Eagles Weighing Tough Decision on ‘Lame Duck’ GM Howie Roseman

[time2rock]

Eagles Weighing Tough Decision on ‘Lame Duck’ GM Howie Roseman

• 
• By Mike Greger

• Updated Feb 18, 2022 at 8:25pm

Getty: Eagles GM Howie Roseman made the outside-the-box decision to hire Nick Sirianni as the next head coach in Philadelphia.

The Philadelphia Eagles were handing out contracts left and right in the middle of the season. They wanted to make sure their key young players were locked up for life. Which they successfully did.

The Eagles inked Josh Sweat, Dallas Goedert, Avonte Maddox, T.J. Edwards, and Jordan Mailata to lucrative extensions. But the man writing those checks has yet to receive the same form of financial job security. General manager Howie Roseman will enter the final year of the four-year extension he signed with the franchise in 2018.

That’s right, Roseman is a lame-duck heading into 2022. Details of his salary were never disclosed, but the Eagles sent a press release out on August 5, 2018, announcing Roseman’s extension along with one for Doug Pederson. It hasn’t been talked about again.

"Doug and Howie are committed to the success of our franchise by ensuring that we remain competitive, both in the short and long term,” team owner Jeffrey Lurie said at the time. "That unified vision for the future of our team is what gives us the best chance to win moving forward.”

---

Twitter Celebrates Carson Wentz Trade

Twitter was fawning with tributes to Roseman on Friday for the way he unloaded Carson Wentz prior to the 2021 season. He fleeced the Indianapolis Colts and received what turned out to be a first-rounder and third-rounder for the broken quarterback. Friday (February 18) marked the one-year anniversary of the robbery.

Now Roseman is set to enter a franchise-changing offseason, armed with three first-rounders and a young team that overachieved in Year 1 under Nick Sirianni. SportsRadio 94WIP’s Joe Giglio called it the "most significant” offseason since the Dallas Cowboys in 1991. They had three picks in the Top-20 that year; the Eagles have three in the Top-19 in 2022. Giglio thinks Roseman deserves an extension.

"I believe it would be a significant mistake for the Philadelphia Eagles to allow Howie Roseman to be a lame duck in this offseason,” Giglio said. "So what I’m getting at is pretty simple: the Eagles need to extend Howie Roseman’s contract now.”

Eagles Fans Love to Chant ‘Fire Howie’

We can debate the pros and cons of Roseman all day. It’s true last year’s unofficial rebuild grew roots faster than anyone anticipated. The Eagles were able to rid themselves of Wentz because they had already drafted his replacement in Jalen Hurts. Of course, the jury’s still out on that move. It looks like a win for the time being, although the calls to "Fire Howie” won’t stop.

Meanwhile, Roseman was able to restructure the contracts of key veterans to create ample cap space to dole out extensions to his young core. Those moves were under-the-radar strokes of genius. However, you could argue that Roseman’s poor drafting over the years has hindered the team from winning multiple Super Bowls. Joey Bosa and Jalen Ramsey were sitting there in the 2016 NFL draft when they chose Wentz with the No. 2 overall pick. Then again, the Eagles don’t win the Super Bowl without Wentz.

To Roseman’s credit, he quickly rectified that mistake. It’s the other first-round gaffes that stand out: Danny Watkins, Marcus Smith, Derek Barnett, Andre Dillard, Jalen Reagor. His refusal to address linebacker has been another point of contention — Fred Warner, Logan Wilson, Micah Parsons, Kyle Van Noy come to mind. And the constant whiffs at wide receiver have turned DK Metcalf and Justin Jefferson into permanent memes in Philadelphia. And let’s not forget the obsession with Riley Cooper.

So, does Roseman deserve a contract extension? I’d make him sweat it out and wait to see how his 2022 draft board pans out. If those three first-round picks are thriving at the midway point — and the Eagles are in prime playoff position — then you have to reward the architect. He earned it. But if the team is flailing and proving the common belief that 2021 was fool’s gold, you dump him.

https://heavy.com/sports/philadelphia-eagles/howie-roseman-lame-duck/

[UK_EaglesFan89]

Let's hope they just let him walk. I mean we know they won't be we can dream. 

[Rob331]

I want him back. The Eagles have been consistent winners throughout his tenure with very few down years. 

[Perforator]

I'd pay for him to leave.

[eglz1]

If there were a way to extend Howie but to build a very strong firewall between him and anything to do with draft selections, I'd be okay with that. He's above average when it comes to trades and contracts. He has utterly sucked when it comes to selecting college talent in the first couple rounds though the last draft wasn't too bad. There is speculation that he listens to his scouts when it comes to lower round picks.

[eggs]

3 hours ago, eglz1 said:

If there were a way to extend Howie but to build a very strong firewall between him and anything to do with draft selections, I'd be okay with that. He's above average when it comes to trades and contracts. He has utterly sucked when it comes to selecting college talent in the first couple rounds though the last draft wasn't too bad. There is speculation that he listens to his scouts when it comes to lower round picks.

I like that idea. 

[Cochis_Calhoun]

Is there even such a thing as a lame duck GM?  Does anyone anywhere sit talking about GM's being on the hot seat,  I don't think I could name more than a couple of GM's outside the NFC East with any confidence.

The only reason I could see it being an issue is if we were looking for a new coach and prospective candidates might be worried there might be a new GM in a year who wants his guy as coach, other than that, who cares?

 

[time2rock]

There are going to be a lot of disappointed Eagles fans when they announce his contract extension.  If I had to guess I'd say there is a 99% chance that happens before the summer.  

[Rob331]

3 hours ago, time2rock said:

There are going to be a lot of disappointed Eagles fans when they announcement his contract extension.  If I had to guess I'd say there is a 99% chance that happens before the summer.  

Bingo! 

[time2rock]

Perhaps this came a bit earlier than expected, but always knew (the gut feeling was strong!) it was going to get done.  

[nipples]

I get that Howie makes mistakes (Reagor), but overall he’s not a terrible GM. I think we are just so close to it that we focus on everything done wrong for the Eagles and ignore the fact that most teams have worse GMs. 
 

You can really only judge GM success based on the team’s success, and since Howie took back over after the Chip Kelly disaster, the Eagles are 13th in the NFL in win percentage (2016-2021), with a super bowl in there. 

[time2rock]

27 minutes ago, nipples said:

I get that Howie makes mistakes (Reagor), but overall he’s not a terrible GM. I think we are just so close to it that we focus on everything done wrong for the Eagles and ignore the fact that most teams have worse GMs. 
 

You can really only judge GM success based on the team’s success, and since Howie took back over after the Chip Kelly disaster, the Eagles are 13th in the NFL in win percentage (2016-2021), with a super bowl in there. 

I get all that.  13th isn't exactly stellar ... that is middle of the pack.  I just want someone who doesn't make egregious mistakes like Reagor over Jefferson (that one was so blatantly obvious ... much worse than JJAW over Metcalf).  If Howie can show that he has learned from his mistakes and avoids them for the most part in the future, then I think people will start to ease up on him.  All GMs are going to make mistakes ... Howie just seems to make more (when it comes to using early picks) than most, and his mistakes are HUGE.