What are we challenging?

The penalty got the first down right?

What did I miss?

Just now, Loosechange said:

How does this work if its overturned? We would get the ball and be pushed back? I was thinking the penalty would give them the first down automatically at first.

Was the penalty after the play? I think that would be the deterring factor.

Well, Titans fleeced is in Byard.  Guess we are even now 

1 minute ago, Portyansky said:

WHY ARE YOU CHALLENGING???? THERE WAS A PENALTY ANYWAY 

It was after the play. If replay shows he was short, the penalty would back up our offense, but still be our ball.

Just now, Loosechange said:

How does this work if its overturned? We would get the ball and be pushed back? I was thinking the penalty would give them the first down automatically at first.

Not sure but Im guessing thats what Siri is asking

Defense needs to punch them in the mouth.

Penalty after a turnover on downs shouldn't extend a drive. 

Either way, put the ref under the hood so he's forced to watch what was missed.

Just now, kiwieagle said:

Even if its after the play?

Hmmmm, if he didn't get it, penalty would be assessed after? Not sure tbh

Just now, xxeaglesfanxx said:

Was the penalty after the play? I think that would be the deterring factor.

It was after the play I believe 

Just now, EagleJoe8 said:

It was after the play. If replay shows he was short, the penalty would back up our offense, but still be our ball.

Gotcha

Why challenge? Doesn't matter if they stopped the QB sneak, the refs threw a flag on 31.

Am I wrong?

1 minute ago, kiwieagle said:

Even if its after the play?

That would be different. But the refs would find some way to give it to Dallas.

1 minute ago, Aspiritfall said:

There was a penalty it's 1st down... Byard is a moron 

If they change the call it will be our ball with -15 yards but I dont think they will

Just now, EagleFan85 said:

What are we challenging?

The penalty got the first down right?

What did I miss?

The penalty was after the play was over so Nick is challenging the spot of the ball prior to the penalty. The Eagles are going to lose a TImeout 

Just now, EazyEaglez said:

I think Sirianni just threw it to break up the flow there and settle his defense some.

Settle it for what? More wide open completions in the middle of the field.

Even if it was after a stop they won't call that because it's the Cowboys that would be hurt by the call.

Just now, Aspiritfall said:

There was a penalty it's 1st down... Byard is a moron 

It's dead ball. If they stopped them short it's instant change of possession. 15 would be walked off on eagles offense. 

Just now, EagleJoe8 said:

It was after the play. If replay shows he was short, the penalty would back up our offense, but still be our ball.

Bad challenge…won’t be enough to overturn the spot 

It won’t matter because they won’t overturn the decision on the field.

7 minutes ago, Birdman said:

Just the one with Reddick is what I remember 

Goddamn annoying, Johnson had a good series that last drive, it would nice to Desai to return the favor 

Dean has a half a sack with Cox too, but they haven’t blitzed enough and they have stupid schemes where our safeties and linebackers are covering Lamb. Desai costing us today.

Would the penalty be after the play and enforced on the Eagles after the turnover on downs? Otherwise, no reason to challenge. 

This won't be overturned. But I like the challenge. 

1 minute ago, GreenReaper said:

No, it was after the play. 

 

So it would be assesed on Eagles possession? 

 

 

BS