Jump to content

Eytan Shander: There are fewer and fewer reasons to move on from Jalen Hurts


Recommended Posts

Eytan Shander: There are fewer and fewer reasons to move on from Jalen Hurts

The Eagles brass may want a different offense next season. That would be bad...

Eytan Shander
PhillyVoice Contributor
Jalen-Hurts-celebrates_112121_usatBILL STREICHER/USA TODAY SPORTS

Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts reacts after a touchdown run against the New Orleans Saints.

Here we sit ahead of Chrismas and the final three weeks of the NFL season. I’m sure your children have asked - whoever the gift-bringer is in whichever gift-giving holiday you celebrate in December – for an Eagles playoff berth, correct?

I haven’t. Not because I’m some Grinch out here rooting against my team, rather I’d want my wish granted on something else. I also recognize this isn’t the super popular, or a unanimous decision. It’s also become painfully evident that no matter what numbers or stats are thrown out, it doesn’t seem to change the opinion of whichever side is arguing.

Yes, I’ll keep my earlier wish of Jalen Hurts being the QB1 moving forward, for at least the next season, and seeing what this team can do with two years of growth – especially Hurts. But this isn’t another "Hurts should be the guy” column, we did that before. It’s more a matter of why the organization still has this belief that someone else is out there, not named Rodgers, Watson, or Wilson.

It’s also about why a fan would be so immersed in this season, enjoying so much of what we’ve been asking from our teams for years, and think they need to upgrade the QB. They have three picks that suddenly don’t seem like top-10 locks.

So again, what exactly are you looking at in this stretch run that has you asking for Spencer Rattler?

Hurts and the Eagles offense are doing things we haven’t seen in years, dominating on the ground like we haven’t seen, well, ever. The offensive line is rotating each week and it doesn’t even matter. Their run game isn't suffering. It’s thriving. Dallas Goedert has shown he can execute the game plan that highlights him as the top threat, and the team can still thrive.

They aren’t even fully using DeVonta Smith to his potential, which will come. The Eagles have one of the rarest combinations of offensive attacks in the NFL and breaking that up would be foolish – dare I say, counter-productive.

There may not be a better time than now – ahead of an inevitable win over the Giants where Hurts will continue to shine – to put this out. There are fewer and fewer reasons to move on from the current QB.

The team isn’t going to get better from where they are right now by simply adding Aaron Rodgers. If they can even get him. They certainly aren’t Super Bowl-ready by using three picks on Deshaun Watson. The offense works. How could anyone say that it doesn’t? Yet…

We’ve seen a similar sentiment echoed throughout the media – people like our own Jimmy Kempski on the latest edition of Post Flight – that the team may not want this type of offense moving forward. It’s hard to ignore, as far too many people who cover this team continue to bring it up in conversations regarding Hurts future.

It’s also easy to believe that the team’s owner and other decision-maker would still be enamored with someone with a cannon for an arm, and not a Ferrari for feet.

Here is the biggest problem with the team’s mentality; by removing the special talents that Hurts has in this offense, the team is forcing a rebuild. It’s making it exponentially tougher on Nick Sirianni. Even harder on the defense.

We couldn’t have had this conversation a month ago, six weeks or even at the start of the season. We needed to see this with our own eyes play out, no matter if you believed or not. Hurts has taken over as the premiere running QB in the NFL but it’s so much more than that. He’s leading one of the most powerful offenses on the ground the league has seen in a while.

Let’s be honest, if you consider yourself some master team-builder, you shouldn’t need another quarterback.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Overall, Hurts is playing at a high QB2 level IMO. Right now the Eagles strength of schedule is under .500 so they're not consistently facing the better teams. Playoff teams will shut down his ability to run and force him to win from the pocket. He doesn't seem to have developed that ability yet, and he may never, just like all of the running QB's before him. He's a running QB right now, and we know that running QB's have won a total of zero Super Bowls. Hurts isn't likely to change that. What Hurts can change is his ability to win from the pocket. Time will tell.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We’re completely ignoring the strength of the opponents here. They’re playing terrible teams. When they run into actual good opponents, they aren’t going to be able to just run all day. They’re going to need to throw themselves back into some games when they play teams like Tampa, Dallas, LA, Green Bay, etc. As of right now, I’m not at all confident that Hurts can do that. 

The only way you’re winning anything with nothing but a running attack on offense is if you’ve also got an insanely good defense. Not to mention you can’t rely on the offensive line to stay this dominant every single year. Especially when injuries pile up as we have seen happen plenty of times. Or when Kelce retires… his elite run blocking is a huge reason for the success. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The best path this off-season is to invest in oline to stay dominate.   Invest in D and another offensive weapon.  Those moves help to build Hurts AND help if they decide to move onto another QB. Draft a development guy later like Zappe and let him compete.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The eagles have a unique opportunity this offseason to add a LOAD of talent on both sides of the ball.

Hurts is coming along pretty well but being young, he's going to show times of inconsistency and has some areas to develop......those areas take time, familiarity, and experience.  For a kid who SHOULDN'T HAVE BEEN STARTING, he's coming along pretty well.

He deserves another year.......The defense needs a talent infusion especially at DE and LB.......going after another QB is downright stupid at this point.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Create New...