Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

The Eagles Message Board

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The Eagles should punt on the 2026 season, trade still-valuable players for future assets

Featured Replies

We're only five weeks into the 2026 NFL season, but it is already crystal clear that it is not going to be a special one for the Philadelphia Eagles. More bluntly, if you're a Birds fan, this season sucks. And, spoiler, it is only going to continue to suck.

However, Howie Roseman and the Eagles are in a position to choose their suckage path the rest of the season. 

• One is to try to compete for a division title in the craptastic NFC East, and if successful pretend that anything can happen in the playoffs. 

• The other is to maximize the value on likely soon-to-be outgoing players, and reset the roster for another long-term run.

The decision really shouldn't be all that hard. They should choose the reset.

The Eagles suck in a way that isn't likely fixable

Let's first establish how the Eagles suck this season.

To begin, as we have seen over the last decade, the Eagles have had their best seasons when their offensive line is dominant. The 2026 Eagles O-line, as currently constructed, is one of the worst in the NFL. Of course, the biggest domino to fall in the deconstruction of the line was the unexpected retirement of Lane Johnson last week.

There are all kinds of iterations of Eagles records when Johnson plays and when he doesn't. The one that I use is from 2016 on, after the Eagles fired Chip Kelly and began running a normal NFL offense. Since 2016, the Eagles are 98-43-1 (0.694) when Johnson plays, and 15-29 (0.341) when he doesn't. Whatever iteration you fancy, they're great when he plays, bad when he doesn't. They're 0-2 since he retired, and the offense has looked dysfunctional in both games.

But the offensive line's problems go well beyond the loss of Johnson. 

LG Landon Dickerson did not have a good training camp, and he had his worst game as a pro Week 1 against the Commanders. He subsequently went on injured reserve. The Eagles then moved starting C Cam Jurgens to LG, and Drew Kendall filled in at C. 

Jurgens then proceeded to play poorly at LG for three games before he reported concussion symptoms and was traded to the Baltimore Ravens. Meanwhile, Kendall sustained a knee injury and did not play Week 5 in London against the Jaguars.

In the Eagles' loss in London, Tyler Steen suffered a shoulder injury, but did return to the game.

The only Week 1 starting offensive lineman who was still standing at one point was Jordan Mailata, who described losing Johnson and Jurgens last week as "a week from hell."

Remember the 2020 season (4-11-1), when the Eagles had a new offensive line configuration nearly every week? Well, the 2026 season is shaping up to be a repeat of that.

 Week

LT 

LG 

C 

RG 

RT 

 1

Jordan Mailata 

Landon Dickerson 

Cam Jurgens 

Tyler Steen 

Lane Johnson 

 2

Jordan Mailata 

Cam Jurgens 

Drew Kendall 

Tyler Steen 

Lane Johnson 

 3

Jordan Mailata 

Cam Jurgens 

Drew Kendall 

Tyler Steen 

Lane Johnson 

 4

Jordan Mailata 

Cam Jurgens 

Drew Kendall 

Tyler Steen 

Markel Bell 

 5

Jordan Mailata 

Willie Lamkin 

Jake Majors 

Tyler Steen 

Markel Bell 

Spoiler: Week 6 will bring yet another new offensive line starting five.

Everything the Eagles do is dependent on great offensive line play. Without it, they have the following issues:

• They are a running football team, and they simply can't run it. It doesn't help that Saquon Barkley and Tank Bigsby are currently out with injuries — and the team lost Will Shipley with a foot injury during their loss in London — but on Sunday they rushed 18 times for 22 yards.

• The scheme that Sean Mannion is trying to install must have a functioning run game in order to marry the run and the pass. Without a successful run game, all the under center stuff and the play action stuff that was promised this summer is not going to be effective. And, in fact, the Eagles' offense has been horrendous when running play action from under center in the limited times they've even tried it this season.

• Jalen Hurts has plenty of strengths, but he is not a quarterback who is going to consistently get the ball out quickly. That's just not his game. And when he does not get good protection, he is forced into a style of play that is not a strength. To Hurts' credit, despite poor line play he put the Superman cape on in wins over bad opponents Weeks 1 and 2, but that was never a sustainable way to win, which was proven over the last three losses.

• The coaching staff has not figured out enough other creative ways to mask their various issues and get the offense jumpstarted. There haven't even been hints this season that they are capable of it.

The combination of the dismantled offensive line and the ineffective scheme that relies on it is very likely not fixable.

This ain't 2024

"We're early on in this season, and our job is to continue to find out what we do best, what we don't do quite as good, and try to attack that way," Nick Sirianni said last Wednesday. "I think quickly we forget that only a mere two years ago, in 2024, we sat in the same situation, and we made some adjustments and we got on a roll. I think sometimes we conveniently forget those things."

Sirianni is trying to play the role of the calm flight attendant during severe turbulence, as he should. And certainly, if you win a Super Bowl, pointing back to adversity that the team faced during that season is a natural reaction.

But... Stop, lol. This is not 2024.

Through five games during the 2024 season, the offense had gained 1,834 yards. They were averaging 366.8 yards per game. This season through five games... 1,311 yards, or 262.2 per game. That would be 104.6 fewer yards per game.

The 2024 offensive line was intact and playing well, and the Eagles had a run game that they could hang their hat on. They at least had an identity to lean into.

Following the Eagles' Week 4 loss to the Rams, Sirianni acknowledged that the team "obviously" did not yet have an identity.

But more troubling is that it's hard to figure out anything the offense does well. There's no identity now, and no identity on the horizon.

But they can still win the NFC East!

The Cowboys are 2-3, while the Giants and Commanders just tied in hilarious fashion on Sunday. The NFC East is wide open! 🥳🎉

So what?

The Eagles are unquestionably the most successful team in the NFC the last decade. They should be hunting for Lombardi trophies, not division title banners. Since they are not capable of winning a Super Bowl this season, based on all of the above, they should let the other three loser teams in the division compete for the right to get knocked out of the playoffs in the wildcard round.

What does a "reset" mean?

The Eagles still have a very talented defense to build around, and they are going to keep the Eagles in games all season, like they did for three quarters before they ran out of gas against the Rams, and for a complete game on Sunday against the Jaguars.

The suggestion here isn't to just tank the season and tear it all down. With the right moves, the Eagles can still compete as soon as next season. They don't have to go through a multi-season downturn.

But what they should do is trade players who aren't in the team's long-term plans for valuable future assets. And they should do it now, during the season, when it's typically a seller's market.

The following players make some level of sense to be traded during the season. We'll do this in alphabetical order:

• RB Saquon Barkley: Barkley still has juice, but turns 30 in February and has an expensive contract.

• LB Zack Baun: Baun is still playing at a Pro Bowl level, but he turns 30 in December and has a big contract. The Eagles also have capable young players at linebacker.

• OG Landon Dickerson: The Eagles somehow got a second-round pick for Jurgens. Dickerson could still have value for OL-desperate teams.

• TE Dallas Goedert: Goedert is still a good receiving tight end, but he turns 32 in January and is a free agent in 2027.

• iDL Moro Ojomo: Ojomo is going to cash in on free agency in 2027, and the Eagles likely won't be able to afford him.

• EDGE Nolan Smith: Teams around the league are always looking for help on the edge, and Smith could be a very good third guy for a contender. He becomes more expensive in 2027 on his fifth-year option, and is scheduled for free agency in 2028. The Eagles already committed a lot of resources toward Jonathan Greenard, and are likely to choose Jalyx Hunt over Smith long-term.

• CB Riq Woolen: Woolen was always sort of a one-year rental for the Eagles, and he has played very well so far this season. Teams are always in the market for good corners at the trade deadline.

To be clear, we're not suggesting that the Eagles can or will trade seven players in-season. And certainly, they shouldn't trade good players just for funsies. The value in return has to be worth it, with an in-season tax tacked on. The above seven still-valuable players just make the most sense if the Eagles were to try to stockpile future assets.

The Eagles currently have eight picks in 2027, and a bonanza of picks in 2028 (currently an extra 1 and an extra 2). By adding to those drafts, they can give themselves extraordinary flexibility to rebuild an aging roster without starting from scratch.

Let's be honest: The Eagles are already kind of resetting

When the Eagles traded Jurgens last week, they somehow got second- and fifth-round picks in return. That was an incredible return on investment for a player who was struggling, though notably at a position he shouldn't be playing. He played significantly better at center in the one game that he was there.

There's a sentiment that the Eagles would have done that deal in any season, no matter how good or bad the team is, because the trade compensation was just too good.

I couldn't disagree more.

Jurgens was a second-round pick. Roseman drafted him knowing that he would sit for a year. The coaching staff then invested a lot of time and effort grooming him to be Jason Kelce's successor. That venture was successful, as Jurgens was a Pro Bowl player (legitimately in 2024, not so much in 2025), and the starting center for a Super Bowl team. They also paid him well during the 2025 offseason, even though he was recovering from back surgery.

If the Eagles really thought that they had a good chance to compete for a Super Bowl this season, it's hard to believe that they would have traded a player they clearly like for a second-round pick, especially given all their offensive line issues they are already experiencing. Second-round picks are obviously valuable, but trading a starting offensive linemen in-season is a massive departure from Roseman's and the team's M.O.

The Jurgens trade was merely the first sign that the Eagles' front office sees where this season is headed.

Conclusion

The Eagles are going to get a long look at young players like Makai Lemon, Markel Bell, Drew Kendall, Willie Lampkin, and maybe at some point Eli Stowers. They'll get to see how those guys fit in long-term.

They also have an inordinate number of players who could have substantial value to other teams around the league, but who are also probably not long for the Eagles' roster. 

But most importantly, they have a general manager in Roseman who has extreme job security and can be bold about making drastic in-season moves for long-term gains; and an owner in Jeffrey Lurie who can see the big picture and prioritizes Super Bowls over short-term mediocrity. 

An awful 2015 season helped eventually lead to the team's first Super Bowl in 2017. An awful 2020 season helped lead to a Super Bowl appearance in 2022, and another eventual championship in 2024. A disastrous 2026 season really doesn't have to be a terrible thing.

The Eagles should (continue to) sell.

PhillyVoice
No image preview

The Eagles should punt on the 2026 season, trade still-va...

If they acknowledge the 2026 season is over, the Eagles can get trade value in return for some players not in their long-term plans.

Best article written about what this team should do. Sell Sell Sell

Time to shed salary and acquire picks to rebuild with young cheap and healthy players

Roseman and Lurie are not thinking that this season is lost.....5 games in with 12 to go. The eagles have had a ton of injuries, mostly on the offensive side of the ball and lost Johnson to retirement. And I think what Roseman is doing, is trying to find veteran offensive linemen who can come in and stabilize the offensive line. It's hard to pry good offensive linemen from anybody, so he has to be willing to overpay, similar to what the ravens did.

Plus, he has to weigh what eagles free agents he wants to sign vs what they could get on the open market.....if their comp pick value is better than anything they could get in a trade, he may not trade them. And they have to weigh just how much dead money they're going to carry.....They're at $81 million right now.....

The eagles will get some guys back from injury, but Dickerson is always going to be a high injury risk, and Bigsby won't be back for 6-8 weeks and Shipley is out for a while. Barkley is less effective with a struggling offensive line......so Howie's focus is going to be on linemen and backup RBs.

HOWEVER, They have a much bigger problem than the roster...What trades they make is secondary to the offensive coordinator and the offensive scheme. The eagles wasted 2 years with Johnson and Patullo, waiting for them to make the offense effective......The question is, did they learn anything from waiting and waiting?

As I said, I doubt Roseman and Lurie are thinking the season is lost.....I think Roseman is trying to patch the biggest positional problem right now. But the trade deadline is November 10th, and that's 4 games from now. If they continue to lose and show no improvement in the offense, only then can I see him making some trades to unload players.....However, if they start to show improvement offensively and stay competitive in the weak NFC east, then I think he rides out the season.

  • Author
1 hour ago, birdman#12 said:

Roseman and Lurie are not thinking that this season is lost.....5 games in with 12 to go. The eagles have had a ton of injuries, mostly on the offensive side of the ball and lost Johnson to retirement. And I think what Roseman is doing, is trying to find veteran offensive linemen who can come in and stabilize the offensive line. It's hard to pry good offensive linemen from anybody, so he has to be willing to overpay, similar to what the ravens did.

Plus, he has to weigh what eagles free agents he wants to sign vs what they could get on the open market.....if their comp pick value is better than anything they could get in a trade, he may not trade them. And they have to weigh just how much dead money they're going to carry.....They're at $81 million right now.....

The eagles will get some guys back from injury, but Dickerson is always going to be a high injury risk, and Bigsby won't be back for 6-8 weeks and Shipley is out for a while. Barkley is less effective with a struggling offensive line......so Howie's focus is going to be on linemen and backup RBs.

HOWEVER, They have a much bigger problem than the roster...What trades they make is secondary to the offensive coordinator and the offensive scheme. The eagles wasted 2 years with Johnson and Patullo, waiting for them to make the offense effective......The question is, did they learn anything from waiting and waiting?

As I said, I doubt Roseman and Lurie are thinking the season is lost.....I think Roseman is trying to patch the biggest positional problem right now. But the trade deadline is November 10th, and that's 4 games from now. If they continue to lose and show no improvement in the offense, only then can I see him making some trades to unload players.....However, if they start to show improvement offensively and stay competitive in the weak NFC east, then I think he rides out the season.

That's what will irk me..."staying competitive in a weak NFC east". I mean, a playoff game is always fun...but when you go into it knowing in the back of your mind we don't stand a chance (unless we get super lucky with the weakest possible matchup), there's no real fun in that. Then when it's over, you're left with pick 23 and needing to burn assets to trade up for a quality player or stay put and have lower odds of getting an impact player, etc. Not to mention, some notion of "false hope" because you made the playoffs.

3 minutes ago, EaglesAddict said:

That's what will irk me..."staying competitive in a weak NFC east". I mean, a playoff game is always fun...but when you go into it knowing in the back of your mind we don't stand a chance (unless we get super lucky with the weakest possible matchup), there's no real fun in that. Then when it's over, you're left with pick 23 and needing to burn assets to trade up for a quality player or stay put and have lower odds of getting an impact player, etc. Not to mention, some notion of "false hope" because you made the playoffs.

Generally I agree, but if, and that's a HUGE if, the eagles start to improve, and they go into the playoffs playing their best football in December, then the possibility is that they make a run.

The problem with that is, Howie has to make that determination over the next 4 weeks before the trade deadline if he is going to sell off. They have the Panthers and then 3 straight NFC East games.....so he has to take it one game at a time.......But the offense has given no reason to believe they are going to improve....they've gotten worse with each game.

So I think it all hinges on the offensive improvement which is why I think he's trying to find some veteran offensive lineman to stabilize this line. I realize he traded Jurgens....but I think they felt confident in Kendall taking over center and the return was too good to turn down.

A team this horribly coached on offense and with a mediocre roster isn't going to make a playoff run

Just now, birdman#12 said:

Generally I agree, but if, and that's a HUGE if, the eagles start to improve, and they go into the playoffs playing their best football in December, then the possibility is that they make a run.

The problem with that is, Howie has to make that determination over the next 4 weeks before the trade deadline if he is going to sell off. They have the Panthers and then 3 straight NFC East games.....so he has to take it one game at a time.......But the offense has given no reason to believe they are going to improve....they've gotten worse with each game.

So I think it all hinges on the offensive improvement which is why I think he's trying to find some veteran offensive lineman to stabilize this line.

1 hour ago, weko said:

A team this horribly coached on offense and with a mediocre roster isn't going to make a playoff run

It's not a mediocre roster......that's just an overreaction. They are generally considered by many sources to be one of the most talented NFL rosters. Are they playing poorly, yes. Have they been outcoached, yes. What we've seen is a talented roster handicapped by poor coaching decisions, an inexperienced OC again, more injuries than they usually get and some young guys who have not played well.

So the question is, Can Sirianni learn anything now that he has to, can Mannion improve at all, can the guys coming back from injury make a difference and can guys like Campbell, Makuba, Lemon, Smith, Hunt, Steen, Stowers, Morris and Robinson develop their game enough to be better contributors.

It's too easy to knee jerk and say none this can happen, even if it seems impossible. But usually 6-8 games into a season, young guys and new OC start to really improve or they don't. If that doesn't happen, they'll have a losing season. We're 5 games in and it's not looking good......but 12 games can change a lot of things...

Gotta love how these armchair GMs gonna tell Howie what he should do.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.