April 30, 20214 yr 3 minutes ago, Road to Victory said: Who cares about college stats? What does that mean? I thought the trade up was a desperate move. I would’ve stayed put at 12 and rolled the dice on the Giants not taking him. If I’m wrong so be it. A 3rd is a lot to move up 2 spots. If the Giants take him, I trade down with Chicago. Go check in with the Giants forums. Everyone in those forums knew they were going to take Smith if he was available. They were celebrating after the Denver pick because they thought they had Devonta, only to be stunned when the Eagles traded up. The trade out of the 11 pick confirmed the fans assumptions. Smith was not going to make it past the NYG guys. Giants need help at the WR position.
April 30, 20214 yr 4 minutes ago, Pliny said: Go check in with the Giants forums. Everyone in those forums knew they were going to take Smith if he was available. They were celebrating after the Denver pick because they thought they had Devonta, only to be stunned when the Eagles traded up. The trade out of the 11 pick confirmed the fans assumptions. Smith was not going to make it past the NYG guys. Giants need help at the WR position. Gettleman could care less about who the Giant fans want. They need Oline much more than WR. They probably draft Slater if they stay there. They just signed Kenny Golladay to a huge contract plus they have Shepard & Slayton. I doubt they take Smith.
April 30, 20214 yr 15 minutes ago, Road to Victory said: Who cares about college stats? What does that mean? I thought the trade up was a desperate move. I would’ve stayed put at 12 and rolled the dice on the Giants not taking him. If I’m wrong so be it. A 3rd is a lot to move up 2 spots. If the Giants take him, I trade down with Chicago. You were wrong. So be it.
April 30, 20214 yr @VaBeach_Eagle what a difference from last year when these boards were new and handling the traffic. Thanks for an awesome job.
April 30, 20214 yr It’s clear now that smith would have been the giants pick. I’m not a fan of a Tooney though. The question is do you prefer Smith or say Bateman + 3rd we traded + another 1st next year (from Bears). Giants got great value for their trade down which would have been available to us at 12 as well.
April 30, 20214 yr 17 minutes ago, Road to Victory said: Who cares about college stats? What does that mean? I thought the trade up was a desperate move. I would’ve stayed put at 12 and rolled the dice on the Giants not taking him. If I’m wrong so be it. A 3rd is a lot to move up 2 spots. If the Giants take him, I trade down with Chicago. The giants reached for a WR after trading down so...
April 30, 20214 yr 1 minute ago, Weedeater said: You were wrong. So be it. How was I wrong? Do you know if the would’ve taken Slater or Smith? They need Oline more than WR but there isn’t a lineman worth taking at 20.
April 30, 20214 yr 8 minutes ago, Road to Victory said: Gettleman could care less about who the Giant fans want. They need Oline much more than WR. They probably draft Slater if they stay there. They just signed Kenny Golladay to a huge contract plus they have Shepard & Slayton. I doubt they take Smith. They would've took hom 100% They just took the next best WR. As much as we all like to slag Howie(rightfully so most of the time) it was a brilliant trade.
April 30, 20214 yr 1 minute ago, Gannan said: The giants reached for a WR after trading down so... Agreed
April 30, 20214 yr 4 minutes ago, NOTW said: Carson's new Indy teammate is...Kwity Paye. Would have died had it been a QB
April 30, 20214 yr 18 minutes ago, Road to Victory said: Gettleman could care less about who the Giant fans want. They need Oline much more than WR. They probably draft Slater if they stay there. They just signed Kenny Golladay to a huge contract plus they have Shepard & Slayton. I doubt they take Smith. Well, Gettleman just validated that they were going after Smith. They just reached and chose WR Toney at 20. The guy has suspect hands and possible character issues. They were completely desperate for a WR.
April 30, 20214 yr 3 minutes ago, mihailo said: Would have died had it been a QB Well there's always round 2...
April 30, 20214 yr Love our pick...but, even better...Dallas got Fed outta both corners that they wanted...
April 30, 20214 yr 59 minutes ago, manz2821 said: I like the Smith pick but pissed that the cowboys got an extra third round pick and still got the player at 12 which they would have gotten at 10. Giants would've took Smith at 11 and then how pissed would you have been? Relax.
April 30, 20214 yr 1 minute ago, Weedeater said: Giants would've took Smith at 11 and then how pissed would you have been? Relax. The giants know how to draft receivers also, it is a good sign.
April 30, 20214 yr Remember, they have the 5th pick in the 2nd round abs 6th in other rounds so picking high in each round.
April 30, 20214 yr 7 minutes ago, Portyansky said: Really hope Asante Jr. will be there in the 2nd There's great value at the top of the 2nd. A lot of players the Eagles could use. But, CB would be preferred, true. I think the Eagles can stay at 37 and still get a player that could've gone earlier than that. So, they are in a good position.
