6 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Why should we add FA? It’s nice to have proven NFL talent added to the locker room. Younger types like Godwin that can ba around long term especially

So you want to start the WR FA cycle over again? Djax and Alshon we paid for also,but you want to go back there now that we have broken free of it? Let's recall every top WR on every team was a rookie once. why can't we cultivate our own TOP WR's at rookie salary????(OH yeah we need a QB for that LOL)

10 minutes ago, stine said:

  Hurts or the RB's? Hurts can run fine. He is very good as a runner. How many times does he pass the ball for a 1st down? And of those he threw for a TD, how many were at Garbage time after the game was out of reach? After the Atlanta Game, Hurts has 10 Passing TD's and 8 Int's.

So in the first half of the giants if Ward catches the ball hitting him in the hands it would be one more TD and one less interception that happens two plays later. Watkins doesn’t stop running his route maybe one less interception. Reagor doesn’t step out of bounds for no reason another huge long TD. Smith stepped out also on a long TD. This stuff goes both ways. Not sure why you have no appreciation for how Hurts get things done. Reagor dropped two game winning TDs. Blame Hurts some more. He can’t throw because Reagor sucks.

4 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

So you want to start the WR FA cycle over again? Djax and Alshon we paid for also,but you want to go back there now that we have broken free of it? Let's recall every top WR on every team was rookie once. why can't we cultivate our own TOP WR's at rookie salary????(OH yeah we need a QB for that LOL)

Alshon helped win us a SB. TO was fantastic as well. So yep….sure do.

Seems like you are making the FA WR case for me. Rosie isn’t doing well picking WR. Rather just buy one than continue to spend all draft capital on all these.

5 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Alshon helped win us a SB. TO was fantastic as well. So yep….sure do.

They had a QB????? You're going to pay 12 million for Godwin to catch 2- 5 yard passes per game? Makes zero sense

4 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Seems like you are making the FA WR case for me. Rosie isn’t doing well picking WR. Rather just buy one than continue to spend all draft capital on all these.

Smith and Quez are fine Reagor sucks 2/3 ain't bad and he can fix that with the wilson/Olave pick

Let's recall we COULD have had JJ,Smith and Quez right now

3 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

They had a QB????? You're going to pay 12 million for Godwin to catch 2- 5 yard passes per game?

Smith and Quez are fine Reagor sucks 2/3 ain't bad and he can fix that with the wilson/Olave pick

Smith, JJAW, Quez, Reagor and Hightower…..one out of five is more what it looks like right now. Hoping Quez does come through.

IF we had a QB, Smith would be posting Chase numbers

5 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

So in the first half of the giants if Ward catches the ball hitting him in the hands it would be one more TD and one less interception that happens two plays later. Watkins doesn’t stop running his route maybe one less interception. Reagor doesn’t step out of bounds for no reason another huge long TD. Smith stepped out also on a long TD. This stuff goes both ways. Not sure why you have no appreciation for how Hurts get things done. Reagor dropped two game winning TDs. Blame Hurts some more. He can’t throw because Reagor sucks.

  Yes, you can point out these for every QB in the League.   My point is Hurts does not pan up as a passer. At least he has not done so yet. Maybe he will prove us all wrong in the next 5 games. Maybe he will stink up the joint. I will wait and see. I am not holding my breath. Yes, he is a dynamic runner. But that type of QB had not won anything yet in the NFL.

 

We took DeVonta so high also….not sure we are getting the proper value from him even.

15 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Most explosive plays in the entire league

Not as a passer lol if he wants to covert to a RB now maybe he will be elite 

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Smith, JJAW, Quez, Reagor and Hightower…..one out of five is more what it looks like right now. Hoping Quez does come through.

Smith,Quez,Reagor are the starters. BU's and special play guys are just that,so ,2/3 startees is what we have

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

We took DeVonta so high also….not sure we are getting the proper value from him even.

Because WE HAVE NO QB, we have RB who can throw a little. So you want to pay Godwin for 30 yards per game of stats?

1 minute ago, stine said:

  Yes, you can point out these for every QB in the League.   My point is Hurts does not pan up as a passer. At least he has not done so yet. Maybe he will prove us all wrong in the next 5 games. Maybe he will stink up the joint. I will wait and see. I am not holding my breath. Yes, he is a dynamic runner. But that type of QB had not won anything yet in the NFL.

 

Goes both ways obviously. Hurts is in charge of a top ten scoring team….that’s converting TDs in the Redzone. 

2 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Not as a passer lol if he wants to covert to a RB now maybe he will be elite 

He already is an elite runner. No question there.

Smith is a stud,we have no one to throw to him

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Goes both ways obviously. Hurts is in charge of a top ten scoring team

Playing the worst defenses in the league LMAO

4 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Not as a passer lol if he wants to covert to a RB now maybe he will be elite 

said this before, that I would have NP adding him to the RB room or as a ST'er

4 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Smith,Quez,Reagor are the starters. BU's and special play guys are just that,so ,2/3 startees is what we have

Like I said, looks like we are developing one in Smith. Hopeful in a second of Quez. Think the ship has sailed on Reagor unfortunately. He’s got talent though….so will suck if he clicks elsewhere.

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Like I said, looks like we are developing one in Smith. Hopeful in a second of Quez. Think the ship has sailed on Reagor unfortunately. He’s got talent though….so will suck if he clicks elsewhere.

Yeah,I think he needs replaced here. let someone else deal with the drops and crap attitude. I would call LV to replace Ruggs for a pick or player in trade

Just now, GreenbleedinNC said:

Yeah,I think he needs replaced here. let someone else deal with the drops and crap attitude. I would call LV to replace Ruggs for a pick or player in trade

Or just sign a proven quality upgrade FA. Bring in Godwin or Gallup.

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Like I said, looks like we are developing one in Smith. Hopeful in a second of Quez. Think the ship has sailed on Reagor unfortunately. He’s got talent though….so will suck if he clicks elsewhere.

BTW Wilson and Olave have terrific route trees. They are both NFL ready,so I would go that route rather than start paying FA WR's for no prodcution,until we find QB. JMO

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Or just sign a proven quality upgrade FA. Bring in Godwin or Gallup.

Once again you want to go back to the future where we pay multiple FA WR's. If we were beating top teams and it was "win now" then I could see it

C is the main position of need in the draft for me. Total stud in the Iowa Linderbaum. Not sure if he’s still on the board when we select first. Lindstrom from BC seems like the next best choice. Feels like we HAVE to get one of these two guys.

3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Or just sign a proven quality upgrade FA. Bring in Godwin or Gallup.

Both were rookies once

Just now, GreenbleedinNC said:

Once again you want to go back to the future where we pay multiple FA WR's. If we were beatin top teams and it was "win now" then I could see it

I said "or” ….just feels like we need to bring in a proven vet. He’ll likely really help our youngsters in house by showing them some of his learned craft. Because we obviously aren’t getting that part done.

1 minute ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Both were rookies once

Yep….developed elsewhere so they succeeded.

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

C is the main position of need in the draft for me. Total stud in the Iowa Linderbaum. Not sure if he’s still on the board when we select first. Lindstrom from BC seems like the next best choice. Feels like we HAVE to get one of these two guys.

Dickerson was a C. We draft C's and make them G's,but the fact is they were C's in college