May 10, 20224 yr 1 minute ago, Shalodeep said: If that's all you got, then I'll continue to enjoying discussing on a discussion board. Thank you Go ahead. Players aren't limited by your opinions.
May 10, 20224 yr 2 minutes ago, brkmsn said: Go ahead. Players aren't limited by your opinions. Nope, just by their limitations and he has plenty at the moment
May 10, 20224 yr 2 minutes ago, Shalodeep said: Nope, just by their limitations and he has plenty at the moment He certainly has room for improvement in many areas, but perhaps you can explain these "limitations" and how they will certainly prevent improvement. They are, as you say, "limitations."
May 10, 20224 yr 9 minutes ago, brkmsn said: He certainly has room for improvement in many areas, but perhaps you can explain these "limitations" and how they will certainly prevent improvement. They are, as you say, "limitations." I've played this game with many of you so I'm going to reverse it. What does he do so well beyond running that gives you hope other than your make a wish list ? Pretty sure here comes the intangible conversation
May 10, 20224 yr 4 minutes ago, Shalodeep said: I've played this game with many of you so I'm going to reverse it. What does he do so well beyond running that gives you hope other than your make a wish list ? Unlike you, I'm not certain of how a young player will turn out. I was encouraged by the improvement he demonstrated from year 1 to year 2. As a fan of the Eagles, I hope to see continued improvement and more consistency. He had a tremendous passing performance against Denver on the road and a terrible game against the giants. But inconsistency is a trait of a young QB, so that in and of itself isn't discouraging to me. I feel that with a position like RB, you get the best version of that player in years 1-5. But with QBs, you get that best version of that player in years 5-10. In other words, to me, he's on schedule as long as he continues to improve.
May 10, 20224 yr 10 minutes ago, brkmsn said: Unlike you, I'm not certain of how a young player will turn out. I was encouraged by the improvement he demonstrated from year 1 to year 2. As a fan of the Eagles, I hope to see continued improvement and more consistency. He had a tremendous passing performance against Denver on the road and a terrible game against the giants. But inconsistency is a trait of a young QB, so that in and of itself isn't discouraging to me. I feel that with a position like RB, you get the best version of that player in years 1-5. But with QBs, you get that best version of that player in years 5-10. In other words, to me, he's on schedule as long as he continues to improve. Cool way not to answer at all
May 10, 20224 yr 1 minute ago, Shalodeep said: Cool way not to answer at all The answer was in there. I didn't avoid answering unlike you.
May 10, 20224 yr 3 minutes ago, brkmsn said: The answer was in there. I didn't avoid answering unlike you. Okay, I'll reword it for you. Other than his ability to run, what part of his skill set feels like an asset more than liability at this point?
May 10, 20224 yr 23 minutes ago, brkmsn said: The answer was in there. I didn't avoid answering unlike you. Okay so the Denver game he threw for 178 yards 2tds, 1int. That's his passing performance you decided to bring up. Do you want a game to make a team go "maybe, just maybe" Davis mills vs Tennessee 301 yards, 3 TDS or in a losing effort to the Patriots 312 yards 3tds or against the chargers 254 yards 2tds. All three of those would be career type games for hurts
May 10, 20224 yr On 5/7/2022 at 1:23 PM, Diehardfan said: The kid gets it already. If the last Carson had this mindset he may still be here. One of the most impressive things about Carson Strong is this... Accuracy. "299 consecutive pass attempts without an interception represent the longest streak in program history."
May 10, 20224 yr The Strong discussion starts around 10 mins in. Waldman says Strong menuevers the pocket as well as any pocket QB you'll find. He also thinks that Strong has 1st-2nd rd talent and there's a real chance he gets an opportunity if Hurts struggles. They talked about Kennedy Brooks as well. Waldman was high on another OU RB last year(Rhamondre Stevenson) and thinks Brooks is the smartest RB in the draft. Said if he had to place his bet on a RB being this generations Terrell Davis in terms of coming out of nowhere, he'd put his money on Kennedy Brooks.
May 10, 20224 yr 3 minutes ago, KDUB1510 said: The Strong discussion starts around 10 mins in. Waldman says Strong menuevers the pocket as well as any pocket QB you'll find. He also thinks that Strong has 1st-2nd rd talent and there's a real chance he gets an opportunity if Hurts struggles. The pressure is squarely on Jalen Hurts. Last year was first year coach, new system and rebuild, no pressure and he did not play well and forced a run heavy game plan. This year, second year, got the WR he wanted, it is all on him, and I for one thinks he will buckle under the pressure due to his limitations in the passing game. He better hope his style and running does not get him hurt early, as the other QB's will not give him his job back.
May 10, 20224 yr 8 hours ago, brkmsn said: He certainly has room for improvement in many areas, but perhaps you can explain these "limitations" and how they will certainly prevent improvement. They are, as you say, "limitations." Flat trajectory since college. All the same issues. No growth. So best predictor of future performance is….? One guess
May 10, 20224 yr 4 minutes ago, ToastJenkins said: Flat trajectory since college. All the same issues. No growth. So best predictor of future performance is….? One guess SWAG ???
May 10, 20224 yr 21 minutes ago, downundermike said: The pressure is squarely on Jalen Hurts. Last year was first year coach, new system and rebuild, no pressure and he did not play well and forced a run heavy game plan. This year, second year, got the WR he wanted, it is all on him, and I for one thinks he will buckle under the pressure due to his limitations in the passing game. He better hope his style and running does not get him hurt early, as the other QB's will not give him his job back. Hurts needs to keep those guys off the field.
May 10, 20224 yr 26 minutes ago, downundermike said: The pressure is squarely on Jalen Hurts. Last year was first year coach, new system and rebuild, no pressure and he did not play well and forced a run heavy game plan. This year, second year, got the WR he wanted, it is all on him, and I for one thinks he will buckle under the pressure due to his limitations in the passing game. He better hope his style and running does not get him hurt early, as the other QB's will not give him his job back. Agreed. I dont want to see us switch to a run heavy style if Hurts is underwhelming as a passer. If they're not gonna bench Him for Strong or Minshew then let him throw us into a top 10 pick. DO NOT switch to a run heavy style just to win 9-10 games and get bounced in the wildcard.
May 10, 20224 yr The problem is that we torched Sirianni for not adapting last year. I just think this staff needs to be honest. If we can't rely on Hurts and there is a guy on the bench that is more trustworthy under center then you have to make the change. I know a lot here would want that before the season but at least give him some games to show he's better. If he's still the same inconsistent guy we saw last year then make the change. I could see a situation where Sirianni gets enamored by Strong but other than that it's Hurts team. It's going to be tough on Sirianni because Strong can read defenses, throws with anticipation, has a great arm and can run the offense on his own. So your working with Strong and then you have to stop and roll it back for Hurts at less progressed level.
May 10, 20224 yr 9 hours ago, Shalodeep said: Okay, I'll reword it for you. Other than his ability to run, what part of his skill set feels like an asset more than liability at this point? It's kind of weird to separate his running from his passing as they are tied together in such a way that defense have to play us differently. His threat as a runner presents opportunities in the passing game. But to give you a better answer, the only thing I feel is a liability with him is his ability to trust what he sees. I think his arm is fine. That's not a liability to me. But in the NFL, you can't hesitate as a passer. When you do, you allow defenses to recover. Hurts has to trust his receiver to do their job and to finish the play. It's not uncommon for running QBs to use their running ability as a crutch early in their careers. I would imagine Hurts takes film study seriously and he most certainly is aware of the many potential TDs he left out on the field by not pulling the trigger as a passer on time or bailing on the pass altogether. This is correctable. 9 hours ago, Shalodeep said: Okay so the Denver game he threw for 178 yards 2tds, 1int. That's his passing performance you decided to bring up. Do you want a game to make a team go "maybe, just maybe" Davis mills vs Tennessee 301 yards, 3 TDS or in a losing effort to the Patriots 312 yards 3tds or against the chargers 254 yards 2tds. All three of those would be career type games for hurts I couldn't care less about his stats. I was impressed with his accuracy and vision in that game. He only attempted 3 passes in the 2nd half as we milked the clock for the win. There were some games where he didn't play as well. So this is a typical glass half full / half empty thing. I see the good games and feel he can play at a high level and just needs to do it consistently. Others see the bad games and want to say that's what he is and the good ones are a fluke.
May 10, 20224 yr 2 hours ago, ToastJenkins said: Flat trajectory since college. All the same issues. No growth. So best predictor of future performance is….? One guess First, the level of competition is much higher in the NFL than in college. So, to come into the NFL and help your team win games as a starter is an accomplishment. Saying there was no growth is a bit absurd. He did a much better job protecting the ball in his 2nd season than his rookie year. He improved his completion percentage by nearly 10%, his QB rating by 10 points, his QBR by 15, and the offense improved significantly in nearly every category. What's actually cool is that there is still plenty of room for growth. We're talking about a QB that is 23 years old, not 30.
May 10, 20224 yr 29 minutes ago, brkmsn said: It's kind of weird to separate his running from his passing as they are tied together in such a way that defense have to play us differently. His threat as a runner presents opportunities in the passing game. But to give you a better answer, the only thing I feel is a liability with him is his ability to trust what he sees. I think his arm is fine. That's not a liability to me. But in the NFL, you can't hesitate as a passer. When you do, you allow defenses to recover. Hurts has to trust his receiver to do their job and to finish the play. It's not uncommon for running QBs to use their running ability as a crutch early in their careers. I would imagine Hurts takes film study seriously and he most certainly is aware of the many potential TDs he left out on the field by not pulling the trigger as a passer on time or bailing on the pass altogether. This is correctable. I couldn't care less about his stats. I was impressed with his accuracy and vision in that game. He only attempted 3 passes in the 2nd half as we milked the clock for the win. There were some games where he didn't play as well. So this is a typical glass half full / half empty thing. I see the good games and feel he can play at a high level and just needs to do it consistently. Others see the bad games and want to say that's what he is and the good ones are a fluke. So if you add his running as an asset, then I'll return it as a liability because running back QBs are prone to abuse and availability is your best availability. He already got hurt once. May have only missed a game, but anyone can see clearly it effected his entirety of his game. I'd agree his hesitation is a liability, and that may fix half of his problem. Now for his willingness to adjust his delivery. His interview everyone got fired up on, he literally scoffed at the idea of someone tweaking his game. That's not something that makes me feel comfortable about adjusting his game. His arm strength is eh, but so is Minshew. I don't think of either of them having great arms, just okay. Now for this ridiculous stat comment. Literally the ONLY defense anyone has been able to put up for this RB is his rushing stats being part of his production that got him above the bottom of the barrel. If stats don't matter in your argument, then he is awful. Can't have it both ways
May 10, 20224 yr 18 minutes ago, brkmsn said: First, the level of competition is much higher in the NFL than in college. So, to come into the NFL and help your team win games as a starter is an accomplishment. Saying there was no growth is a bit absurd. He did a much better job protecting the ball in his 2nd season than his rookie year. He improved his completion percentage by nearly 10%, his QB rating by 10 points, his QBR by 15, and the offense improved significantly in nearly every category. What's actually cool is that there is still plenty of room for growth. We're talking about a QB that is 23 years old, not 30. Going to have to disagree there, sorry they won games by specifically planning around the same shortcomings he has had since bama
May 10, 20224 yr 1 minute ago, Shalodeep said: So if you add his running as an asset, then I'll return it as a liability because running back QBs are prone to abuse and availability is your best availability. He already got hurt once. May have only missed a game, but anyone can see clearly it effected his entirety of his game. I'd agree his hesitation is a liability, and that may fix half of his problem. Now for his willingness to adjust his delivery. His interview everyone got fired up on, he literally scoffed at the idea of someone tweaking his game. That's not something that makes me feel comfortable about adjusting his game. His arm strength is eh, but so is Minshew. I don't think of either of them having great arms, just okay. Now for this ridiculous stat comment. Literally the ONLY defense anyone has been able to put up for this RB is his rushing stats being part of his production that got him above the bottom of the barrel. If stats don't matter in your argument, then he is awful. Can't have it both ways Cunningham lost more games due to injury from injuries in the pocket than due to his running. I can go back and try to repost all those videos of QBs hurting themselves with slides, but it's a waste of time. It's a nice myth to believe I suppose. RG3 can be the poster-boy for it but the truth is he was just injury prone like Troy Aikman, Jim McMahon, and Sam Bradford to name a few. As for the stats. I'm not even sure what you're talking about. Stats are an asset in discussion, but they aren't always the "tell-all." In the Denver game, I wasn't impressed with his "stats." I was impressed with his passing. The numbers mean nothing. The passes were mostly on target and on time. I believe he had the one bad throw where he hesitated just a little bit and Surtain nearly got the pick (covering Smith).
May 10, 20224 yr 3 minutes ago, ToastJenkins said: Going to have to disagree there, sorry they won games by specifically planning around the same shortcomings he has had since bama That's smart when game-planning with a young, inexperienced QB. If we are still running the same offense with Hurts in 5 years, Ill share your concern.
May 10, 20224 yr 7 minutes ago, brkmsn said: That's smart when game-planning with a young, inexperienced QB. If we are still running the same offense with Hurts in 5 years, Ill share your concern. and at bama…and at OU. He gets one more year. He isnt worth the contract extension. They have built this roster to get the qb next yr
May 10, 20224 yr 20 minutes ago, brkmsn said: Cunningham lost more games due to injury from injuries in the pocket than due to his running. I can go back and try to repost all those videos of QBs hurting themselves with slides, but it's a waste of time. It's a nice myth to believe I suppose. RG3 can be the poster-boy for it but the truth is he was just injury prone like Troy Aikman, Jim McMahon, and Sam Bradford to name a few. As for the stats. I'm not even sure what you're talking about. Stats are an asset in discussion, but they aren't always the "tell-all." In the Denver game, I wasn't impressed with his "stats." I was impressed with his passing. The numbers mean nothing. The passes were mostly on target and on time. I believe he had the one bad throw where he hesitated just a little bit and Surtain nearly got the pick (covering Smith). Two on this team history off top of head (at work ATM so can't dig deep) is McNabb and Wentz. Also, he got picked at Denver. Can't remember the play though 16 minutes ago, brkmsn said: That's smart when game-planning with a young, inexperienced QB. If we are still running the same offense with Hurts in 5 years, Ill share your concern. If we are running the same offense week 7, he is done
Create an account or sign in to comment