October 19Oct 19 9 minutes ago, Talkingbirds said:My last sentence "France always loves a revolution, but this is mostly by their citizens.” Maybe I misread Bill’s comment, but just about any demonstration nowadays there’s going to be flags and banners representing Palestine, Iran, Mexico or the country of choice for that week. None of which has any ties to what the protest is about.Pretty sure Bill was implying these aren't French citizens because they'd be waving the flags of France if they were.
October 19Oct 19 8 hours ago, we_gotta_believe said:You think that could possibly be due, in part, to it being an anti-government protest? If you wanted to protest Lurie's management of the team, would you show up to Novacare waving an Eagles flag, or would it be a huge sign with "Fire Sirianni" scrawled across it?Ah, you're right. Right wing loonies here never traditionally show up to an anti-government protest with tons of American flags.And now that you mention it, I've never ever seen the French flag being predominantly displayed in French anti-government protests before. You'd have thought that with what I posted that I must have seen tons of photos and videos of past French protests where the French flag was predominantly waved.
October 19Oct 19 4 hours ago, Frankfurteagle89 said:Over 1800 people were arrested during the recent protests. I’m not projecting bad faith weak arguments saying that the violent part of the protests were a combination of left extremists, anarchist, people with migrant backgrounds and who ever else felt the need to take part in destroying and looting.We’ll see in the coming days when more data becomes available. ✌️You speak as if you live in Europe or something.Why can't you let American liberals educate you on this issue?
October 19Oct 19 8 hours ago, DEagle7 said:They're young white liberals waiving the Palestinian flag as a condemnation of Israel. It's not "droves of immigrants burning down France to protest immigration policy", which is the dumb narrative being pushed here and diffusely in the media.And yes young Western liberals are all on the same bandwagon with shoehorning the Palestinian flag thing into every broader protest they have. Piling on heaps of broader social social issues together is like "Young Liberals 101" and the reason they get nothing accomplished. The French just always take their protests above and beyond so it's getting more hype.You don't think that, just maybe, it could be that there was a protest with a legitimate grievance that got hijacked by radicals, leading to all of this?Not even a legitimate possibility?
October 19Oct 19 8 minutes ago, Bill said:Right wing loonies here never traditionally show up to an anti-government protest with tons of American flags.So if right wing loonies do something in the US, then the absence of that behavior in an entirely different country shall lead to the conclusion that those people aren't French citizens?Yo, I've seen some dumb logic parroted around here but this is up there with some of the dumbest. Take a step back and re-state your argument, because you look pretty stupid right now, bud.
October 19Oct 19 11 minutes ago, Bill said:You don't think that, just maybe, it could be that there was a protest with a legitimate grievance that got hijacked by radicals, leading to all of this?Not even a legitimate possibility?You seem to be confused on how burden of proof works. If your claim is that the movement was hijacked by "radical migrants" then you need to provide evidence to back it up, not asking someone else to disprove it.
October 19Oct 19 32 minutes ago, Bill said:You don't think that, just maybe, it could be that there was a protest with a legitimate grievance that got hijacked by radicals, leading to all of this?Not even a legitimate possibility?It's a protest with specific grievances that others gave piled on additional grievances on top of absolutely. I already said that the old yellow vest labor guys have joined in. Won't comment of legitimacy either way. But I have seen zero evidence that these protests have any significant pro immigrants demands, nor that the agitators are composed disproportionately in any significant way of immigrants like Vance et al suggested.
October 19Oct 19 Like as of right now the best I can tell is that the "evidence" for immigrants specifically causing problems at these protests is 1) that the most violent protest-loving country on the planet is violently protesting and 2) there are a lot of Palestinian flags at the protests, a country from which there are a negligible number of immigrants in France. If there's something else please enlighten me. Otherwise I'm gonna go out on a limb and assume JD Vance remains full of sheet.
October 19Oct 19 Interesting discussion here. All we can say is that we don't know yet who is behind the violence and destruction though we are absolutely certain the vast majority of protesters are simply normal French student youth.What we can also say is that many countries in Europe, including France and Germany, have real problems with the large numbers of immigrants that have come into the country over the last couple decades and not assimilated into the local culture. Those problems are real and have zero to do with racism though they can be and have been made worse thru racism. There is no evidence that these issues have contributed to the recent mayhem yet there is no clear evidence that they have not contributed, i.e. we need more info to be able to understand the nuances (here we go with that word again).
October 19Oct 19 fwiw - I just read some Swedish reports of the trouble over the weekend in Paris. They suggest that while 100k people were involved, there were approx 2000 masked people dressed in all black. There are no conclusions yet as to who those masked people were but the suspicion is the far left. If that is the case then you'd expect a mix of people in that group.
October 19Oct 19 1 hour ago, DrPhilly said:Interesting discussion here. All we can say is that we don't know yet who is behind the violence and destruction though we are absolutely certain the vast majority of protesters are simply normal French student youth.What we can also say is that many countries in Europe, including France and Germany, have real problems with the large numbers of immigrants that have come into the country over the last couple decades and not assimilated into the local culture. Those problems are real and have zero to do with racism though they can be and have been made worse thru racism. There is no evidence that these issues have contributed to the recent mayhem yet there is no clear evidence that they have not contributed, i.e. we need more info to be able to understand the nuances (here we go with that word again).Pick a side coward. You either love communism or hate brown people.
October 20Oct 20 8 minutes ago, Gannan said:Fake assassination attempt was right on time. At least some things never changeIs it an attempt if it was just words online ?
October 20Oct 20 26 minutes ago, Talkingbirds said:Is it an attempt if it was just words online ?For Trumps purposes, probably
October 20Oct 20 23 minutes ago, Dave Moss said:An assassination attempt would certainly boost Republicans chancesBecause if it succeeds voters can no longer pretend Trump is on the ballot?
October 20Oct 20 Who would have guessed the seditious traitor who tried to overthrow the government and currentlyresides in the Oval Office would be a Russian asset?? Oh, thats right Hillary Clinton 10 fng years ago but yeah keep slurping it up Trump-pets. Soon you will be eating goulash like you always dreamed of. Vote blue if nothing else but to put a check on this lunatic
October 20Oct 20 12 hours ago, we_gotta_believe said:So if right wing loonies do something in the US, then the absence of that behavior in an entirely different country shall lead to the conclusion that those people aren't French citizens?Yo, I've seen some dumb logic parroted around here but this is up there with some of the dumbest. Take a step back and re-state your argument, because you look pretty stupid right now, bud.No, you stated that people don't bring flags to an anti-government protest.I provided a local example of such conduct.Then I went on about how in French protests they wave the French flag all the time. Except after the first few days of this one, for some reason.
October 20Oct 20 12 hours ago, we_gotta_believe said:You seem to be confused on how burden of proof works. If your claim is that the movement was hijacked by "radical migrants" then you need to provide evidence to back it up, not asking someone else to disprove it.Yeah, my burden of proof is on the news.
October 20Oct 20 12 hours ago, DEagle7 said:It's a protest with specific grievances that others gave piled on additional grievances on top of absolutely. I already said that the old yellow vest labor guys have joined in. Won't comment of legitimacy either way. But I have seen zero evidence that these protests have any significant pro immigrants demands, nor that the agitators are composed disproportionately in any significant way of immigrants like Vance et al suggested.The initial protest demands were legitimate, as France has royally Fd over the youth with how they reconfigured their second level educational system.The overwhelming majority of the violence occurring is due to other actors, namely immigrants, not the students. There's a difference between getting sprayed with a water cannon when you won't disperse (traditional French protests about a one cent increase to the price of a baguette, and getting sprayed with a water cannon because everything not tied down is getting looted and everything tied down is getting smashed.
October 20Oct 20 13 hours ago, Bill said:You speak as if you live in Europe or something.Why can't you let American liberals educate you on this issue?You speak as if we don’t have the same access to information as someone who lives in Europe.
October 20Oct 20 2 minutes ago, Tnt4philly said:You speak as if we don’t have the same access to information as someone who lives in Europe.Unless you're watching European news all day, you kinda don't.Plus he's got, you know, anecdotal evidence.
October 20Oct 20 33 minutes ago, Bill said:Yeah, my burden of proof is on the news.Think about this logic for a minute and maybe you will see its flaws.
October 20Oct 20 12 minutes ago, Bill said:Unless you're watching European news all day, you kinda don't.Plus he's got, you know, anecdotal evidence.You don’t have to watch the news all day to get a grip on current events. Again, it’s 2026, we all have access to the same information and news as anyone else. And again, the news is not the best place to get evidence and requires "fact checking.”
Create an account or sign in to comment