October 17, 2024Oct 17 42 minutes ago, Phillyterp85 said: And some more sources: Back in January, US Intelligence estimated that the IDF had killed 20-30% of Hamas combatants. Hamas is estimated to have had 30,000 members at the start of the war. So 20-30% would be 6,000 to 9,000 casualties. https://www.timesofisrael.com/us-said-to-believe-israel-killed-just-20-30-of-hamas-terrorists-in-gaza-fighting/ Back in January, Hamas claimed the total death toll was 25,000. So using the US intel number of combatant casualties and the Hamas number of total casualties, that would put the civilian to combatant ratio somewhere between 1.8:1 and 3.2:1. And again, this is using the Hamas total death figure, which has been shown to be very flawed, and at times seemingly made up. So are you going to finally answer my question and give me an example of where I have made up my own statistics? Or just come back 2 days later and make up another false claim that I haven't posted sources..... So your only source is the IDF numbers?
October 17, 2024Oct 17 1 hour ago, Dave Moss said: So your only source is the IDF numbers? No. My source is IDF numbers, US Intel numbers, and Hamas numbers. This was all laid out for you pretty clearly. Is this one of those things where you fully accept the Hamas numbers but don’t accept IDF and US Intel numbers? That would be a pretty interesting way to look at things…. Nice move of the goalposts too. So you went from "you use made up statistics” to "ok so you have sources for your statistics, but I don’t like one of them!” And care to back up your claim that I make up my own statistics? Or were you lying when you said that? Me: If you take IDF's data on Hamas combatant casualty numbers, US intel's data on Hamas combatant casualty numbers, and Hamas' data on total casualties, you get a range of civilian to combatant casualty ratios. Dave: So your only source is the IDF numbers? I certainly hope you use better reading comprehension and logic while educating our youth.
October 17, 2024Oct 17 2 hours ago, Phillyterp85 said: And some more sources: Back in January, US Intelligence estimated that the IDF had killed 20-30% of Hamas combatants. Hamas is estimated to have had 30,000 members at the start of the war. So 20-30% would be 6,000 to 9,000 casualties. https://www.timesofisrael.com/us-said-to-believe-israel-killed-just-20-30-of-hamas-terrorists-in-gaza-fighting/ Back in January, Hamas claimed the total death toll was 25,000. So using the US intel number of combatant casualties and the Hamas number of total casualties, that would put the civilian to combatant ratio somewhere between 1.8:1 and 3.2:1. And again, this is using the Hamas total death figure, which has been shown to be very flawed, and at times seemingly made up. So are you going to finally answer my question and give me an example of where I have made up my own statistics? Or just come back 2 days later and make up another false claim that I haven't posted sources..... Pick your battles. Dave is committed to being wrong about this war, and nothing you tell him will change his mind. A much more effective tactic is to simply pile on the ridicule that he richly deserves.
October 17, 2024Oct 17 2 hours ago, Phillyterp85 said: No. My source is IDF numbers, US Intel numbers, and Hamas numbers. This was all laid out for you pretty clearly. Is this one of those things where you fully accept the Hamas numbers but don’t accept IDF and US Intel numbers? That would be a pretty interesting way to look at things…. Nice move of the goalposts too. So you went from "you use made up statistics” to "ok so you have sources for your statistics, but I don’t like one of them!” And care to back up your claim that I make up my own statistics? Or were you lying when you said that? Me: If you take IDF's data on Hamas combatant casualty numbers, US intel's data on Hamas combatant casualty numbers, and Hamas' data on total casualties, you get a range of civilian to combatant casualty ratios. Dave: So your only source is the IDF numbers? I certainly hope you use better reading comprehension and logic while educating our youth. I think you make up the statistics you post because they’re not close to being right. However, if you’re using bad sources that could be the problem.
October 17, 2024Oct 17 1 hour ago, Procus said: Pick your battles. Dave is committed to being wrong about this war, and nothing you tell him will change his mind. A much more effective tactic is to simply pile on the ridicule that he richly deserves. Yeah, I’m generally anti-colonialism but I’ll acknowledge that I miss sometimes.
October 18, 2024Oct 18 1 hour ago, Dave Moss said: I think you make up the statistics you post because they’re not close to being right. However, if you’re using bad sources that could be the problem. lol that’s a funny non answer. Ok Dave, why don’t you tell us how many Hamas combatants have been killed and what your source is for that information. If you claim I’m wrong, then surely you know the right answer and have a verifiable source for that information. Also, which of the 3 sources are bad? IDF, US, Hamas? Are only two of them incorrect but one of them totally accurate?
October 18, 2024Oct 18 Author 7 hours ago, Phillyterp85 said: Ok Dave, why don’t you tell us how many Hamas combatants have been killed
October 18, 2024Oct 18 dave, just in case you've missed the actual genocide going on in the world as a result of your antisemitism, i mean anti-colonialism, i mean progressive ideology. The World Is Ignoring the Catastrophe in Sudan | TIME Fight for Darfur and Khartoum intensifies | Article | Africa Confidential (africa-confidential.com) Relentless fighting is devastating Sudan and escalating in Darfur's capital, UN says | AP News i bet you'll be organizing a big protest over this as soon as you finish reading these.
October 18, 2024Oct 18 Any day now, I'm sure @Dave Moss will let us know what the "REAL" number of Hamas casualties are and provide us with the "Good" source for that information.
October 18, 2024Oct 18 On 9/25/2024 at 10:49 PM, Arthur Jackson said: DIVINE SECRETS OF THE YAHYA SINWARHOOD! lol underrated joke
October 18, 2024Oct 18 2 hours ago, Phillyterp85 said: Any day now, I'm sure @Dave Moss will let us know what the "REAL" number of Hamas casualties are and provide us with the "Good" source for that information. Take it easy on him. His good buddy and source for all info was just killed.
October 18, 2024Oct 18 25 minutes ago, vikas83 said: Take it easy on him. His good buddy and source for all info was just killed. Sinwar getting killed was inevitable. Doesn’t change a thing though.
October 18, 2024Oct 18 2 hours ago, Mike030270 said: That summary of events got you hyped, didn't it?
October 18, 2024Oct 18 32 minutes ago, paco said: That summary of events got you hyped, didn't it? he's probably just one of those guys that are really into amputees
October 18, 2024Oct 18 Author 2 hours ago, Dave Moss said: Sinwar getting killed was inevitable. Doesn’t change a thing though. Sorry for your loss
October 18, 2024Oct 18 2 hours ago, Dave Moss said: Sinwar getting killed was inevitable. Doesn’t change a thing though. How many combatants did he tell you were killed in the war prior to his demise?
October 18, 2024Oct 18 3 hours ago, Dave Moss said: Sinwar getting killed was inevitable. Doesn’t change a thing though. And that is true, it certainly won’t change you being a propaganda spreading shill for Hamas.
Create an account or sign in to comment