Jump to content

Calm down, the Eagles aren't making the playoffs


Recommended Posts

Calm down, the Eagles aren't making the playoffs

Sure, they've been better the last month, but let's not forget what got them in this position in the first place...

Eytan Shander
PhillyVoice Contributor



Philadelphia Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni.

Let's get one thing clear: the Philadelphia Eagles are not making the playoffs.

It seems Philly fans have lost their sense of beginnings once again, forgetting why it’s taken ten weeks for us to talk about the postseason. It’s not their fault — most are stuck on social media where speaking in absolutes and insulting those who disagree are the only things truly rewarded. Others grew up with decades of AM sports talk radio, goaded by hosts into either loving or hating whatever the forced general topic of the day was.

It's like they've been brainwashed into forgetting that we were all right, right that the staff was (and is) incompetent. New coaches came in trying to reinvent the wheel – or create a new prototype. We sat there and yelled and screamed, "Run the ball!" and still saw the opposite week after week.

Look at the think pieces that followed, the ones calling for the head coach or DC’s job. Howie Roseman was under fire, so was Jeff Lurie. The only thing that’s changed? A commitment to running the football — ya know, the same thing fans and those in the media have been clamoring for since the start of the season. Finally, after nearly a half season of losing, they made a change. And suddenly, the players are making plays — it’s been the story of the last month.

But let's not give too much credit to the coaches. If anything, Nick Sirianni and his staff appear to be just not getting in the way. The run plays are basic in asking the five offensive linemen to put hands on guys and open up holes. The Eagles have a talented run OL – even when it’s not fully healthy. Jordan Howard is running down field off open holes, Boston Scott is using his speed in open space – created by those holes. And Kenneth Gainwell… well, two out three ain’t bad. Miles Sanders, who has been out the last several weeks was never afforded this benefit, but perhaps could be if he returns against the Saints on Sunday.

Nothing exotic is happing in the run game; there’s just an actual commitment to it. We simply see players making plays, just like in the passing game. When Jalen Hurts looked incredibly sharp in the first half against the Broncos, were the Eagles running some intricate offense that was scheming people open? No, it was DeVonta Smith using his incredible hands and route-running ability. It was Quez Watkins just flat out beating guys with his speed. And when he had the chances, Hurts threw Smith open – something that we saw him struggle with earlier in the season — or simply trusted his rookie receiver enough to go up and make a contested catch. Is that coming from some extended coaching? No, it’s coming with reps.

The offense is getting better because it’s relying less on the coaching staff and more on the players. Yes, it’s "changed” in that they are doing exactly what the entire world knew they should be doing. They look "better” because they finally decided to help the young QB out with a run game.

Yet, here we are. Cue the think pieces on how the Eagles were doubted or how the "haters” came out early only to be proven wrong. The same people writing those, tweeting that theory, or just having that conversation at the barber shop, are forgetting why the Eagles are currently on the outside looking in. Maybe you forgot too.

The refusal to adhere to some of the most fundamental elements of the game cost the Eagles the first six weeks of their season. It’s going to cost them the playoffs too, even with an easier schedule awaiting them down the stretch. But by refusing to praise someone for not continuing to make the same basic mistake, I’ll be labeled negative or for those with far less ability to see nuance, a hater.

It’s ridiculous if you truly look at what’s going on, especially after the players beat up on Denver. Part of the built-in expectations of all this post-season talk is that the offensive coaches are getting better. There is little mention about how damaging the first month and a half were, and how they stunted growth of an offense and its players.

The recent success of the Eagles offense should be credited to Hurts, the offensive line, Smith, and a bunch of running backs. They were simply helped by the coach not calling as many pass plays and actually giving them a chance. 

Most people don’t have the ability to see past their worldview. It’s just easier to already know about someone based on what they tweet, or how they look, or what kind of hair they have, as opposed to listening to what they have to say. The same applies here. People can’t discern between valid criticism of a coaching staff that refused to budge in their attempt to recreate offense, versus praise of players who moved the ball and opened holes on the ground.

If you want to praise a coaching staff on the Eagles this year, start and end with the special teams and Mike Clay.


Dolphins vs. Jets — OVER 44.5

This total is insanely low, and you should pounce all over it. The Jets defense is absolutely atrocious and can’t stop anyone – including Miami. This isn’t about the Dolphins keeping it close or the Jets losing bad, it’s just about how many points get scored overall in Jets games. From week 4 through 10, only one total hit in the 40s! If you want an extra push to the over, just look at how well Tua played against the Ravens and how aggressive their defense was against Lamar Jackson. Joe Flacco starting for the Jets means a bunch of sacks and possibly a pick-six. We don’t need it. This game may go over at the half.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

For the record, did not read.  Only posted this because it represents a different POV.  

IMO the Eagles are definitely in the mix for a playoff spot.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Didn’t read either, I’m just happy that Eagles are still playing meaningful football after Thanksgiving, if they win Sunday things are going to become interesting.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just a negative POV......that's his opinion.  But his whole argument was that they were bad in the beginning of the year, they will revert to being bad as the season goes on.  Which is ridiculous.  

Development and improvement sometimes happens game to game, but usually happens over the course of a season.  This idiot apparently can't understand that.

He says the eagles struggled early because they ignored some of the fundamental aspects of the game. But they fixed that......improvement.

Hurts had too much put on his shoulders early......fixed that.....improvement.

I don't know if the eagles will make the playoffs.....but they appear to be settling in to an identity and are gaining more and more confidence.......which is critical to winning.  Nobody is saying the eagles are a complete football team....they still have a lot of improvement to make.....but to dismiss their progress because they had to make progress is flat out idiotic.

I don't know how these guys can cover pro football and never understand how teams get better......And I don't understand how they get paid for such terrible analysis and writing.



  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I read and thought it was quite amusing. 

The writer talks on a couple of occasions about haters on social media etc. But he's a hater himself. 

He wants to give no credit to the coaches because early in the year they struggled. I guess it should be ignored that they are all young and all rookies in their positions?

Look I think many of us had concerns on Sirianni earlier this year. Many of us had the same concerns with Gannon. But over the last few weeks Sirianni has shown a lot of growth and Gannon now seems to be coming on. Am I sold on either? No not 100% but I don't think you could ever be on rookie coaches.

He gives no credit for the run game either. He just says they are using their OL to go out there and open up big holes. That the RBs are doing what they are good at and that Hurts is improving. So no scheming goes in to getting the OL to open up the right holes and the RB to exploit that? No scheming goes in to the run game at all? Even against what was the best run D in the NFL? And no credit goes to coaches for seemingly helping Hurts to improve?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Create New...