10 minutes ago, Sack that QB said:

Who do you think will be the better QB in 3 years, irrespective of their team surrounding them: Justin Fields or Hurts

2 minutes ago, D-Shiznit said:

Fields wasn't a legitimate top prospect anyway; Haskins had much better film in the same program/offense

Patrick Mahomes sucked in his first playoff game

16 hours ago, Saltpeter said:

Alright boys, I'm in the mood to get roasted. My 2022 QB rankings.

https://tiermaker.com/create/nfl-qbs-tier-list-2022-23-396637

 

AR the best I’ve seen but think Herbert will surpass him to the top if he stays relatively healthy

 

 

4 Quadrants.  1 and 2 on the top; 3 and 4 on the bottom.  To get a contract extension as a starting QB you've got to be in the top 2 quadrants.

Hurts at present is much closer to Quadrant 4 than he is to Quadrant 2.  

42 minutes ago, 4for4EaglesNest said:

But you can’t have any pudding, if you don’t eat your meat.  

Charity at home?

2 hours ago, schuy7 said:

I was being sarcastic.

I was just stating facts.  Tom Brady won his first 10 playoff games before losing a game. Aaron Rodgers lost his first playoff game.  

1 hour ago, Alphagrand said:

Fields wasn't a legitimate top prospect anyway; Haskins had much better film in the same program/offense

I thought Fields was a better rated recruit out of high school.  The concern with Haskins was the lack of starts.  

1 hour ago, LeanMeanGM said:

Patrick Mahomes sucked in his first playoff game

Couldn't even get off the bench!

13 minutes ago, schuy7 said:

Couldn't even get off the bench!

Hence why he’s unproven 

1 hour ago, LeanMeanGM said:

Patrick Mahomes sucked in his first playoff game

That was his first rookie season so it doesn't count.

Just now, downundermike said:

That was his first rookie season so it doesn't count.

I can’t believe he didn’t win rookie of the year and mvp in 2018

2 hours ago, Iggles_Phan said:

You keep repeating this like it matters.  It didn't matter the first time you said it.  It matters even less now.

Nor does Hurts performance in his first PO game against a top defense.

We knew the Eagles weren't PO ready last season, nor should we have expected them to be, pre-season most expectations were for 6-7 wins.

Howie said they were rebuilding, and he said this off-season that they're still rebuilding.

So what matters this season is to improve. And we'll find out only after the season if they achieve that goal.

I mean Lawrence absolutely sucked last year (so did Wilson), so you wouldn't pick them up if they were cut?

 

10 minutes ago, austinfan said:

Nor does Hurts performance in his first PO game against a top defense.

We knew the Eagles weren't PO ready last season, nor should we have expected them to be, pre-season most expectations were for 6-7 wins.

Howie said they were rebuilding, and he said this off-season that they're still rebuilding.

So what matters this season is to improve. And we'll find out only after the season if they achieve that goal.

I mean Lawrence absolutely sucked last year (so did Wilson), so you wouldn't pick them up if they were cut?

 

They were rookies. And, drafted 1 and 2 overall, their leash is far longer and they have a far higher pedigree. They also would have an extra year of control for their contracts. So of course you’d pick them up instead

Who's the next high profile QB that ends up moving on to another team? Besides Kyler Murray.  

7 minutes ago, DEagle7 said:

Who's the next high profile QB that ends up moving on to another team? Besides Kyler Murray.  

Justin Herbert. I’m going to DM him with several burners to gaslight him into thinking he deserves better.

Just now, LeanMeanGM said:

Justin Herbert. I’m going to DM him with several burners to gaslight him into thinking he deserves better.

I know a Dolphins fan that called the Dolphins office after the Eagles pummeled them to work out a trade. He got pretty far before they caught on...like a few levels up. On top of it all, he was drunk as hell.

This is why he’s violent. 

6 minutes ago, WentzFan11 said:

This is why he’s violent. 

Even his agent is smoking him

21 minutes ago, DEagle7 said:

Who's the next high profile QB that ends up moving on to another team? Besides Kyler Murray.  

I still think there’s a chance rodgers next offseason makes a stink again and wants out. Especially if the packers regress once again. If not rodgers I could see Lamar if he doesn’t get the contract he expects. He’s on his 5th year option so he’s likely franchised next year if they don’t come together on an extension. 

8 minutes ago, WentzFan11 said:

This is why he’s violent. 

Jake Elliot killin it

43 minutes ago, austinfan said:

Nor does Hurts performance in his first PO game against a top defense.

We knew the Eagles weren't PO ready last season, nor should we have expected them to be, pre-season most expectations were for 6-7 wins.

Howie said they were rebuilding, and he said this off-season that they're still rebuilding.

So what matters this season is to improve. And we'll find out only after the season if they achieve that goal.

I mean Lawrence absolutely sucked last year (so did Wilson), so you wouldn't pick them up if they were cut?

 

No, it does matter.  It shows how far he has to go.  

 

The QB needs to improve.   BTW... Lawrence and Wilson sucked in a DIFFERENT way than Hurts. Both have a much much better arm than Hurts and don't have to rely on their legs to do everything for them.   That said, I didn't like either of them either... same as I didn't want Hurts.  

37 minutes ago, WentzFan11 said:

This is why he’s violent. 

I have no idea if I do or don’t believe that Wentz story…I lean towards bs.

But does anyone think this is some coincidence that a thing of Howie bowling with the players gets tweeted after that story broke?

1 hour ago, austinfan said:

Nor does Hurts performance in his first PO game against a top defense.

We knew the Eagles weren't PO ready last season, nor should we have expected them to be, pre-season most expectations were for 6-7 wins.

Howie said they were rebuilding, and he said this off-season that they're still rebuilding.

So what matters this season is to improve. And we'll find out only after the season if they achieve that goal.

I mean Lawrence absolutely sucked last year (so did Wilson), so you wouldn't pick them up if they were cut?

 

If everyone knew the eagles weren’t playoff ready, then why is the most persistent argument for Hurts (that he took them to the playoffs in year 2) even remotely valid?