Each team would be taking major franchise shifting swings. In which direction we would find out in time.

I think I would do it from the Eagles perspective. From the Saints? Maybe. But I think a Tanner McKee trade would come after or be packaged in with more picks or players.

I want to remind everyone that Nick Sirianni HAS THE SECOND MOST WINS THROUGH HIS FIRST FIVE SEASONS OF ANY COACH IN THE HISTORY OF PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL

Is he heavily buoyed by a GM who gave him a loaded roster? Yes. Does he have coordinators who take a lot of load off of him? Yes. But this isn’t the first time in history that a team had talent and/or good coordinators. However this is only the second time a coach has won so much with them WITH THE SECOND MOST WINS THROUGH HIS FIRST FIVE SEASONS OF ANY COACH IN THE HISTORY OF PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL

But Philadelphia does not actually have the greatest roster of alltime. Philadelphia also does not have the greatest coordinators of alltime. How many SBs does Bill Walsh win without Joe Montana and Jerry Rice and Ronnie Lott? How many SBs does Jimmy Johnson win without Emmitt Smith and Michael Irvin and the Great Wall? Did you know Bill Parcells did not call plays AND had Bill Belichick as his defensive coordinator? Did you know Mike Tomlin did not call plays AND had Dick Lebeau as his defensive coordinator?

Kellen Moore went to the NFC South and couldn’t win the division where 8-9 was good enough. That’s enough to convince you he’s better than a guy who has more playoff wins than years coached?

Current coaches with more playoff wins than years coached:

Sirianni

Mcvay

Reid

that’s it

2 hours ago, Aerolithe_Lion said:

I want to remind everyone that Nick Sirianni HAS THE SECOND MOST WINS THROUGH HIS FIRST FIVE SEASONS OF ANY COACH IN THE HISTORY OF PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL

Is he heavily buoyed by a GM who gave him a loaded roster? Yes. Does he have coordinators who take a lot of load off of him? Yes. But this isn’t the first time in history that a team had talent and/or good coordinators. However this is only the second time a coach has won so much with them WITH THE SECOND MOST WINS THROUGH HIS FIRST FIVE SEASONS OF ANY COACH IN THE HISTORY OF PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL

But Philadelphia does not actually have the greatest roster of alltime. Philadelphia also does not have the greatest coordinators of alltime. How many SBs does Bill Walsh win without Joe Montana and Jerry Rice and Ronnie Lott? How many SBs does Jimmy Johnson win without Emmitt Smith and Michael Irvin and the Great Wall? Did you know Bill Parcells did not call plays AND had Bill Belichick as his defensive coordinator? Did you know Mike Tomlin did not call plays AND had Dick Lebeau as his defensive coordinator?

Kellen Moore went to the NFC South and couldn’t win the division where 8-9 was good enough. That’s enough to convince you he’s better than a guy who has more playoff wins than years coached?

Current coaches with more playoff wins than years coached:

Sirianni

Mcvay

Reid

that’s it

According to this fan base if you don't win with garbage you are worthless and carried by the talent. Same goes for the QB win with garbage or you suck and the back up should play because they did the awesome with 2nd stringers in pre seasonzzzz.

Siri's record is irrelevant. He is not getting the 2024 or 2022 team and coaching staff back together.

You have to judge him on what he did in 2025 and what you think that means going forward.

Its clear that he is a moron who undermines his own team. He betrayed the Eagles offense so that his best friend could be OC and then stay OC when he fell on his face.

On a scale of 0 to 100 Siri's judgement and performance this year was a 0

Nothing else matters besides his Patullo / Siri offense.

He is supposed to be this glue guy and he watched AJ quit on the team and could do nothing to motivate him.

If you think the only way to win with a CEO / Offense coach is to keep him away from the offense and bring in someone competent then why do you need him?

This PoS purposely destroyed play after play by having Calcaterra in the game to block when a competent Latu was on the bench.

A dog with buttons would play Latu more than Siri did.

He would use Fred as a blocker when Lane was in the game and was too stupid to realize he had other backup OL who could be the Fred type blocker with Lane out.

He's just a stupid person. The team and the fans deserve better.

As far as I can tell the whole point of the Eagles 2025 offense was to keep Patullo at OC and to play Calcaterra often.

23 minutes ago, SkippyX said:

Siri's record is irrelevant. He is not getting the 2024 or 2022 team and coaching staff back together.

You have to judge him on what he did in 2025 and what you think that means going forward.

Its clear that he is a moron who undermines his own team. He betrayed the Eagles offense so that his best friend could be OC and then stay OC when he fell on his face.

On a scale of 0 to 100 Siri's judgement and performance this year was a 0

Nothing else matters besides his Patullo / Siri offense.

He is supposed to be this glue guy and he watched AJ quit on the team and could do nothing to motivate him.

If you think the only way to win with a CEO / Offense coach is to keep him away from the offense and bring in someone competent then why do you need him?

This PoS purposely destroyed play after play by having Calcaterra in the game to block when a competent Latu was on the bench.

A dog with buttons would play Latu more than Siri did.

He would use Fred as a blocker when Lane was in the game and was too stupid to realize he had other backup OL who could be the Fred type blocker with Lane out.

He's just a stupid person. The team and the fans deserve better.

As far as I can tell the whole point of the Eagles 2025 offense was to keep Patullo at OC and to play Calcaterra often.

Yup, this season was wasted in a season where they could have made a serious run at a repeat.

Instead we get tweedle dumb and tweedle dumber running the offense into the ground.

Im still trying to figure out exactly what it is Sirriani does?

He doesnt call plays, he doesnt call defense, he stepped away from offensive game planning then said he stepped back in and got worse, he doesnt pick players or build rosters or develop talent. Seems to me all he does is yell at his players to get off the field, yell at his own fans, yell at other teams fans and talk about flowers.

I mean whats the point of him?

1 hour ago, Utebird said:

Yup, this season was wasted in a season where they could have made a serious run at a repeat.

Instead we get tweedle dumb and tweedle dumber running the offense into the ground.

Im still trying to figure out exactly what it is Sirriani does?

He doesnt call plays, he doesnt call defense, he stepped away from offensive game planning then said he stepped back in and got worse, he doesnt pick players or build rosters or develop talent. Seems to me all he does is yell at his players to get off the field, yell at his own fans, yell at other teams fans and talk about flowers.

I mean whats the point of him?

Maybe a puppet? Lol

This forum always finds a way to lower the standards...

Why not post AJ and Sirianni for Urlacher brought to the future from his prime years and a 3rd? Maybe Fitzgerald flown in from back it time???

It's every bit as likely.

Sir should have done the respectable thing like Doug did. Fall on his Sword with the OC.. Instead we have a HC who scapegoated the OC twice..