Hurts been in the scrum. Not like he just pushes and instantly does some butt fumble. Should have been blown dead in my opinion. Forward progress stopped. Given improper extra time attacking and mauling our QB: sure the guy finally rips the ball out. No player can guarantee perfectly to shield and hang on to the football under those conditions with an elite NFL defender athlete just freely ripping at the ball while he’s being scrummed in by practically every single player on the field at once.

Just now, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Your a Fing clown 🤡 I did watch the play your boy fumbled got knocked out by bears #26…. But even without the fumble Hurts was still going to be short and not convert on the play….

Ok so what did you see with Goedert effecting and during the play?

1 minute ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Your a Fing clown 🤡 I did watch the play your boy fumbled got knocked out by bears #26…. But even without the fumble Hurts was still going to be short and not convert on the play….

Call me names..when I wasn’t even really disagreeing with you about anything.

4 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Your a Fing clown 🤡 I did watch the play your boy fumbled got knocked out by bears #26…. But even without the fumble Hurts was still going to be short and not convert on the play….

So ok, how did the fumble happen from your viewpoint?

It took a real long time in a tight aggressive scrum with every player on the field all right there(maybe one or two guys not directly about it)

List any names of players impervious to fumbling that ball.

Hurts held on and protected it actually for a very long time in that situation. I’m saying Hurts didn’t fumble as quickly as most any other player would have. Most anybody fumbles it up within an acceptable pre-whistle time frame. Refs choked their whistles way too long…like you don’t see that ever with any other QBs that they protect so much.

14 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Ok so what did you see with Goedert effecting and during the play?

Goedert is right there behind Hurts pushing on that arm…while the defender has free shot at Hurts held up in humans scrum.

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Goedert is right there behind Hurts pushing on that arm…while the defender has free shot at Hurts held up in humans scrum.

How could anybody hold on to the ball in that?

11 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

So ok, how did the fumble happen from your viewpoint?

Doesn’t matter difference between me and you when the play negative I hold the player accountable….

Hurts got the ball ripped out he fumbled…. Saquon had the ball punched out last week from behind by Dallas he fumbled…

Making excuses for why it happens for what to make you feel better about Hurts

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

holding hurts jersey is pushing his arm got it but hey whatever excuses you need to not hold Hurts accountable what you do on all his turnovers anyway

2 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

holding hurts jersey is pushing his arm got it but hey whatever excuses you need to not hold Hurts accountable what you do on all his turnovers anyway

Fumble isn’t happening yet

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Fumble isn’t happening yet

That’s the photo when the whistle should have blown…at least by then even

5 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Doesn’t matter difference between me and you when the play negative I hold the player accountable….

Hurts got the ball ripped out he fumbled…. Saquon had the ball punched out last week from behind by Dallas he fumbled…

Making excuses for why it happens for what to make you feel better about Hurts

Difference between me and you is I don’t involve emotion so much and cloud my judgement with agenda.

6 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Doesn’t matter difference between me and you when the play negative I hold the player accountable….

Hurts got the ball ripped out he fumbled…. Saquon had the ball punched out last week from behind by Dallas he fumbled…

Making excuses for why it happens for what to make you feel better about Hurts

6 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

So this is past when the play should have been blown dead. But this isn’t anywhere around how they got the ball out from him. Much much later….

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

So this is past when the play should have been blown dead. But this isn’t anywhere around how they got the ball out from him. Much much later….

A defender comes totally free right around exactly in that hole we are looking through from that photo taken.

5 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Defender comes all the way around the scrum to freely attack Hurts completely wrapped up in the human scrum.

3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Fumble isn’t happening yet

No crap Sherlock

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

That’s the photo when the whistle should have blown…at least by then even

Whistle blows too soon not a 1st down, whistle too late fumble. It’s a hard play to officiate.

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Defender comes all the way around the scrum to freely attack Hurts completely wrapped up in the human scrum.

Do you want me to give hurts a pass for not protecting the ball through the whistle??? It isn’t going to happen Hurts himself wouldn’t give himself a pass that’s the issue nobody held accountable on this team rather scapegoat Patullo

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Defender comes all the way around the scrum to freely attack Hurts completely wrapped up in the human scrum.

Goedert is only pushing on that side of Hurts…mind you. So when the defender attacks the ball it actually becomes Goedert as a major factor against Hurts holding on to the ball when ripped at freely by an untouched defender.

1 minute ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

No crap Sherlock

Well then don’t jump the gun

Patullo sucks…. Hurts missing wide open Smith on 3rd down(Geodart even more wide open on the same play)

Patullo sucks we Smith matched up on a LB

Patullo sucks Saquon drops a easy ball in the flat

And that only a handful of the missed opportunities not bringing up the fumble in the RZ or the int into double coverage

2 minutes ago, Talkingbirds said:

Whistle blows too soon not a 1st down, whistle too late fumble. It’s a hard play to officiate.

Great point…most refs protect the other QBs much more. But..such a hard play to officiate. In hindsight at the least whistle should have blown though, you believe that’s correct?