Posted January 13, 20232 yr Five first team all pros in six years. SB ring. Captain. Heart and soul of this team for the better part of a decade. Tons of charity work off the field. All around Philly personality that we all love. Oh and his podcast is hilarious. He's on mine. Dawk has always been my absolute favorite Eagle. I grew up watching him. I never thought someone else might take that title for me. I think it's happened.
January 13, 20232 yr Kelce and Dawk are 1A and 1B. Can't go wrong with either one of them, they're both legends.
January 13, 20232 yr 7 minutes ago, downundermike said: Chuck, Kelce, Dawk and .............................................. Hurts, obviously
January 13, 20232 yr 13 minutes ago, downundermike said: Chuck, Kelce, Dawk and .............................................. Depends on "how many" if it's just 4 then tough question....but I view it as similar to the Eagles "Wall/HOF".
January 13, 20232 yr Author 21 minutes ago, downundermike said: Chuck, Kelce, Dawk and .............................................. Reggie?
January 13, 20232 yr I'm 51 ... in my lifetime it's Reggie, Dawk, Kelce, Peters. Gotta have some longevity.
January 14, 20232 yr Author 19 minutes ago, Rey said: I'm 51 ... in my lifetime it's Reggie, Dawk, Kelce, Peters. Gotta have some longevity. Peters forfeited his spot for me when he put on that disgusting cowboy uniform.
January 14, 20232 yr 47 minutes ago, Uscg-green said: Peters forfeited his spot for me when he put on that disgusting cowboy uniform. Yeah, and the cash grab for moving to LT from LG his last year, then disappearing like a bum. I don't resent football players trying to maximize their bank, but that knocked him off my all-time Eagles' greats list.
January 14, 20232 yr 57 minutes ago, Uscg-green said: Peters forfeited his spot for me when he put on that disgusting cowboy uniform. I hear ya on that ... but he still did a lot for this team while he was in our colors. Reggie left, Dawk left ... I just try to judge what they did while they were here. Once they leave it's ultimately about paychecks, I can't fault them for collecting one where they can.
January 14, 20232 yr 38 minutes ago, xxeaglesfanxx said: Reggie White and Brian Dawkins are definitely on their. So is Chuck
January 14, 20232 yr 3 hours ago, Captain F said: White Kelce Dawkins Bednarick Probably the only team in the league that doesn’t have a QB on their Mount Rushmore… but I’m good with that Dolphins - Marino Patriots - Brady Jets - Namath Bills - Kelly Titans - Mcnair Texans - Probably Watson Jaguars - Brunell Colts - Manning Steelers - Roethlisberger or Bradshaw Ravens - Flacco? Browns - Graham Bengals - Burrow already? Chargers - Rivers or Fours Raiders - ……. Chiefs - Mahomes already Broncos - Elway Seahawks - Wilson 9ers - Young Cardinals - ….. Rams - Warner Vikings - Tarkenton? Packers - Rodgers Lions - Stafford Bears - …… Falcons - Ryan or Vick? Saints - Brees Panthers - Cam Bucs - Brady already Cowboys - Staubach Giants - Eli Commandeers - Baugh So the definite no’s are us, Chicago, Arizona, LV? Do they throw Plunkett a bone?
January 14, 20232 yr 1 hour ago, Aerolithe_Lion said: Probably the only team in the league that doesn’t have a QB on their Mount Rushmore… but I’m good with that Dolphins - Marino Patriots - Brady Jets - Namath Bills - Kelly Titans - Mcnair Texans - Probably Watson Jaguars - Brunell Colts - Manning Steelers - Roethlisberger or Bradshaw Ravens - Flacco? Browns - Graham Bengals - Burrow already? Chargers - Rivers or Fours Raiders - ……. Chiefs - Mahomes already Broncos - Elway Seahawks - Wilson 9ers - Young Cardinals - ….. Rams - Warner Vikings - Tarkenton? Packers - Rodgers Lions - Stafford Bears - …… Falcons - Ryan or Vick? Saints - Brees Panthers - Cam Bucs - Brady already Cowboys - Staubach Giants - Eli Commandeers - Baugh So the definite no’s are us, Chicago, Arizona, LV? Do they throw Plunkett a bone? Idk man McNabb was better than a lot of those guys you have listed for other teams. Also what about Warner for Arizona?
January 14, 20232 yr Stabler for the Raiders Montana way ahead of Young for the 49ers. Dude won four Super Bowls and is arguably the greatest QB of all time not named Brady.
January 14, 20232 yr 1 hour ago, Bwestbrook36 said: Idk man McNabb was better than a lot of those guys you have listed for other teams. Also what about Warner for Arizona? It’s not a best QB’s list, it’s a best 4 of your franchise. Remember Baltimore has only been around since ‘96; hard to find 4 who did more than Flacco. Reed, Lewis, Ogden.… do you put a kicker over a SB champion, decade-starting QB? No way. Jamal Lewis? Hmmm…. I wouldn’t. That’s the circumstance of whether a QB or not. Or Watson. Does Houston even have 4 guys worth bringing up? Watt and Andre Johnson definitely. Anyone else at all? Hopkins for part of his career? Watson was the alltime leader in completion percentage when he left. After him it may be another QB in Matt Shaub… Warner for Arizona is tough, he was there 5 years and only started 3. One was a losing season. Larry Wilson, Night Train Lane, Jackie Smith, and that Fitzgerald guy are alltime players at their respective positions. Aenes Williams is HoF, Dan Dierdorf is HoF, Pat Peterson made 8 consecutive pro bowls, Jim Hart started 180 games… Warner may not even be top 10.
January 14, 20232 yr 28 minutes ago, Aerolithe_Lion said: It’s not a best QB’s list, it’s a best 4 of your franchise. Remember Baltimore has only been around since ‘96; hard to find 4 who did more than Flacco. Reed, Lewis, Ogden.… do you put a kicker over a SB champion, decade-starting QB? No way. Jamal Lewis? Hmmm…. I wouldn’t. That’s the circumstance of whether a QB or not. Or Watson. Does Houston even have 4 guys worth bringing up? Watt and Andre Johnson definitely. Anyone else at all? Hopkins for part of his career? Watson was the alltime leader in completion percentage when he left. After him it may be another QB in Matt Shaub… Warner for Arizona is tough, he was there 5 years and only started 3. One was a losing season. Larry Wilson, Night Train Lane, Jackie Smith, and that Fitzgerald guy are alltime players at their respective positions. Aenes Williams is HoF, Dan Dierdorf is HoF, Pat Peterson made 8 consecutive pro bowls, Jim Hart started 180 games… Warner may not even be top 10. Fair enough, I know it's not a best QBs list I just thought a lot of those teams had better players listed than the QBs listed for their mt Rushmore. So I was basically saying that McNabb was better then a lot of them and shouldn't he be considered on our mt Rushmore? 5nfc championship games a super bowl appearance and has most of our passing records.
January 14, 20232 yr 3 minutes ago, Bwestbrook36 said: Fair enough, I know it's not a best QBs list I just thought a lot of those teams had better players listed than the QBs listed for their mt Rushmore. So I was basically saying that McNabb was better then a lot of them and shouldn't he be considered on our mt Rushmore? 5nfc championship games a super bowl appearance and has most of our passing records. But then does that make him better than the greatest Dlineman who ever lived? A QB who got 4th in offensive player of the year one time vs a center who’s been all-pro 5 times? A LT with 9 consecutive pro bowls (minus 2012 when he missed the whole season)? A safety whos one of 3 DB’s ever with 99 Sacks+FF’s+Ints? Chuck Bednarik who had even more all-pros than Kelce and did it at 2 different positions? Mcnabb is easily the best QB in eagles history, but his individual accomplishments pale in comparison
January 14, 20232 yr 7 minutes ago, Aerolithe_Lion said: But then does that make him better than the greatest Dlineman who ever lived? A QB who got 4th in offensive player of the year one time vs a center who’s been all-pro 5 times? A LT with 9 consecutive pro bowls (minus 2012 when he missed the whole season)? A safety whos one of 3 DB’s ever with 99 Sacks+FF’s+Ints? Chuck Bednarik who had even more all-pros than Kelce and did it at 2 different positions? Mcnabb is easily the best QB in eagles history, but his individual accomplishments pale in comparison All great points, I withdrawal my argument lol
January 14, 20232 yr He was already there for me. He’s now a lock for the NFL HOF with this last all-pro. He’ll be a super lock if he gets that second ring.
Create an account or sign in to comment