Posted January 22, 20232 yr If the Eagles win their second Super Bowl is Howie Roseman a Hall of Fame Executive? He would have won two championships within five years with two different head coaches and two different starting quarterbacks. He would be the only GM to ever have done that especially within that short of a timeframe. All in all we have come a long way from wanting to put Howie back in the basement.
January 22, 20232 yr 11 minutes ago, EazyEaglez said: If the Eagles win their second Super Bowl is Howie Roseman a Hall of Fame Executive? He would have won two championships within five years with two different head coaches and two different starting quarterbacks. He would be the only GM to ever have done that especially within that short of a timeframe. All in all we have come a long way from wanting to put Howie back in the basement. I would say so. As you stated, he would be the only GM to have ever done this. Years ago, I too, wanted him gone for some mistakes he has made (the reprehensible Jalen Reagor, JJ Whiteside, etc) but he has made up for these mistakes very impressively....
January 22, 20232 yr 2 hours ago, EazyEaglez said: If the Eagles win their second Super Bowl is Howie Roseman a Hall of Fame Executive? He would have won two championships within five years with two different head coaches and two different starting quarterbacks. He would be the only GM to ever have done that especially within that short of a timeframe. All in all we have come a long way from wanting to put Howie back in the basement. Raiders GM Al Davis: ‘76 Madden Stabler, ‘80 Flores Plunkett But otherwise I agree with everything else you said. Don’t forget 5 division titles with 4 different pro bowl QBs, that’s also impressive from a talent acquisition standpoint
January 22, 20232 yr 1 hour ago, EazyEaglez said: If the Eagles win their second Super Bowl is Howie Roseman a Hall of Fame Executive? He would have won two championships within five years with two different head coaches and two different starting quarterbacks. He would be the only GM to ever have done that especially within that short of a timeframe. All in all we have come a long way from wanting to put Howie back in the basement. If the didn’t choke so badly they could have gone to 4 straight super bowls and 5 in 8 years. That’s dynasty numbers right there. But I’m just happy they got their one eventually and hopefully they get another this year.
January 22, 20232 yr I've trashed Roseman A LOT pre 2017 and he has made me eat my words... He really has done a great job the last 5 to 6 years...
January 22, 20232 yr Yeah I speculated about this earlier in the year. I think it would make him a hall of fame executive.
January 22, 20232 yr If he can find a way to keep this team at a near level starting next year, then yeah he's the goat. Tall task, however, with all of the high dollar contracts we have and the talent we'll surely lose. I expect at least 5 new defensive starters next season.
January 22, 20232 yr 3 hours ago, EazyEaglez said: If the Eagles win their second Super Bowl is Howie Roseman a Hall of Fame Executive? He would have won two championships within five years with two different head coaches and two different starting quarterbacks. He would be the only GM to ever have done that especially within that short of a timeframe. All in all we have come a long way from wanting to put Howie back in the basement. Him and Dave Gettleman make a hell of team
January 22, 20232 yr 4 hours ago, EazyEaglez said: If the Eagles win their second Super Bowl is Howie Roseman a Hall of Fame Executive? He would have won two championships within five years with two different head coaches and two different starting quarterbacks. He would be the only GM to ever have done that especially within that short of a timeframe. All in all we have come a long way from wanting to put Howie back in the basement. I think he'd have a very good claim to it, yes. This is in some way similar, but other ways not so, but harken back to Joe Gibbs and the Redskins of the 80's. I had a front row seat to that period of time in Redskins history, since I lived so close to RFK and had two brothers (and my father), as Redskins fans. But Gibbs won the Super Bowl in (strike shortened season) 1982 with Theismann under center. 5 years later, in 1987 (another strike shortened season) he won the Super Bowl with Doug Williams under center (also count Jay Schroeder as the regular season QB for that season). Not quite apples to apples, Gibbs was a heck of a coach and got into the Hall based on a lot of factors other than those two Super Bowls. But without them, I don't know if he gets in. So if the Eagles win multiple Super Bowls under Howie, and the way Howie does business, I think he deserves serious consideration for the Hall.
January 22, 20232 yr What is this 2nd SB you speak of? We got a NFCCG to win 1st!!! I'm sticking with the Eagles mentality... 1 game at a time don't look ahead when you need to be concentrating on the journey. LFG!!!
January 22, 20232 yr Author 33 minutes ago, Portyansky said: What is this 2nd SB you speak of? We got a NFCCG to win 1st!!! I'm sticking with the Eagles mentality... 1 game at a time don't look ahead when you need to be concentrating on the journey. LFG!!! I wrote if bud, and I’m not trying to jinx it, but I’m a fan and not a player. They can think one game at a time. 😂
January 22, 20232 yr Author 2 hours ago, b_west3 said: If he can find a way to keep this team at a near level starting next year, then yeah he's the goat. Tall task, however, with all of the high dollar contracts we have and the talent we'll surely lose. I expect at least 5 new defensive starters next season. Most times this goes in cycles. When was the last time we saw a back to back SB winner? It isn’t something easy to accomplish, but when it comes to what makes someone HOF worthy yes SB wins matter, but you also have to continue with the full body of work and even though most of us have had some negative feelings towards Howie in the past, (myself included) the truth is under his watch the Eagles have been much better than we give him credit for. 3 hours ago, Bwestbrook36 said: Jinxy!!!!!!! Come on man! You don’t believe in that superstition stuff. 😂
January 22, 20232 yr If he wins the SB then Hurts will turn out to be one of the best draft steals of all time...making up for the two horrible misses he had with Reagor and JJaw.
January 22, 20232 yr 3 hours ago, EazyEaglez said: I wrote if bud, and I’m not trying to jinx it, but I’m a fan and not a player. They can think one game at a time. 😂 We are an extension of the team....
January 22, 20232 yr Author 18 minutes ago, Portyansky said: We are an extension of the team.... If we had our say they would never lose.
January 22, 20232 yr 1 minute ago, EazyEaglez said: If we had our say they would never lose. According to some people here. They wanted us to lose games in the season 🤣🤦♂️
January 22, 20232 yr Author 3 minutes ago, Portyansky said: According to some people here. They wanted us to lose games in the season 🤣🤦♂️ Good point. 😂🤣😂
January 23, 20232 yr We all know what I thought about Howie. I wanted him gone and I was heavy on that side. But he's turned it around and I've changed my opinion on him. And I'm happy to say I was wrong. That said, he did this before. He created a SB winning roster and then made poor decisions afterwards that led to the team regressing for 3 straight years. And he's going to have to pull off more miracles after this year no matter that happens from here on out. But he's earned the right to have that opportunity to again rebuild and restock this roster.
January 24, 20232 yr 2 hours ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said: We all know what I thought about Howie. I wanted him gone and I was heavy on that side. But he's turned it around and I've changed my opinion on him. And I'm happy to say I was wrong. That said, he did this before. He created a SB winning roster and then made poor decisions afterwards that led to the team regressing for 3 straight years. And he's going to have to pull off more miracles after this year no matter that happens from here on out. But he's earned the right to have that opportunity to again rebuild and restock this roster. If he is gonna get us to super bowl every 5-6 yrs he can do whatever the F he wants.
January 24, 20232 yr On 1/22/2023 at 8:38 AM, EazyEaglez said: If the Eagles win their second Super Bowl is Howie Roseman a Hall of Fame Executive? He would have won two championships within five years with two different head coaches and two different starting quarterbacks. He would be the only GM to ever have done that especially within that short of a timeframe. All in all we have come a long way from wanting to put Howie back in the basement. What do you mean if? Eagles going to defeat the 49ers and Patrick is injured (high ankle) and Slay will shut down Chase. Eagles winning it.
January 24, 20232 yr Author 15 hours ago, JournalistMic said: What do you mean if? Eagles going to defeat the 49ers and Patrick is injured (high ankle) and Slay will shut down Chase. Eagles winning it. Didn’t want to be so presumptuous. People have their superstitions. 😂
January 24, 20232 yr If they win a second Super Bowl with a completely different roster that he rebuilt from scratch… yeah, I’d say so. Who is even left from the last Super Bowl? BG, Kelce, Seumalo,Lane, Cox, Elliott are all I can think of.
January 24, 20232 yr 16 hours ago, JournalistMic said: What do you mean if? Eagles going to defeat the 49ers and Patrick is injured (high ankle) and Slay will shut down Chase. Eagles winning it. Don’t think the Mahomes injury matters much. Burrow owns KC, I had them winning even with a healthy Mahomes. 17 hours ago, Bwestbrook36 said: If he is gonna get us to super bowl every 5-6 yrs he can do whatever the F he wants. Yep. If he can get the Eagles a Super Bowl every 5 years, I don’t give a F about the four years in between.
Create an account or sign in to comment