February 14Feb 14 21 hours ago, Utebird said: Quick was on his last broken legs with randall, randall didnt play with carmichael. And while Arkansas Fred was good doesnt really matter when your o line sucks and your starting RB is anthony toney, heath sherman or a broken down herschel walker. Not to mention people act like mcnabb had pinkston and thrash for 10 years, his last nfccg he had desean, kevin curtis was good for a year with 1200 yards, brown and stallworth was solid then the year he did have TO mcnabb choked in the biggest game then blew it up the next year because hes a clown. You're right, he didn't play with Carmichael. And no one's saying he had "Trash" and Pinkston for 10 years, but they were there for the 4 in a row NFCCG's (Thrash was there for 3, Pink for all 4). T.O. was only on the team for the one we won, and he didn't even play in the game. You really gonna hype up Kevin Curtis, a player that had 1 good season??? You also bring up Stallworth, who was a #3 WR. LOL, I think you might be the "clown. It's cool how you make excuses for Cunningham, but bring up avg players and scrubs to point out why McNabb was a choker, lol.
February 14Feb 14 19 hours ago, Devaster said: The 2024 OLine is one of the best OLines ever. And considering we lost Kelce to retirement last season that is impressive. And Barkley had an all-time great season. I don't think the 2017 offense is comparable at all. There wasn't any defense in the 2017 SB outside of a couple plays by the Eagles to shift the balance and win the game. I mean in 2017 the Eagles were 3rd in scoring offense and 7th in yards. 2024 they were 7th in both so I would say they were comparable.
February 14Feb 14 3 hours ago, MF POON said: You're right, he didn't play with Carmichael. And no one's saying he had "Trash" and Pinkston for 10 years, but they were there for the 4 in a row NFCCG's (Thrash was there for 3, Pink for all 4). T.O. was only on the team for the one we won, and he didn't even play in the game. You really gonna hype up Kevin Curtis, a player that had 1 good season??? You also bring up Stallworth, who was a #3 WR. LOL, I think you might be the "clown. It's cool how you make excuses for Cunningham, but bring up avg players and scrubs to point out why McNabb was a choker, lol. Cunningham was a choker too but mcnabb had more throughout his career from coaching to O line to RB. Dont remember calling you a clown but its all good
February 14Feb 14 2 hours ago, Utebird said: Cunningham was a choker too but mcnabb had more throughout his career from coaching to O line to RB. Dont remember calling you a clown but its all good You called McNabb a clown, so I jokingly said maybe you are. Didn't mean to offend so apologies. We can agree to disagree, as it's not even that big of a deal. Enjoy us being champs!
February 15Feb 15 1 hour ago, MF POON said: You called McNabb a clown, so I jokingly said maybe you are. Didn't mean to offend so apologies. We can agree to disagree, as it's not even that big of a deal. Enjoy us being champs! Gotcha, sorry I couldnt remember exactly what I wrote... Mcnabb was a clown though . Randall was a Diva. I prefer Hurts, even keel.💪🏆
February 15Feb 15 I misread the title and thought this was "best 3 Eagles players ever,” and I see people putting Foles in there. I almost punched the dog.
February 15Feb 15 34 minutes ago, hputenis said: I misread the title and thought this was "best 3 Eagles players ever,” and I see people putting Foles in there. I almost punched the dog. My wife might punch my dog tonight ...
February 15Feb 15 22 minutes ago, Utebird said: My wife might punch my dog tonight ... Was this an attempt at a sex joke? Or is your dog truly in danger?
February 15Feb 15 15 minutes ago, hputenis said: Was this an attempt at a sex joke? Or is your dog truly in danger? Only if she( my dog) is allergic to Peanut butter ...🤔
February 15Feb 15 10 minutes ago, Utebird said: Only if she( my dog) is allergic to Peanut butter ...🤔 Have you been sneaking into the catnip and robitussin again?
February 16Feb 16 On 2/14/2025 at 11:50 AM, ManchesterEagle said: I mean in 2017 the Eagles were 3rd in scoring offense and 7th in yards. 2024 they were 7th in both so I would say they were comparable. Comparing rankings between years isn't all that meaningful. There are way too many factors that are specific to that season. This year's team was one of the most dominant ever. I don't think they caught the Chiefs on an off day like I have seen some commentary out there. Everything came together this year for an all-time team. Nothing against the 2017 team, but this team was different. And the feeling was different. I had a feeling they were going to blow out the Chiefs.
February 16Feb 16 Cunningham will always be my favorite. He changed the way I look at the QB position in the NFL. But I am constantly adding players to my all-time favorites list. Right now, my top 3 are: Hurts, Pickett, and McKee. Those are the three I am still rooting for on the field.
February 16Feb 16 Hurts Mcnabb ————— these two are very clearly our best QBs then Cunningham/Jaws Foles started 2.5 seasons and you’re putting him on the list for 2 games. Cmon now; 2 games doesn’t eclipse 10 years of Jaws or whatever it was of Cunningham
February 16Feb 16 8 minutes ago, Aerolithe_Lion said: Foles started 2.5 seasons and you’re putting him on the list for 2 games. Cmon now; 2 games doesn’t eclipse 10 years of Jaws or whatever it was of Cunningham I think a magical SB run beats that.
February 16Feb 16 1 minute ago, Infam said: I think a magical SB run beats that. Jaws made a SB too. The difference between Foles being #2 for a lot of people and not making the list at all may very well boil down to whether or not BG beats that guard. An alltime moment for Eagles history, but not an alltime eagles career. This is hyperbole
February 16Feb 16 1 minute ago, Aerolithe_Lion said: Jaws made a SB too. The difference between Foles being #2 for a lot of people and not making the list at all may very well boil down to whether or not BG beats that guard. An alltime moment for Eagles history, but not an alltime eagles career. This is hyperbole Alltime Eagles Legend QB imo. Don't care about his career.
February 16Feb 16 Mine are: 1) Cunningham 2) McNabb 3) Hurts Hurts will undoubtedly end up number 1 -- to climb to 3rd after just four seasons starting is pretty amazing. Foles won 25 games as an Eagles starter, including playoffs. I love the guy for winning our first SB, but come on, get serious.
February 16Feb 16 20 hours ago, Devaster said: Comparing rankings between years isn't all that meaningful. There are way too many factors that are specific to that season. This year's team was one of the most dominant ever. I don't think they caught the Chiefs on an off day like I have seen some commentary out there. Everything came together this year for an all-time team. Nothing against the 2017 team, but this team was different. And the feeling was different. I had a feeling they were going to blow out the Chiefs. Look I’m not saying the 2024 team isn’t better. The D was definitely better this year (particularly the corners and having an all pro linebacker) But for me the offense was definitely comparable. They didn’t have Barkley but the O-Line was great and they were very deep at the skill positions. It’s no coincidence that Wentz and Foles both looked elite that year.
Create an account or sign in to comment