June 11, 20214 yr I think the point by the OP was to get different viewpoints and engage in some conversation this no Reggie and no Jerome. I’m sure both would easily be on nearly everyone’s list.
June 11, 20214 yr 4 hours ago, EazyEaglez said: I think the point by the OP was to get different viewpoints and engage in some conversation this no Reggie and no Jerome. I’m sure both would easily be on nearly everyone’s list. I'm not playing the OP's sick games
June 11, 20214 yr 19 minutes ago, Bwestbrook36 said: I'm not playing the OP's sick games I hear you. Notice I didn’t make a list either. 😂
June 14, 20214 yr Original poster is obviously anti-deadist. What about, Who are the all-time greatest *white* D-line players?
June 16, 20214 yr On 6/14/2021 at 5:33 AM, Big___Al said: Original poster is obviously anti-deadist. What about, Who are the all-time greatest *white* D-line players? Reggie White, obviously.
June 30, 20214 yr As noted above, if you're assembling a best Eagles of all time front 4 it's: Reggie Fletch Jerome Simmons The only debate is if you want to discuss Cole in lieu of Simmons, but I believe Simmons wins out.
June 30, 20214 yr 13 minutes ago, eagle45 said: All time best DL…no one who has hit 10 sacks in a season is eligible. Now go. Did Andy Harmon ever have 10 in a year? If not, he's an obvious choice.
June 30, 20214 yr 12 minutes ago, FranklinFldEBUpper said: Did Andy Harmon ever have 10 in a year? If not, he's an obvious choice. Andy Harmon had sack seasons of 11, 11.5 and 9. He is one of the most criminally underrated Interior pass rushers of all time.
June 30, 20214 yr 46 minutes ago, hoosierdaddy said: As noted above, if you're assembling a best Eagles of all time front 4 it's: Reggie Fletch Jerome Simmons The only debate is if you want to discuss Cole in lieu of Simmons, but I believe Simmons wins out. Cole was good but Simmons was on another level, Simmons had 3 seasons in a row with 100 plus tackles and two more with 96 and 98 Coles season high in tackles was 77. Simmons also led the league in sacks one year with 19 and while Cole has more sacks with the eagles than Simmons, 85.5 to 76.5 Simmons has more career sacks with 122.5 to Coles 95.5 Not to mention Simmons has 2 ints with the eagles and 3 total tds as well and was an all pro Twice which Cole never was.
June 30, 20214 yr 33 minutes ago, eagle45 said: All time best DL…no one who has hit 10 sacks in a season is eligible. Now go. Mike Mamula. Charlie Johnson Darwin Walker. Carl Hairston.
June 30, 20214 yr 49 minutes ago, Utebird said: Cole was good but Simmons was on another level, Simmons had 3 seasons in a row with 100 plus tackles and two more with 96 and 98 Coles season high in tackles was 77. Simmons also led the league in sacks one year with 19 and while Cole has more sacks with the eagles than Simmons, 85.5 to 76.5 Simmons has more career sacks with 122.5 to Coles 95.5 Not to mention Simmons has 2 ints with the eagles and 3 total tds as well and was an all pro Twice which Cole never was. Yep -- good points. I'm firmly in the Simmons over Cole camp after you frame it up.
June 30, 20214 yr 2 hours ago, Utebird said: Mike Mamula. Charlie Johnson Darwin Walker. Carl Hairston. I kinda remember Hairston having something like 15 sacks one year.
June 30, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, FranklinFldEBUpper said: I kinda remember Hairston having something like 15 sacks one year. I know Harrison did, maybe Hairston did in a season before they tracked sacks but after they started he never had a season with 10 sacks or more. I find it odd that the NFL didn't track sacks as an official stat until mid 80s???
July 9, 20214 yr On 6/30/2021 at 9:43 AM, Utebird said: Mike Mamula. Charlie Johnson Darwin Walker. Carl Hairston. I had Graham, Corey Simon, Walker, Mamula.
July 9, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, eagle45 said: I had Graham, Corey Simon, Walker, Mamula. Corey Simon was great as a rookie, I mean hell he got a sack in his first ever defensive snap and finished the year with 9.5 but after that he got fat and was useless. If he could have maintained his rookie season play he'd be a multiple pro bowler Instead he ended up as just a fat waste of space👎 That why I picked Charlie Johnson over him. I agree about graham though I amend my pick.
July 19, 20214 yr Get BG on this list. He's gotten better with age and carved himself out a damn good career in Philly. Longevity and SB winning plays count for a lot.
July 20, 20214 yr 15 hours ago, Procus said: Get BG on this list. He's gotten better with age and carved himself out a damn good career in Philly. Longevity and SB winning plays count for a lot. DE - Reggie 1987 DT -Jerome Brown 1991 DT - Cox 2015 DE - BG 2017 I feel this is probably too highly biased towards the recent past though.
July 21, 20214 yr 21 hours ago, wyote said: DE - Reggie 1987 DT -Jerome Brown 1991 DT - Cox 2015 DE - BG 2017 I feel this is probably too highly biased towards the recent past though. Unfortunately the Eagles don't have such a fruitful history, unless you take into consideration the pre-superbowl era.
Create an account or sign in to comment