November 9Nov 9 1 hour ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:Huge change. Coaches and players alike. There may only be 3 or 4 players on this roster that I wouldn’t consider trading (unless the offer was ridiculous).So yeah QB is a big question.OL… I mean I don’t rate Steen at all. Bell looks like he’s really struggling and Kendall should be a back up.I think obviously Smitty is great, Wicks has been good, Lemon has improved but I don’t see like a top top WR there to be honest. I see a good one for sure but not elite. He’s a slot WR who plays with toughness but I’ve not even really seen a shiftiness.TE I mean yeah sure let’s see what Stowers has? But Goedert likely goes, Mundt has been bad and Stowers is a major unknown plus is undersized for a TE. I’m certainly not relying on him.Again...I'll ask. Explain a burn it down job with this current team? I'll explain my question. Don't you think this happens organically? With the players at least? I mean...do you think the plan is to have Joe Milton, Elijah Mitchell, Cooper. Lemon, ... one legged Goedert and Dickerson, give Steen a new contract??? Don't you think changes are coming simply with contracts expiring? I understand your anger.. a great O mind should be able to put up points even with these levels of backups. KC, Rams, Dallas..they are completely lighting up the scoreboard with these great O minds and ( here comes more sarcasm) .. . Plus they are overcoming ALL those injuries too... 5th string players like Lamb, Luca, Rice, Walker, Pickens, Stafford etc.... but those great minds are lighting it up anyway.Again...enough happens organically. If you have been a fan of this team the last 12 years, you have seen this cycle twice already. You know the method. Contracts expire, good draft position. Cap space opens up. Old players move on. But it's not a rush job. Football has too big of a roster... you replace everything and then it's difficult to judge fringe young players. Plus you want some stability and leadership to remain and move on naturally. Examples would be Baun and Barkley. You don't move on necessarily before the season. They could be traded at the deadline next year... you work with their agents. There are relationships that the organization needs to maintain. It's how you get players to want to come here. I'm pretty sure Lurie and Howie and Co.are motivated to win. They will make the moves. But I don't think " burn to the ground " is necessary... the parts are naturally going to change.
November 9Nov 9 I guess my mindset is different because I was already expecting a transition from this current roster by 2028... I didn't expect the same QB, RB, TE,maybe Mailata and Jurgens were going to be the only 2 OL left anyway.... I was hoping Campbell and Makuba could stick....but the foundation was Davis, Carter, DeJean and Mitchell. Maybe Hunt ? So the turnover was coming. Very organically. The two major things I look at.... not paying the big QB contract and maximizing the draft the next 2 years. All the other stuff isn't as important.
November 9Nov 9 10 hours ago, joemas72 said:I will disagree. The first, second and third picks of next years draft....should be the best player that's on the board.There are multiple ways to acquire players....however when you are on the clock... there is a best player there. You take him. That's the foundation and core of your team. You can build around it with free agency and trades.College is loaded with QBs coming. Don’t see us passing that up
November 9Nov 9 6 hours ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:Jalen is a huge question mark. Do I think he’ll be back next year? Yeah I do but I don’t necessarily think with a new contract that ties us to him.Saquon is great but he’s the wrong side of 30 and he’s got a lot of mileage on the clock. I love him for what he did in 2024 and he seems to be a great guy and a great leader. But do I think he’s going to be a key part of this team when we are contenders again? Sadly not no.Wonder what the trade value could be looking like for Hurts? Big QB class coming. Which is good to find a new Qb. But lowers the vet QB market.
November 9Nov 9 1 hour ago, cunninghamtheman said:BG.com has us taking WR Jeremiah Smith first. That would be pretty sick!That would be sick but he is expected to be drafted #1 overall right now. I have us drafting our future QB1 as of right now that could change but NONE of our QBs have showed me anything worth us investing in them going forward. I give McKee the most credit he did as good as Hurts with less and a line that couldn't block for a pocket passer like Tanner. The other 2 are mobile and this offense is more built around them. Granted the Oline couldn't block my stepson's JV high school football Dline and that's without blitzing. Hurts obviously isn't the answer I think ideally you draft your future QB sit him behind Hurts for a year and build your team around him in the next two drafts.
November 9Nov 9 Author 10 hours ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:They need to tear this down. They can’t bring back Jalen, Saquon and Tank next year and hope that the coaching looks better. This is a burn it to the ground and restart. All of the coaches need to go (Vic aside but he was close to retirement so he may just want out). The offense needs a complete overhaul and the defense needs significant pieces. And that’s not going to happen in one offseason so it’s going to take a couple of years.Let me ask you. Go coach one of your college soccer teams, then play them vs Man United and tell me you can win. If you asked the staff to paint the entire Linc in 6 months using model kit brushes , do you think they could do it? No, you need the correct things to work with. If you expect to compete with 4th stringers at the NFL level you are sadly mistaken. Coaches are coaches, they are NOT highly skilled guys on the field. I do believe losing Stoutland was a mistake. Still you can't ask a coach to win with sub par players at every position. It's great experience for the new guys,but they aren't taking us to the SB. So that being said how can you rate/rank/judge any coach who you give sub par players to? Siri is the winningest coach in franchise history and that can indeed continue if you give him pro bowl caliber players. Changing coaches is NOT going to magically turn 4th stringers into pro bowlers. Did the coaches cause the injuries? Did the coaches put blood clots in Hurts veins? I am doubtful. Now if you want to blow it up and draft some top guys, then you can put Siris skills to the test, but then you would know truly if he is the problem(or Mannion). If Jalen can play in 2027, he will be the QB(because you know we're still paying him). Now move from there. There is nothing wrong with Bark or Tank that a better O line can't fix
November 9Nov 9 Author 10 hours ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:Jalen is a huge question mark. Do I think he’ll be back next year? Yeah I do but I don’t necessarily think with a new contract that ties us to him.Saquon is great but he’s the wrong side of 30 and he’s got a lot of mileage on the clock. I love him for what he did in 2024 and he seems to be a great guy and a great leader. But do I think he’s going to be a key part of this team when we are contenders again? Sadly not no.LOL he hasn't played much this year and has while not being 100%. No RB will be good if the D is in his backfield when he gets the ball. You need a hold for a RB to run through and that is not being provided by the O line(thus you see the flare screens WAY too often). We lost too many players for any skill guy to excel this year. That doesn't mean they are done and gone. bark has played a limited amount. last year he was also spelled by Tank/ Ship. He doesn't have the mileage you think because we took that off him when we got him from the Gnats. 30 is no longer old in the NFL. I'm fine with Bark and Tank next year IF we can get a better O line. Not against getting other RB's in, but we lost all those this year also. So C'mon you don't throw all the babies out with the bathwater. We need alot of help, but RB and WR would be on my back burner. We know Smitty is good, we have no clue about Wicks due to his lack of targets. Lemon should be fine, Cooper is fine as a BU. TE is a need still. O line is the biggest issue. If Hurts quits, then Milton it will be along with Payton. Now if you want to look for your next franchise QB, then do so. We need to do that either this year or next, so I fully expect we take a QB with our first pick, the we absolutely need O picks, both starters and BU's and a S somewhere fairly early on. So I'm not calling it a rebuild, more like a retooling. If you want to toss everyone out don't expect to compete for 3 years
November 9Nov 9 Author 6 hours ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:Huge change. Coaches and players alike. There may only be 3 or 4 players on this roster that I wouldn’t consider trading (unless the offer was ridiculous).So yeah QB is a big question.OL… I mean I don’t rate Steen at all. Bell looks like he’s really struggling and Kendall should be a back up.I think obviously Smitty is great, Wicks has been good, Lemon has improved but I don’t see like a top top WR there to be honest. I see a good one for sure but not elite. He’s a slot WR who plays with toughness but I’ve not even really seen a shiftiness.TE I mean yeah sure let’s see what Stowers has? But Goedert likely goes, Mundt has been bad and Stowers is a major unknown plus is undersized for a TE. I’m certainly not relying on him.Bell was SUPPOSED to sit behind LANE and LEARN this yea(but we know how that went). Of course he is struggling, C'mon now. Lemon was supposed to be worked in slowly, but when your top 2 both go down you are asking him to produce a miracle. He is learning on the job also. Who do we have at RB? RB 6/7? Yet you expect Barkley production? Not happening. I'm not destroying everything, we need guys to get healthy to see what we still have. I suspect and expect many of those to come back "online". They(WR's) will have a new QB to deal with. That Chemistry also takes time. You guys want pro production out of BU's journeymen and hurt players. you are dreaming, but you don't toss all the good players you have. Let's see if we can compete after getting some skill guys back. At that point you can begin to judge Mannion again. Right now you have no basis to do that
November 9Nov 9 Author 6 hours ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:QB is the massive question mark for sure but likely a top 5 pick with a strong QB class coming in.OL- Mailata Kendall/Bell likely playing to early but could be fine with time. Steen not bad just do we want to pay him is the question or go younger. Really looking at 2-3 starters on the OL most likelyWR- think we are fine just need to get healthy Lemon is really shown some promise now and Smitty/Wicks both shown they can play.TE- why I want to get Stowers on the field see what he can do.RB- we still have Saquon and Tank behind him should be fine next year.We see things the same
November 9Nov 9 Author 2 hours ago, DownwithDallas said:That would be sick but he is expected to be drafted #1 overall right now. I have us drafting our future QB1 as of right now that could change but NONE of our QBs have showed me anything worth us investing in them going forward. I give McKee the most credit he did as good as Hurts with less and a line that couldn't block for a pocket passer like Tanner. The other 2 are mobile and this offense is more built around them. Granted the Oline couldn't block my stepson's JV high school football Dline and that's without blitzing. Hurts obviously isn't the answer I think ideally you draft your future QB sit him behind Hurts for a year and build your team around him in the next two drafts.Yep, you me, Joe and 93 are on he same page. Siri is a CEO HC, not an effective play caller in my view(which would be a COO HC). We didn't get enough time seeing what Mannion can do(or can't),he needs players to work with. Jury on him is out until we get some of these guys back, then we can start judging how effective he is. I do like Tanner, always have, but you need a rock solid O line for him as he is a statue(see Bradford). As you said Milton and Payton are both mobile types. I would suspect we keep them both(at BU pay) and add our future QB this draft. If Hurts comes back we keep Payton on the PS. I believe we let Tanner walk(as much as I like the guy) or trade him if possible. Tanner would be a nice QB in Pittsburgh to replace ARod. So our QB's would be(with Hurts) Hurts, Milton, draft pick, Payton(on PS) Without, draft pick, Milton, Payton. All 3 of these lack experience so may as well drop the draft pick into the fire or let Milton start with the draftee taking over as the season moves along
November 9Nov 9 5 hours ago, joemas72 said:I understand your anger.. a great O mind should be able to put up points even with these levels of backups. KC, Rams, Dallas..they are completely lighting up the scoreboard with these great O minds and ( here comes more sarcasm) .. . Plus they are overcoming ALL those injuries too... 5th string players like Lamb, Luca, Rice, Walker, Pickens, Stafford etc.... but those great minds are lighting it up anywayThere’s a huge difference between what say the Giants have done this year (with a lot of injuries) and what Shanahan has done with the Niners over the last couple of years. And what Nick and this coaching staff are doing. Nobody is expecting them to win every game. At this point I don’t think we are expecting them to win any games. But to look so inept? To look so ill disciplined, so unprepared and so damn sloppy? Every single week? It’s unacceptable.
November 9Nov 9 5 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:Wonder what the trade value could be looking like for Hurts? Big QB class coming. Which is good to find a new Qb. But lowers the vet QB market.I mean I’m not sure he has much trade value? There is uncertainty about his future here, he’s out indefinitely and has a huge cap hit next year doesn’t he?
November 9Nov 9 1 hour ago, GreenbleedinNC said:Now if you want to blow it up and draft some top guys, then you can put Siris skills to the test, but then you would know truly if he is the problem(or Mannion).Oh I absolutely do not want to put his skills to the test. The clown needs to go. He is the problem. Not the only problem but he’s the biggest problem.
November 9Nov 9 Author 6 minutes ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:There’s a huge difference between what say the Giants have done this year (with a lot of injuries) and what Shanahan has done with the Niners over the last couple of years. And what Nick and this coaching staff are doing. Nobody is expecting them to win every game. At this point I don’t think we are expecting them to win any games. But to look so inept? To look so ill disciplined, so unprepared and so damn sloppy? Every single week? It’s unacceptable.Agreed, so what do you do now? Who is to blame? You can point fingers everywhere. How long did it take the Gnats to become relevant? Why are they relevant? Because they made their O line better. We don't have that. With a top notch O line even I could get a few yards. They are sloppy because you are dealing with BU's some of who have barely played an NFL game
November 9Nov 9 Author 4 minutes ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:Oh I absolutely do not want to put his skills to the test. The clown needs to go. He is the problem. Not the only problem but he’s the biggest problem.How is he the problem being the winningest coach in franchise history????? Does he lack some skills, oh yeah for sure, but you overlook all the positive stuff. Coaches need players that play. Siri bad at some things, or is that Mannion? You can point fingers,or you can man up and make things better. Name an available coach you want to get. First,he needs to be available, then he wants to coach here,then Howie and Lurie need to like them and get him. Now you have a new coach in the middle of a transition(as I call it). So who is it,Siri,Mannion, the O line coach who has no players? If you get a new coach, he may not like Mannion. I personally haven't seen alot from Mannion, but as I say we have TWO games to judge him by(before the wheels fell of) Would you feel the same if we had all our guys back and were winning?
November 9Nov 9 Author 15 minutes ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:Oh I absolutely do not want to put his skills to the test. The clown needs to go. He is the problem. Not the only problem but he’s the biggest problem.Look who we lost. A pro bowl HOF Right tackle. Musical chairs at RG(Steen seems locked in for the moment),C and LG, a stud WR, another possibly very good WR(we don't know what Wicks can do), your starting QB, a stud RB, another very good RB(Tank), another passable RB(Ship). How do you coach RB6 to be Barkley? How do you coach a ROOKIE RT who is learning on the job? You expect him to be Lane by now? You think Coop(who I love) is the same caliber player as Smitty? Wicks? How do you mix the interior linemen who by all accounts are BU's? Players matter. The coaches aren't magicians
November 9Nov 9 Blockbuster: the Jaguars are trading a 2027 first-round pick and a 2029 second-round pick to the Eagles for defensive tackle Jordan Davis, sources tell ESPN.This is the Jaguars’ third trade for a defensive player today while the Eagles now are poised to have 10 picks in the first two rounds of the next three drafts. https://www.espn.com/contributor/adam-schefter/8dd40f558e405?modifier=webview http://espn.com/app
November 9Nov 9 Just now, DownwithDallas said:Blockbuster: the Jaguars are trading a 2027 first-round pick and a 2029 second-round pick to the Eagles for defensive tackle Jordan Davis, sources tell ESPN.This is the Jaguars’ third trade for a defensive player today while the Eagles now are poised to have 10 picks in the first two rounds of the next three drafts. https://www.espn.com/contributor/adam-schefter/8dd40f558e405?modifier=webview http://espn.com/appJust came to post this nice haul for Davis honestly and let’s us resign Ojomo in the offseason
November 9Nov 9 1 minute ago, Bleedinggreen93 said:Just came to post this nice haul for Davis honestly and let’s us resign Ojomo in the offseasonI was just writing this lol
November 9Nov 9 First domino to fall is Davis have to wonder who else is going to be traded.Pure speculation but the rumor is out there that we might want Jim Schwartz back as our DC next season( especially if Vic retires) Carter/Ojomo would seem like better fits in Schwartz scheme then Davis
November 9Nov 9 1 hour ago, UK_EaglesFan89 said:There’s a huge difference between what say the Giants have done this year (with a lot of injuries) and what Shanahan has done with the Niners over the last couple of years. And what Nick and this coaching staff are doing. Nobody is expecting them to win every game. At this point I don’t think we are expecting them to win any games. But to look so inept? To look so ill disciplined, so unprepared and so damn sloppy? Every single week? It’s unacceptable.What is a lot of injuries? 6th string RB... 4th string QB not here....I mean Winston and McCarthy have been starters in the league...throwing to Nabers and likely... has the OL lost 3 starters?? Who is playing on one leg?And... of course the obvious.... the GM brings in the players... the backups. At certain times backups are better for one team because they are in the system longer... offense needs some time in the system right? Which backup players you want to compare position by position in volume...to the guys the Eagles are trotting out this year? And let me ask....would you prefer winning 10 games this year with this group? What did the Giants accomplish winning with a couple players missing?
November 9Nov 9 Author With 10 picks in 2 rounds we're going to get alot of excellent players. Pick your next franchise QB, can't rule out Smith at WR either. We should be able to land both with picks left for O line and S. GL to Davis. Edge,DT also. Howie is going to have a load of fun in this draft
November 9Nov 9 Author PhillyVoicePhiladelphia Eagles 2028 draft picksThanks to the A.J. Brown trade to New England, the Eagles already have two first-round picks in 2028.
November 9Nov 9 Author So we have alot of 2028 high picks we can use also in the 2027 draft. We're in terrific shape
Create an account or sign in to comment