Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

The Eagles Message Board

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Ongoing Eagles New Discussion volume 2

Featured Replies

  • Author
3 hours ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

2-7 now can we finally say this team is cooked not the end of the world to have a down season have some really promising guys.

I actually thought Milton looked solid, Lemon is starting to come into his own even though he had some drops.

The OL is bad but the more reps guys like Kendall and Bell get the better they should become

Yep we are DOA now. This was the game I was waiting for to admit it

  • Replies 78.6k
  • Views 1.7m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

Posted Images

  • Author

659204614_903767309354723_5895315746326735170_n.jpg

  • Author
2 hours ago, Penn7980 said:

I thought Siri would be fired after the 2023 season. He somehow managed to stay employed. This season though he would have a much worse situation on hand. Doubt he would be able to pull if off.

How can you judge any staff when 3/4 of your team is in the MASH tent? All their preseason plans were having all those people around. They basically had to start all over. They can't magically turn RB6 into Barkley or 2nd string WR's into Smitty. They aren't magicians. I'm curious though as to why we were hit excessively with injuries. I mean even with Hurts out if we had retained everyone else at least we could have competed

1 hour ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

How can you judge any staff when 3/4 of your team is in the MASH tent? All their preseason plans were having all those people around. They basically had to start all over. They can't magically turn RB6 into Barkley or 2nd string WR's into Smitty. They aren't magicians. I'm curious though as to why we were hit excessively with injuries. I mean even with Hurts out if we had retained everyone else at least we could have competed

Quick question... Dallas is struggling badly.... with their first string. We are on 5th string RB... 2 healthy starting OL... the TE is obviously not healthy. A QB that wasn't on the roster a month ago. Both starting WRs out.

Obviously the injuries are trickling down to special teams.

What are we expecting? We shouldn't win. Haven't put the better team on the field since week 2. Have golden opportunity here to get a great draft position next year in what is considered a very strong and deep draft ( with a bunch of already high paid college players)

Granted nobody likes losing but how can anyone be upset that Joe Milton, Elijah Mitchell, Makai Lemon, Darius Cooper, Bell, Kendall and injured Dickerson and Goedert don't look like a good offense?? I mean...fire the coach because those guys don't look good. The team lost the message... lol.... because those guys don't look good??? Lol

But Dallas with all that talent...and the Rams with all that talent.... struggle...but you know...those coaches are just so great...lol

Game Observations:

  • Hard to "really” judge Milton with who is out there with him, BUT he is the same guy I saw in college, i.e., Big arm; inaccurate, slow to process a defense. Aka, NOT the guy!

  • McKee can at least process a defense. Decent accuracy…but a statue.

  • When Baun went out, the defense REALLY dropped off!

  • Trotter had a better game, Particularly in the run game.

  • I really like Greg Olsen as a commentator, Imo, he is the best. His incite on the Eagles style of defense was interesting. I had not thought of it as such.

  • The O Line is not JUST not very good, it is BAD! As an Eagles’ fan, I/we have been spoiled with two HOFers and two guys who are in the discussion for best ever at their respective position in Kelce and Lane Johnson. The first, second, and third pick in the next draft should be offensive linemen! The guys they have just are not good. Mailata even looks paultry these last few weeks. And he is the one keeper. Landon Dickerson…he is not the same player. The other picks the team needs is an edge rusher on defense. I love Barkley, but he looks like he did in NY when their oline sucked.

  • Lemon is getting valuable experience.

  • Might as well give the kid they drafted a shot at QB. They can’t look much worse on offense.

And i WAS a huge Sixers fan when Dr J, Moses Malone, Bobby Jones, Mo Cheeks, Andrew Toney played. Screw lebron James! Wouldn’t cheer for that ….

Go Birds! 😁

Hats off to Milton for getting up quickly after getting DESTROYED by Reese. Forgot to give him kudos for that.

43 minutes ago, Senhorcook said:

Game Observations:

  • Hard to "really” judge Milton with who is out there with him, BUT he is the same guy I saw in college, i.e., Big arm; inaccurate, slow to process a defense. Aka, NOT the guy!

  • McKee can at least process a defense. Decent accuracy…but a statue.

  • When Baun went out, the defense REALLY dropped off!

  • Trotter had a better game, Particularly in the run game.

  • I really like Greg Olsen as a commentator, Imo, he is the best. His incite on the Eagles style of defense was interesting. I had not thought of it as such.

  • The O Line is not JUST not very good, it is BAD! As an Eagles’ fan, I/we have been spoiled with two HOFers and two guys who are in the discussion for best ever at their respective position in Kelce and Lane Johnson. The first, second, and third pick in the next draft should be offensive linemen! The guys they have just are not good. Mailata even looks paultry these last few weeks. And he is the one keeper. Landon Dickerson…he is not the same player. The other picks the team needs is an edge rusher on defense. I love Barkley, but he looks like he did in NY when their oline sucked.

  • Lemon is getting valuable experience.

  • Might as well give the kid they drafted a shot at QB. They can’t look much worse on offense.

I will disagree. The first, second and third picks of next years draft....should be the best player that's on the board.

There are multiple ways to acquire players....however when you are on the clock... there is a best player there. You take him. That's the foundation and core of your team. You can build around it with free agency and trades.

  • Author
4 hours ago, joemas72 said:

Quick question... Dallas is struggling badly.... with their first string. We are on 5th string RB... 2 healthy starting OL... the TE is obviously not healthy. A QB that wasn't on the roster a month ago. Both starting WRs out.

Obviously the injuries are trickling down to special teams.

What are we expecting? We shouldn't win. Haven't put the better team on the field since week 2. Have golden opportunity here to get a great draft position next year in what is considered a very strong and deep draft ( with a bunch of already high paid college players)

Granted nobody likes losing but how can anyone be upset that Joe Milton, Elijah Mitchell, Makai Lemon, Darius Cooper, Bell, Kendall and injured Dickerson and Goedert don't look like a good offense?? I mean...fire the coach because those guys don't look good. The team lost the message... lol.... because those guys don't look good??? Lol

But Dallas with all that talent...and the Rams with all that talent.... struggle...but you know...those coaches are just so great...lol

I am ok with higher draft picks now. I wanted to see this game before I tossed in the towel. No I can't judge Mannion on his plan without the people he planned around all missing. So now Hurts comes back for a year(maybe). Lemon will get better. Like to have Bark and Tank back next year. We'll just have to wait and see what Howie does now. I think O line should be a top draft need, then again are we looking at a new franchise QB? I would think we are. S also a need. Finally we got some production from Grennard. TE still also an issue in my view. So we have plenty of options to look at

On 11/2/2026 at 6:36 AM, Bleedinggreen93 said:

Obviously the more we lose the more people talk about firing Siri but the names people want Steichen, Tomlin, Flores I’m just like when has that ever been the FO type of HC hire?

Tomlin/Flores are already super unlikely just being defensive minded

Steichen is alright but Lurie/Howie tend to favor the young innovative OCs don’t usually hire the guys with a huge proven track record.

AR, Chip,Doug, Siri- the only HC hire that was big name was Chip Kelly the rest were not even being looked at as HCs

Flores just don’t see as a fit here. He’s too combative a personality. Situations he could do fine in the NFL. Not with Rosie and Lurie though. He’d be battling them through the media in record time. Could possibly argue for his past potentially reigning his personality in at this point. He can’t really afford to have a repeated massive blowup firestorm situation. Would define him permanently! Most would already rightfully attach him as being defined with that label at this point plenty through enough career track record already. Most optimistic view? Peak ceiling potential? Absolute ideal scenario?….solely reliant on that proven track record personality label completely looming…forcing him to make very sure he doesn’t even come near those lines as a coach again. Self awareness…..followed up by his understanding of absolute career survival. Forcing him while limiting his coaching powers and range.

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Flores just don’t see as a fit here. He’s too combative a personality. Situations he could do fine in the NFL. Not with Rosie and Lurie though. He’d be battling them through the media in record time. Could possibly argue for his past potentially reigning his personality in at this point. He can’t really afford to have a repeated massive blowup firestorm situation. Would define him permanently! Most would already rightfully attach him as being defined with that label at this point plenty through enough career track record already. Most optimistic view? Peak ceiling potential? Absolute ideal scenario?….solely reliant on that proven track record personality label completely looming…forcing him to make very sure he doesn’t even come near those lines as a coach again. Self awareness…..followed up by his understanding of absolute career survival. Forcing him while limiting his coaching powers and range.

He’s a good coach in so many ways I actually believe. But add in the Philly media and he’d be an absolute time bomb.

5 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

I am ok with higher draft picks now. I wanted to see this game before I tossed in the towel. No I can't judge Mannion on his plan without the people he planned around all missing. So now Hurts comes back for a year(maybe). Lemon will get better. Like to have Bark and Tank back next year. We'll just have to wait and see what Howie does now. I think O line should be a top draft need, then again are we looking at a new franchise QB? I would think we are. S also a need. Finally we got some production from Grennard. TE still also an issue in my view. So we have plenty of options to look at

They need to tear this down. They can’t bring back Jalen, Saquon and Tank next year and hope that the coaching looks better. This is a burn it to the ground and restart. All of the coaches need to go (Vic aside but he was close to retirement so he may just want out). The offense needs a complete overhaul and the defense needs significant pieces. And that’s not going to happen in one offseason so it’s going to take a couple of years.

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Flores just don’t see as a fit here. He’s too combative a personality. Situations he could do fine in the NFL. Not with Rosie and Lurie though. He’d be battling them through the media in record time. Could possibly argue for his past potentially reigning his personality in at this point. He can’t really afford to have a repeated massive blowup firestorm situation. Would define him permanently! Most would already rightfully attach him as being defined with that label at this point plenty through enough career track record already. Most optimistic view? Peak ceiling potential? Absolute ideal scenario?….solely reliant on that proven track record personality label completely looming…forcing him to make very sure he doesn’t even come near those lines as a coach again. Self awareness…..followed up by his understanding of absolute career survival. Forcing him while limiting his coaching powers and range.

Now under Tomlin he works. Possibly the only coach capable of working with him and getting his best. That’s clearly an area of Tomlin’s strength.

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Now under Tomlin he works. Possibly the only coach capable of working with him and getting his best. That’s clearly an area of Tomlin’s strength.

Tomlin has been absolutely elite at managing egos and difficult personalities on all levels.

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Tomlin has been absolutely elite at managing egos and difficult personalities on all levels.

I like Tomlin but I don’t think that’s the answer. We need a HC who can bring in an offense and can call plays. We need to be done with this merry go round of play callers. Every year pretty much we either fire because they are bad or we lose them because they are good. And it’s all because we have a HC who can’t do squat on offense or on defense.

On 11/3/2026 at 12:27 PM, Bleedinggreen93 said:

And he got fired after a 4-12 season…. Don’t really recall AR having a terrible season outside of year 1 mediocre sure but terrible no.

Again do we really think we keep Siri if this team only wins 2-4 games this year? Especially if we keep getting blown out in 2nd half’s…. If we start to show signs of life at the end of the year then yea maybe but if we continue to look like we have the last 2-3 weeks rest of the year I don’t think Siri returns

Siri clearly brings such hardship towards the O. O minds aren’t going to work under him. Had to trick Moore into it declaring he’d have full autonomy. He had top champion O returning all but one starter. He ran taking weakest job instead. Second year with that group was a great situation. Except the Siri factor. That’s exactly situations when quality OCs stick around. They know they can be more patient to take that quality opportunity instead.

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Siri clearly brings such hardship towards the O. O minds aren’t going to work under him. Had to trick Moore into it declaring he’d have full autonomy. He had top champion O returning all but one starter. He ran taking weakest job instead. Second year with that group was a great situation. Except the Siri factor. That’s exactly situations when quality OCs stick around. They know they can be more patient to take that quality opportunity instead.

Lions OC one of many examples. That’s part of how to be a successful coach.

On 11/5/2026 at 4:40 PM, GreenbleedinNC said:

Whatever. I really don't see us getting enough to warrant weakening our O line even more next year. Despite playing like trash, we still have a shot to win the division if we get guys back. We still have 1/2 a season yet to go. I'm starting to take "sandbagging" issues with Smitty and Wicks. Getting full play for 1/2 a season is BS. They could have cut off their legs and replaced them in this amount of time. WTH is going on?

I just am not seeing high odds of bright upside future left for Dickerson. He’s always been injury prone. Just feel the massive amounts his entire college and pro career just have be taking their toll.

21 minutes ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:

They need to tear this down. They can’t bring back Jalen, Saquon and Tank next year and hope that the coaching looks better. This is a burn it to the ground and restart. All of the coaches need to go (Vic aside but he was close to retirement so he may just want out). The offense needs a complete overhaul and the defense needs significant pieces. And that’s not going to happen in one offseason so it’s going to take a couple of years.

Jalen is clearly a huge question mark. Saquan just was obviously a two year work horse milk his last prime career juice player for us. Bad gamble bet how they played his situation here frankly. You know after that first season.

23 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Now under Tomlin he works. Possibly the only coach capable of working with him and getting his best. That’s clearly an area of Tomlin’s strength.

Super over rated mediocre coach king of the 8-8 season rings nothing to the table. Lucky the Eagles wouldn’t hire someone like Tomlin so no need to worry about this

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Jalen is clearly a huge question mark. Saquan just was obviously a two year work horse milk his last prime career juice player for us. Bad gamble bet how they played his situation here frankly. You know after that first season.

Jalen is a huge question mark. Do I think he’ll be back next year? Yeah I do but I don’t necessarily think with a new contract that ties us to him.

Saquon is great but he’s the wrong side of 30 and he’s got a lot of mileage on the clock. I love him for what he did in 2024 and he seems to be a great guy and a great leader. But do I think he’s going to be a key part of this team when we are contenders again? Sadly not no.

27 minutes ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:

They need to tear this down. They can’t bring back Jalen, Saquon and Tank next year and hope that the coaching looks better. This is a burn it to the ground and restart. All of the coaches need to go (Vic aside but he was close to retirement so he may just want out). The offense needs a complete overhaul and the defense needs significant pieces. And that’s not going to happen in one offseason so it’s going to take a couple of years.

I wouldn’t say burn it down but definitely need to start moving pieces that won’t be here… Saquon tough being a RB is he worth moving or just let his contract end in what 2028?

I’ve mentioned numerous guys that won’t return that we need to move.

Then you can look at Dickerson/Steen on the OL as we might not resign steen and Dickerson just looks finished.

Nolan who I’m just not sure is going to be here after next season will have value with his 5th year option plus being an edge

Ojomo talks are interesting sounds like the Jags could be in play but do we really want to trade him? Could there really be a surprise blockbuster trade for Carter for a Jeffery Simmons caliber haul of picks? ( also should allow us to retain ojomo)

Now draft time sitting in the top 10 in a strong QB class think you have to draft a QB.

Whether Hurts an Eagles next season or not be it health or trade need to secure us the QB of the future free up the cap space and let Howie rebuild a super team

1 minute ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

I wouldn’t say burn it down but definitely need to start moving pieces that won’t be here… Saquon tough being a RB is he worth moving or just let his contract end in what 2028?

I’ve mentioned numerous guys that won’t return that we need to move.

Then you can look at Dickerson/Steen on the OL as we might not resign steen and Dickerson just looks finished.

Nolan who I’m just not sure is going to be here after next season will have value with his 5th year option plus being an edge

Ojomo talks are interesting sounds like the Jags could be in play but do we really want to trade him? Could there really be a surprise blockbuster trade for Carter for a Jeffery Simmons caliber haul of picks? ( also should allow us to retain ojomo)

Now draft time sitting in the top 10 in a strong QB class think you have to draft a QB.

Whether Hurts an Eagles next season or not be it health or trade need to secure us the QB of the future free up the cap space and let Howie rebuild a super team

Why isn’t this a burn it down job?

If we look at both sides of the ball.

Offense: Major questions at QB, we very likely need to draft a QB high in the next 2 years or spend money on a FA QB or trade for one. RB like you say we either need to move Saquon or let him walk after 2028. The OL the only guy you’d keep no doubt is Mailata. Then we need 2 TEs and I’d say another really good if not elite WR. So let’s be generous that’s 8-9 guys? 4 OL (plus need depth), 2 TEs, 1 QB RB and WR.

Defense: On defense we need a stud DE, we need depth at DT, we need at least 1 LB, 1 CB and 2 Safeties. So we need 6 starters on defense.

So we probably need 15 new starters plus depth and have to hope some of the guys we have right now can be depth guys. That’s a lot.

1 hour ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:

Why isn’t this a burn it down job?

If we look at both sides of the ball.

Offense: Major questions at QB, we very likely need to draft a QB high in the next 2 years or spend money on a FA QB or trade for one. RB like you say we either need to move Saquon or let him walk after 2028. The OL the only guy you’d keep no doubt is Mailata. Then we need 2 TEs and I’d say another really good if not elite WR. So let’s be generous that’s 8-9 guys? 4 OL (plus need depth), 2 TEs, 1 QB RB and WR.

Defense: On defense we need a stud DE, we need depth at DT, we need at least 1 LB, 1 CB and 2 Safeties. So we need 6 starters on defense.

So we probably need 15 new starters plus depth and have to hope some of the guys we have right now can be depth guys. That’s a lot.

Explain a " burn it down job" ?

3 hours ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:

Offense: Major questions at QB, we very likely need to draft a QB high in the next 2 years or spend money on a FA QB or trade for one. RB like you say we either need to move Saquon or let him walk after 2028. The OL the only guy you’d keep no doubt is Mailata. Then we need 2 TEs and I’d say another really good if not elite WR. So let’s be generous that’s 8-9 guys? 4 OL (plus need depth), 2 TEs, 1 QB RB and WR.

QB is the massive question mark for sure but likely a top 5 pick with a strong QB class coming in.

OL- Mailata Kendall/Bell likely playing to early but could be fine with time. Steen not bad just do we want to pay him is the question or go younger. Really looking at 2-3 starters on the OL most likely

WR- think we are fine just need to get healthy Lemon is really shown some promise now and Smitty/Wicks both shown they can play.

TE- why I want to get Stowers on the field see what he can do.

RB- we still have Saquon and Tank behind him should be fine next year.

1 hour ago, joemas72 said:

Explain a " burn it down job" ?

Huge change. Coaches and players alike. There may only be 3 or 4 players on this roster that I wouldn’t consider trading (unless the offer was ridiculous).

3 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:

QB is the massive question mark for sure but likely a top 5 pick with a strong QB class coming in.

OL- Mailata Kendall/Bell likely playing to early but could be fine with time. Steen not bad just do we want to pay him is the question or go younger. Really looking at 2-3 starters on the OL most likely

WR- think we are fine just need to get healthy Lemon is really shown some promise now and Smitty/Wicks both shown they can play.

TE- why I want to get Stowers on the field see what he can do.

RB- we still have Saquon and Tank behind him should be fine next year.

So yeah QB is a big question.

OL… I mean I don’t rate Steen at all. Bell looks like he’s really struggling and Kendall should be a back up.

I think obviously Smitty is great, Wicks has been good, Lemon has improved but I don’t see like a top top WR there to be honest. I see a good one for sure but not elite. He’s a slot WR who plays with toughness but I’ve not even really seen a shiftiness.

TE I mean yeah sure let’s see what Stowers has? But Goedert likely goes, Mundt has been bad and Stowers is a major unknown plus is undersized for a TE. I’m certainly not relying on him.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.