on occasion.AJ winds up with 3 TDs and close to 200 yards even with Hurts having his turnover festival F game if they did not also have their F games.Hurts is the 11th highest paid QB.AJ is the 6th highest paid WR.Mailata is the 8th highest paid LT.Why does only one of them need some accountability?Just fix the AJ TD drop on play 1, the Mailata hold, and Jake missing a 48 yard FG and that game is 20-10 Eagles lead at the half.Hurts plays exactly the same game.Then the Eagles run more and Herbert has to pass more in the 2nd half.Or the Chargers have to sell out vs the run and they go Dagger on them.Herbert netted 112 yards on 42 of his 43 drop backs/runs, and he had a flukey screen pass go for 60.You think Herbert needing to throw more in the 2nd half would have gone well for the Chargers?Yeah, go ahead and pretend Hurts is the problem or was even the biggest problem in this game (AJ was)WRs should never throw an interception off their hands and drop 2 TDs in the same game.The Eagles talent was 30 points better than the Chargers before Patullo/Siri, Snap Tipper 56, Hurts, AJ, and Mailata all stunk up the joint with F games.We got 15 more gimp snaps from Calcaterra too!56 is an awesome number for Steen. He turns average DEs into Lawrence Taylor by letting them know exactly when the snap is coming.This is the GoaT with a Steen at center head bobbing the snap count for Denver. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9W8a10604cY20 QB hits! 20!Siri and Patullo know that Steen is tipping the snap and they are fine with it.Howie and Lurie can fix most of this. I have no idea why they won't.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 8 hours ago, Talonblood said:Bench him for a game to let him refocus. See what happens.Just like Kotite did to Randall? Same opponent too.I remember Randall being a chip shot shank away from a Super Bowl after that and Kotite finished up 4-35.I do want Hurts to win another SB, just not for another team like Minnesota or Indy.If Siri had any balls he would have benched Hurts at halftime and maybe they win that game. It would not be punishment, it would be tactical in the moment.Then Hurts starts this week and the team got the message.Or they didn't get the message and then you start thinking about McKee playing more.Only a Kotite level scumbag benches their SB MVP QB in a setup game vs Prairie View Vegas to make him look bad.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 BTW, when some talking head loser on TV says "The Defense was the MVP" and you have to see 10 people here parroting the propaganda like a cult...MOSTVALUABLEPLAYERA defense is not a player. Its about 20 players. No way in hell was Josh Sweat better than Hurts in the SB.If Sweat broke his leg on the first play, they still would have swarmed all night.If Hurts did, the Chiefs might win the game.Hurts had 282 yards of offense on 35 plays. (8 a pop)He had 72 yards rushing on 11 carries ( just under 7 a pop)Saquon and Gainwell had 67 yards rushing on 31 carries (just over 2 a pop)Fangio was not the MVP.Doug was not the MVP over Foles.Sean Payton and his onsides kick was not the MVP over Brees.If that LIX SB was Buffalo over the Rams 40-6 and then 40-22 and Allen had the same stats, NO ONE is calling for McDermott or the D, or a DE to be MVP.I get that from a Cowboys fan but from an Eagles fan? Its truly disgusting to hate your QB that much.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 46 minutes ago, SkippyX said:Just like Kotite did to Randall? Same opponent too.I remember Randall being a chip shot shank away from a Super Bowl after that and Kotite finished up 4-35.I do want Hurts to win another SB, just not for another team like Minnesota or Indy.If Siri had any balls he would have benched Hurts at halftime and maybe they win that game. It would not be punishment, it would be tactical in the moment.Then Hurts starts this week and the team got the message.Or they didn't get the message and then you start thinking about McKee playing more.Only a Kotite level scumbag benches their SB MVP QB in a setup game vs Prairie View Vegas to make him look bad.Its more than this one game that Hurts hasn't been very good, and in this last game, he was horrible. I would let him sit, regain his faculties, let it all sink in, and then let him start again. It would be GOOD for Hurts.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 People think Hurts = Wilson is an insult. It is actually a self-insult to anyone who thinks its an insult.Hurts was 6-3 in the playoffs in his first 4 years as a starter with 2 SBs and a ring.Wilson was 7-3 with the same (but not an MVP)Wilson through his first 9 seasons was 98-45-1 with 9 playoff wins. It was not 11+ playoff wins and 2 or 3 SB rings because his coach was brain dead.There is only 1 playoff game in NFL history that you can absolutely 100% blame the head coach for the loss.Smart guy Pete iced the Falcons kicker as he missed. So the kicker got a second try and beat Seattle.Pete was also the "screw Beast Mode, we are going 3 wide at the goal line!" moronIf you think that was a bad throw in the end zone its because you know nothing about football.The 2 pathetic Seahawks WRs were not yet annihilated when Wilson starts his throw.That Seahawks team is nothing with high priced free agent Matt Flynn at QB.Sherman is Darrell Revis on the Jets + losing a SB in SF instead of Revis winning in NE if Sherman did not have Wilson carrying his team's offense.Wilson had 267 TDs to 81 picks through 9 years. That's 3.3 to 1.That had him 2nd at the time and he is now 4th all-time even with his old age on bad teams seasons.Hurts has the 6th highest all-time in SB passer rating at 109.4.Wilson is 3rd all-time at 117.4For a long time Aaron Rodgers was the only QB with a career 100+ rating, until Wilson joined him.Wilson was still at 100 for his career after 2 years in Denver.He has now dipped under but he is still 5th all-time.Wilson also averaged 600+ rushing and 3 TDs a season for his first 4 years (the SB years included)He had a winning record every year for his first 9 years and he won 10+ games 8 times.Stafford just had his 8th total winning record season and 5th season of 10+ wins.The reason those of you who are incapable of thinking on your own believe that Wilson is a punch line is called propaganda.Propaganda only works on the ignorant.He has not been great in his mid to late 30s on bad teams. McNabb was completely washed by age 34.I don't even hold DC and Minny numbers against McNabb and I blame him for cancelling 2+ parades by himself.The media wants you to hate Wilson. This is because they love the violent criminal and drug cheat, Richard Sherman.Sherman hated Wilson because he got the spotlight and made more money than he did.Wilson should be a clear first ballot HoFer based on his play and success, but the scumbag propaganda media also votes for the HoF.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 27 minutes ago, Talonblood said:Its more than this one game that Hurts hasn't been very good, and in this last game, he was horrible. I would let him sit, regain his faculties, let it all sink in, and then let him start again. It would be GOOD for Hurts.It would not be GOOD for Hurts. The halftime benching might have been.I think Hurts should get the exact same treatment as these QBs after 5+ turnover games.Pittsburgh Steelers at Cincinnati Bengals - September 11t...Pro-Football-Reference.comDetroit Lions at Seattle Seahawks - November 8th, 2009 |...Detroit Lions at New Orleans Saints - October 15th, 2017...Indianapolis Colts at San Diego Chargers - November 11th,...Seattle Seahawks at Green Bay Packers - November 1st, 199...Green Bay Packers at Cincinnati Bengals - October 30th, 2...Baltimore Ravens at Buffalo Bills - September 29th, 2013...Kansas City Chiefs at Denver Broncos - December 14th, 198...Pro-Football-Reference.comNew York Jets at Miami Dolphins - October 23rd, 1988 | Pr...Allen only had 4 here because of fumble luck. He did have 3 picks and 2 fumbles, 1 lost. Do you coach that differently?Pro-Football-Reference.comBuffalo Bills at New York Jets - September 11th, 2023 | P...Eli had 20 picks and 13 fumbles with 7 lost in 2007. Whatever he needed to learn, he learned on the field.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 16 hours ago, Mike030270 said:The defense was the SB MVPYeah besides the couple of great scrambles he had I don't think Hurts played amazing. But then again Super Bowl MVP is meaningless anyway. It's one game.And you can't bench Hurts (unless he's injured) because it won't "fix" Hurts. By benching him you pretty much admit that Hurts can't work with this offensive scheme and you want someone else to drive it. They would fire Patullo before benching Hurts.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 8 hours ago, SkippyX said:It would not be GOOD for Hurts. The halftime benching might have been.I think Hurts should get the exact same treatment as these QBs after 5+ turnover games.Pittsburgh Steelers at Cincinnati Bengals - September 11t...Pro-Football-Reference.comDetroit Lions at Seattle Seahawks - November 8th, 2009 |...Detroit Lions at New Orleans Saints - October 15th, 2017...Indianapolis Colts at San Diego Chargers - November 11th,...Seattle Seahawks at Green Bay Packers - November 1st, 199...Green Bay Packers at Cincinnati Bengals - October 30th, 2...Baltimore Ravens at Buffalo Bills - September 29th, 2013...Kansas City Chiefs at Denver Broncos - December 14th, 198...Pro-Football-Reference.comNew York Jets at Miami Dolphins - October 23rd, 1988 | Pr...Allen only had 4 here because of fumble luck. He did have 3 picks and 2 fumbles, 1 lost. Do you coach that differently?Pro-Football-Reference.comBuffalo Bills at New York Jets - September 11th, 2023 | P...Eli had 20 picks and 13 fumbles with 7 lost in 2007. Whatever he needed to learn, he learned on the field.Ok, ok- that is YOUR OPINION, not FACTS. I hold to MY opinion. Your opinion is ONLY that- an opinion. Everybody has one, sort of like an a** hole.
December 11, 2025Dec 11 Benching a franchise QB is only something a coach does when his job is on the line. Those "benchings" really aren't benchings, they're replacings. Sirianni isn't getting fired after this season, so it's important for him to demonstrate trust in his players.
Create an account or sign in to comment