9 hours ago, kiwinavega said:

What does he do? He wins football games at a historic rate. Even in this very frustrating season we won 11 games with a brutal schedule. He's not free of blame by any means, but he's made the playoffs every year, had a crazy carousel of coordinators, and made the Super Bowl in 40% of his seasons. You don't do that if you are just some scrub.

That’s a team stat. What does he do himself that makes him special

9 hours ago, Gannan said:

All those players? The offense is exactly the same as it was last year minus one offensive lineman...2 after Johnson's injury. They have the most talented roster in the NFL.

I was talking about the team in it's entirety. I didn't specify offense. They lost a lot of guys and coaches. Repeating is tough and even more tough when hiring an unproven green offensive coordinator. I was frankly more disappointed in the undisciplined penalty ridden play than anything else this year. They weren't locked in at all. Fat from the championship.

IMHO Siriani's only role is to manage the roster that Howie built. He's pretty much useless as a play caller or anything else.

That's why I don't think they will replace him with a Harbaugh or whoever. Harbaugh especially wouldn't want to coach Hurts ie a Lamar with less talent.

We already know the formula it has worked twice, hire great coordinators and let them cook. Why not just do it again, whether Siri stays or goes is irrelevant.

30 minutes ago, opa-opa said:

IMHO Siriani's only role is to manage the roster that Howie built. He's pretty much useless as a play caller or anything else.

That's why I don't think they will replace him with a Harbaugh or whoever. Harbaugh especially wouldn't want to coach Hurts ie a Lamar with less talent.

We already know the formula it has worked twice, hire great coordinators and let them cook. Why not just do it again, whether Siri stays or goes is irrelevant.

IMHO he gets an F- for managing the roster in 2025. Fire him.

I asked my DC fan friend: "Quinn retires tomorrow for health reasons. Eagles fire Siri and hire Stefanski. Do you want Siri?"

His answer: "No, a hard NO!"

11 hours ago, Mike030270 said:

That’s a team stat. What does he do himself that makes him special

Follow that to its logical extension and nobody is responsible for success or accountable for failure

Go get Mike McDaniel.

Or trade Siri to New Orleans for Kellen Moore.

On 1/11/2026 at 9:52 PM, Aspiritfall said:

I wouldn't be upset if siri was shown the door that said I don't think siri will be fired but I do think kp is gone... Theres absolutely no way to justify keeping kp... If siri objects he'll go the same way Doug did

Well I think Lurie is becoming aware of Siriannis and Hurts limitations and they are not good for consistent NFL success. we've been overcoming this with a lot of talent but eventually that doesn't work either.

If we get rid of AJ Hurts will need another WR that can win 50/50 balls cause thats what hurts likes to throw.

13 hours ago, JohnB said:

there is no reason in the world why we should have lost to t he 49ers. They were banged up. They were without some key players and they really got rattled the week before against Seattle. My point is I don't think we would have fared much better against the Packers.

We have already defeated them. We shouldn’t have lost to the 49ers, but the Eagles got out coached and were undisciplined. You’re right they shouldn’t have lost, and the lack or discipline, and offensive ingenuity really cost this team. The Eagles offense is so basic, defenders off the street can come in and defend it. Knowing that they already defeated the Packers in Green Bay should have given them a better chance, because no one on the Packers offensively is as dynamic of a player as Mccaffrey.

Sirianni should be on the hot seat but he’s not going to be and he’s going to get more time. So with that likely being the case they need to bring in an OC and tell Sirianni to be hands off with it. Which in my opinion goes back to the whole "he should be fired” thing but there you go. But this can’t be his scheme anymore and he can’t really be involved. And that OC needs to be the right man to get the most out of Jalen again.

3 minutes ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:

Sirianni should be on the hot seat but he’s not going to be and he’s going to get more time. So with that likely being the case they need to bring in an OC and tell Sirianni to be hands off with it. Which in my opinion goes back to the whole "he should be fired” thing but there you go. But this can’t be his scheme anymore and he can’t really be involved. And that OC needs to be the right man to get the most out of Jalen again.

That's the conundrum the Eagles find themselves in. This is Sirianni's offense and always has been. Moore brought a few things to the table of his own, but he operated within Siri's overarching philosophy.

I'm not 100% sure, but John Harbaugh was a ST coach so he may have acted more as a true CEO type of coach whom let his OC and DC have full reign. If Sirianni stays, that's the realm Howie and Lurie have to put him in...a true CEO type with hands-off on the offense and let the new OC have full reign to design and run the offense as he sees fit. But, I imagine Sirianni's ego would have real trouble with that.

3 hours ago, EaglesAddict said:

If Sirianni stays, that's the realm Howie and Lurie have to put him in...a true CEO type with hands-off on the offense and let the new OC have full reign to design and run the offense as he sees fit. But, I imagine Sirianni's ego would have real trouble with that.

Completely agree. I’d move on from Sirianni but I think most of us (if not all of us) can agree that he isn’t going anywhere this offseason. His record is really really good and so he’s got a good defense to stay. But they need to move him away from the offense and get him back to the CEO HC work that he has been really good at.

Well if an ultimatum was given, Sirianni chose to save himself.

31 minutes ago, EazyEaglez said:

Well if an ultimatum was given, Sirianni chose to save himself.

Exactly. And now everyone can put to rest any thoughts on Sirianni getting fired … at least at this time.

If Cignetti wants to be HC then you fire Siri. I wouldn't limit the search to an OC.