Jump to content

What they're saying: Should Eagles sign Freeman or McCoy? How 'married' are they to Wentz?


Recommended Posts



May 29, 2020

What they're saying: Should Eagles sign Freeman or McCoy? How 'married' are they to Wentz?

Matt Mullin
By Matt Mullin
PhillyVoice Staff


USA Today Sports/File

Free agent running backs Devonta Freeman and LeSean McCoy.

Welcome to a Friday edition of What They're Saying, where we'll catch you up on all the latest news and rumors surrounding the Eagles, from their quest to land a veteran backup running back to the latest on their franchise quarterback and even an interesting theory on why the Eagles made one of their big offseason moves. 

Since you're probably ready to get your weekend started, let's skip a lengthy intro and just dive right into it...

Eagles should sign Freeman over Shady

David Murphy | Philadelphia Daily News


On Thursday, Jeff McLane of the Inquirer reported that the Eagles had an offer out to free agent running back Devonta Freeman, while still maintaining interest in all-time franchise rushing leader LeSean McCoy, as they continue to search for a veteran running back to add to a group that features Miles Sanders, Boston Scott, Corey Clement, and others. 

Aside from the four-year age difference between the younger Freeman and the more seasoned McCoy, there are differences in style as well. And over at Inquirer.com, columnist David Murphy took a look at the pros and cons of adding each rusher, and came away with the belief that there should be a clear favorite for the Eagles... 


With McCoy, there might be more of a reason to believe that the player you’ve seen over the course of his career is the one you will get. But that player has a lot of similarities to the player the Eagles already have in Miles Sanders, and I can’t help but think that they would be better served with a steadier, more north-to-south runner.

Despite his size (5-foot-8, 206 pounds), Freeman is a physical runner who has thrived on the inside zone. Between 2015 and 2017, he was one of the most efficient short-yardage runners in the NFL, with only one running back eclipsing the number of first downs he gained on third-and-1 and fourth-and-1. In those three seasons, Freeman was successful on 37 of 54 such attempts.

Compare that with some of the game’s biggest names: Melvin Gordon (36 of 63), Todd Gurley (28 of 64), Ezekiel Elliott (28 of 46), LeGarrette Blount (24 of 55). McCoy was successful on 29 of 54 such carries.


Freeman is a more accomplished receiver than McCoy. Despite his struggles on the ground in 2019, he still finished the year with 59 catches for 410 yards and four touchdowns. In fact, he has averaged 54 catches per season throughout his career, seven more than McCoy.  [inquirer.com]


Together forever?

Dan Graziano | ESPN


Over at ESPN, they ranked all 32 starting NFL quarterbacks by how "married" they and their respective teams are. And given that they just inked him to a massive extension last year, it's no surprise that Eagles QB Carson Wentz found himself high up on that list.



But what may be surprising to the casual Eagles fan who saw that monster deal lock him down through 2024 is that the Eagles aren't really tied to Wentz beyond 2021. Of course, the odds suggest he'll be around longer than that. 


8. Philadelphia Eagles

Starter: Carson Wentz | Signed through: 2024
Tier: Locked-in vet | Ranking in tier: No. 5

Contract: Four-year, $128 million extension signed in June 2019, including $66.5 million fully guaranteed at signing.

Wentz's contract structure is built on staggered roster bonuses that were designed to help the Eagles navigate 2019 and 2020 salary-cap issues. He's basically getting $30 million this year and $25.4 million fully guaranteed in 2021.

None of his salary is guaranteed beyond 2021, though $15 million of his 2022 salary becomes fully guaranteed if he's still on the team in March 2021. (It's also worth noting, given Wentz's history, that his 2022 salary is currently guaranteed for injury.) The remaining proration of the bonuses means the Eagles would incur a dead-money charge of about $24.5 million if they decided to move on from Wentz in the 2022 offseason. That's a lot, but not impossible, especially if his injury issues persist and if 2020 second-round pick Jalen Hurts develops.

Wentz probably stays in Philly for more than the next two years, but the Eagles aren't contractually married to him for any longer than that.  [espn.com]


Carson speaks out

Daniel Gallen | Penn Live


Sticking with Wentz for a moment, the Eagles quarterback and face of the franchise uncharacteristically took a stance on a massive social issue on Thursday when he tweeted about the death of George Floyd at the hands of a Minneapolis police officer, who has since been arrested. 


With social activist Malcolm Jenkins no longer on the team, it appears Wentz may be ready to step forward and fill that leadership void. And former teammates have taken notice. 


Additionally, Chris Long, a former Walter Payton Man of the Year winner and activist in his own right, had high praise of his former teammate during an interview on his "Green Light" Podcast with Warriors coach Steve Kerr. 


"I just had that conversation with Carson Wentz,” Long said. "I shared with you that tweet. I was very moved by that because you heard Shannon Sharpe talk about this week. He said who’s gonna step up? We need Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers. It’s great that we’ve got X, Y, Zs of the world, but we need the big named quarterbacks and that type of thing.

"So to see that happen, and [Wentz] said ‘institutional racism.’ He typed those words out. That was really important to me, and I got chills thinking about it because it’s so bare minimum, but that’s all we need. We just need guys to address it.”

Kerr and Long both said they seek out experts on issues to have discussions with before they make public statements. They want to be informed, and Kerr said he tries to "latch on” in order to learn as much as he can.

That’s the first step in being able to make a larger impact with a significant platform, both men said. And for Wentz, speaking out is a big first step.

"Hop in the passenger’s seat and say let’s roll,” Long said. "I think that’s the biggest thing for anybody out listening. You don’t have to be an expert. I know that had to be intimidating for Carson to send that tweet. I always knew he had that in him. I know that a lot of my teammates had that in them. Just because a guy is silent doesn’t mean he isn’t a good person, but right now, silence is not enough. I hope people step up.”  [pennlive.com]


Wentz among highest paid athletes in world

Staff | Forbes


Here's one last Wentz item that was almost as surprising as the QB's sudden decision to speak out on racial issues in the country, although the two aren't mutually exclusive as it's often the richest and most successful who fear speaking out because they believe they have the most to lose, when in fact they might be the ones who can most help bring about the systemic changes we so desperately need at the moment. 

And Wentz, at least financially speaking, has quite a bit to lose. 

According to Forbes, Wentz ($59.1 million) is the 10th highest paid athlete in professional sports. Worldwide. He’s also the second highest paid NFL player. Here’s more from Forbes profile on Wentz’ earnings and accolades:


•  The Philadelphia Eagles signed Carson Wentz to a contract extension in June 2019 worth $128 million over four years.

•  The deal included a $16.4 million signing bonus, as well as a $30 million option bonus paid in March 2020.

•  Wentz has a robust endorsement portfolio with Nike, NRG, Bobcat, Amazon, Sanford Health, Bose, Scheels and BlackRidge Bank.

•  He holds Eagles single-season franchise records for passing yards, completions and touchdowns.

•  Wentz was selected second overall pick in the 2016 NFL Draft, after fellow quarterback Jared Goff.  [forbes.com]


That $16.4 million signing bonus and $30 million option bonus that Wentz received is in addition to his regular $9 million salary, bringing his total football earnings to about $55 million, with another $4 million in endorsements bringing his total to north of $59 million.

As Forbes pointed out, the pandemic greatly impacted this list with baseball players being the hardest hit and football players seeing the biggest surge in number of players on the list due to the timing of when their season starts. 

Here is the full top 10:


1. Roger Federer: $106.3 million
2. Cristiano Ronaldo: $105 million
3. Lionel Messi: $104 million
4. Neymar: $95.5 million
5. LeBron James: $88.2 million
6. Stephen Curry: $74.4 million
7. Kevin Durant: $63.9 million
8. Tiger Woods: $62.3 million
9. Kirk Cousins: $60.5 million
10. Carson Wentz: $59.1 million


Jared Goff (No. 15) was the only other NFL player to crack the Top 20.

Hangin' with Mr. Cooper

Mike Kaye | NJ.com


Finally, we arrive at an interesting nugget from an all-time great, Joe Thomas, who believes he knows the real reason why the Eagles were so desperate to acquire the likes of Darius Slay this offseason. Here's more from Mike Kaye of NJ.com:


Thomas, who was named to 10 Pro Bowls during his illustrious NFL career, believes Eagles general manager Howie Roseman wanted to find a way to stop [Cowboys WR Amari] Cooper from destroying his secondary on a regular basis. Slay held Cooper to just three catches for 38 yards during the pair’s previous meeting in Detroit last season.

"Darius Slay was very good against Amari Cooper when they played,” Thomas said on NFL Network this week. "He only allowed a 33% completion percentage. Oh, and by the way, Philly’s DBs were the worst in the NFL against Amari Cooper since 2015.”

Slay serves as a major upgraded over Ronald Darby as the Eagles’ No. 1 cornerback. He is able to match up and move around against the opposing team’s top wide receiver. Cooper has that role for the Cowboys, and Slay should be able to slow the Pro Bowl playmaker down in coverage.

Cooper caught a combined 10 passes for 130 yards against the Eagles in their two matchups last season.  [nj.com]

Earlier this week, our own Jimmy Kempski broke down the film on Slay and wrote about each of his matchups last season. 

Follow Matt on Twitter: @matt_mullin

Like us on Facebook: PhillyVoice Sports



Link to comment
Share on other sites

Freeman already said he wants money and will sit out a year if needed to get paid. So if thats the case No. 

Signing McCoy would be the same mistake of resigning Sproles last year. Have to know when to say its time to move on. 



Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, DeathByEagle said:

Freeman already said he wants money and will sit out a year if needed to get paid. So if thats the case No. 

That's what he says but I'm not sure if he'll follow through with that threat. He's an ageing RB with injury concerns. Taking a year out didn't get Bell what he wanted. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Create New...