October 19Oct 19 1 minute ago, NOTW said:Makes sense (even if these are AI/fake, still funny ok!)Ok that last one is funny as hell at least
October 19Oct 19 16 minutes ago, DEagle7 said:It no, but but they smashed and burned many businesses/properties. It's not like this is dramatically worse. You're grading on a scale when it comes to French protests.Again I'm asking for proof of immigrant involvement here, not made up numbers and flags. Because arrest data and reports from the ground don't support that claim at all and I find it is usually pushed by people who have an axe to grind here. Again, show me data.Nope, I don’t have specific numbers, either way. Do youths from immigrants count?! Many of these have been left behind and are living in city areas where the police does not want to drive through. Look, the narrative that these protests are because of immigration wasn’t my point, but some were definitely involved in the looting and destruction. It surely wasn’t done only by young white liberals looking for a better life. It’s a combination. No matter, they all need to be tossed in prison. I’m talking about the criminal protesters.
October 19Oct 19 Just now, Frankfurteagle89 said:Nope, I don’t have specific numbers, either way. Do youths from immigrants count?! Many of these have been left behind and are living in city areas where the police does not want to drive through. Look, the narrative that these protests are because of immigration wasn’t my point, but some were definitely involved in the looting and destruction. It surely wasn’t done only by young white liberals looking for a better life. It’s a combination. No matter, they all need to be tossed in prison. I’m talking about the criminal protesters.Again that should be easy enough to demonstrate then. Because all I've heard so far is "feels and flags", which seems like nonsense propaganda compared to arrest records and reports on the ground.Look I've got no issues if you have immigrant beef in your country.thats your prerogative. But projecting that onto other situations using bad faith weak arguments is just dumb. "Oh no the French are protesting aggressively!!!" Clutches Pearls
October 19Oct 19 21 minutes ago, DEagle7 said:Again that should be easy enough to demonstrate then. Because all I've heard so far is "feels and flags", which seems like nonsense propaganda compared to arrest records and reports on the ground.Look I've got no issues if you have immigrant beef in your country.thats your prerogative. But projecting that onto other situations using bad faith weak arguments is just dumb. "Oh no the French are protesting aggressively!!!" Clutches Pearls Over 1800 people were arrested during the recent protests. I’m not projecting bad faith weak arguments saying that the violent part of the protests were a combination of left extremists, anarchist, people with migrant backgrounds and who ever else felt the need to take part in destroying and looting.We’ll see in the coming days when more data becomes available. ✌️
October 19Oct 19 2 minutes ago, Frankfurteagle89 said:Over 1800 people were arrested during the recent protests. I’m not projecting bad faith weak arguments saying that the violent part of the protests were a combination of left extremists, anarchist, people with migrant backgrounds and who ever else felt the need to take part in destroying and looting.We’ll see in the coming days when more data becomes available. ✌️You are though, because you admit you have no data to back up that claim. "It feels like it's probably immigrants because I know I don't like them in my country" is the definition of projection.
October 19Oct 19 1 hour ago, Phillyterp85 said:Never said people waving palestinian flags during the riots are from palestine. You created an analogy, saying that if eagles fans were protesting against Lurie, they wouldn't show up with Eagles flags. But instead show up with something like a sign saying "fire Siriani". You seeing a bunch of signs saying "Macron resign" at these riots?As I already said, I may be incorrect regarding the demographic makeup of the rioters. That's fine. If these riots are actually being carried out by young French citizens, then France has an even bigger problem on their hands.Digging in again per usual, eh?Let's go at this another way since it's becoming more and more likely that you once again fell for another right wing talking point...First explain your rationale for framing the Palestinian flag as a rival of France. What specifically about Palestine makes your implication valid that they are the Cowboys fans in contrast to the Eagles fans of French citizens.Then please provide a link to an article that backs up your earlier claim that these riots are being carried out by "large groups of migrants."
October 19Oct 19 Just now, DEagle7 said:You are though, because you admit you have no data to back up that claim. "It feels like it's probably immigrants because I know I don't like them in my country" is the definition of projection.Nah, I’ve never said I don’t like "them” here. I’ve got plenty with a migrant background in my social circle and also at work. I know it’s always easy to claim someone is an immigrant hater when mass immigration is not viewed positively. And no, it doesn’t feel like some migrants / immigrants were involved. Does that make the protest a protest about immigration? No, it’s still a student protest because of high prices, bad schools etc.. So do you have numbers that it was just white young liberals rioting? Let’s see when the numbers come out where the rioters are from. Which city districts from Paris and Marseille they are from.
October 19Oct 19 1 hour ago, Phillyterp85 said:, I was told that French people wouldn't wave French flags during anti-government protests....No, you were told that absence of French flags does not automatically equate with the perpetrators being "large groups of migrants". Spend more time reading, less time listening to whatever your sources are that are indistinguishable from Sean Hannity.
October 19Oct 19 As a reminder, this is what I responded to from Bill:"For the French being French, not seeing many French flags being waved at their protests."By this logic, the civil rights protesters in the 60's must not have been American because we didn't see many American flags being waved at their protests. See how retarded that sounds?
October 19Oct 19 6 minutes ago, Frankfurteagle89 said:Nah, I’ve never said I don’t like "them” here.I’ve got plenty with a migrant background in my social circle and also at work. I know it’s always easy to claim someone is an immigrant hater when mass immigration is not viewed positively.And no, it doesn’t feel like some migrants / immigrants were involved. Does that make the protest a protest about immigration? No, it’s still a student protest because of high prices, bad schools etc..So do you have numbers that it was just white young liberals rioting? Let’s see when the numbers come out where the rioters are from. Which city districts from Paris and Marseille they are from. so because you have nothing, now you're turning it around on me to prove a negative and backtracked to "well now let's be patient and wait and see" after going all in on Vance's statement earlier. Classic. By all available reports the largest demographic of protestors are highschool/college kids. There are also union workers, laborist party members and old yellow vest vets that have joined as it became a bigger movement. All with stated purposes of protesting quality of life, school, Israel, specific taxes, vacation mandates, Macron etc etc. There is nothing available right now that points to any strong pro/anti immigrants demands from the protestors or a specific ethnic demographic available that shows any particular group participating in a disproportionate fashion outside of "young and liberal". None. So take your own advice and maybe take a beat before trying to twist this into your own personal narrative. Furthermore I have I have plenty of family and friends in france who again are laughing at the narratives being pushed by Vance and other idiots. Several who work in the media. Most of whom are not sympathetic towards the protestors. One even asked a mutual German friend for a flammenwefer to "clear out all the art students".
October 19Oct 19 1 hour ago, Phillyterp85 said:You seeing a bunch of signs saying "Macron resign" at these riots?This good enough for you?Licensable picture: FRANCE-WOMAN-HOLDING-HANDMADE-CARDBOARD-SIGN-CRITICIZING-MACRON-BUDGET-POLICY-AT-DEMONSTRATION-IN-PARIS-2026 | Reuters Connect https://share.google/nyUPUBv1FxsCw61llhttps://www.euronews.com/2026/10/18/looting-and-buildings-ablaze-frances-violent-saturday-protests-in-10-pictures
October 19Oct 19 6 minutes ago, we_gotta_believe said:This good enough for you?Licensable picture: FRANCE-WOMAN-HOLDING-HANDMADE-CARDBOARD-SIGN-CRITICIZING-MACRON-BUDGET-POLICY-AT-DEMONSTRATION-IN-PARIS-2026 | Reuters Connect https://share.google/nyUPUBv1FxsCw61llhttps://www.euronews.com/2026/10/18/looting-and-buildings-ablaze-frances-violent-saturday-protests-in-10-picturesRadical jihadist identified. I change my stance.
October 19Oct 19 54 minutes ago, we_gotta_believe said:Digging in again per usual, eh?Let's go at this another way since it's becoming more and more likely that you once again fell for another right wing talking point...First explain your rationale for framing the Palestinian flag as a rival of France. What specifically about Palestine makes your implication valid that they are the Cowboys fans in contrast to the Eagles fans of French citizens.Then please provide a link to an article that backs up your earlier claim that these riots are being carried out by "large groups of migrants."Oh for f-cks sake this doesn't need to be turned into a phd project. I assumed that people who were destroying property and destroying historical buildings while running around waving Palestine flags were not citizens of France and instead were immigrants to the country. No problem admitting I'm wrong and that these people are French citizens.
October 19Oct 19 30 minutes ago, DEagle7 said: so because you have nothing, now you're turning it around on me to prove a negative and backtracked to "well now let's be patient and wait and see" after going all in on Vance's statement earlier. Classic.By all available reports the largest demographic of protestors are highschool/college kids. There are also union workers, laborist party members and old yellow vest vets that have joined as it became a bigger movement. All with stated purposes of protesting quality of life, school, Israel, specific taxes, vacation mandates, Macron etc etc. There is nothing available right now that points to any strong pro/anti immigrants demands from the protestors or a specific ethnic demographic available that shows any particular group participating in a disproportionate fashion outside of "young and liberal". None. So take your own advice and maybe take a beat before trying to twist this into your own personal narrative.Furthermore I have I have plenty of family and friends in france who again are laughing at the narratives being pushed by Vance and other idiots. Several who work in the media. Most of whom are not sympathetic towards the protestors. One even asked a mutual German friend for a flammenwefer to "clear out all the art students".Ok - good points.👍 No further discussion needed.✌️
October 19Oct 19 24 minutes ago, we_gotta_believe said:As a reminder, this is what I responded to from Bill:"For the French being French, not seeing many French flags being waved at their protests."By this logic, the civil rights protesters in the 60's must not have been American because we didn't see many American flags being waved at their protests.See how retarded that sounds?You’re talking about the 60’s, different times then. I’m sure there were a few Confederate flags and maybe some white hooded goons rioting and burning. Maybe a Cuban, Puerto Rican, Viet Cong or the Red power flag for Native Americans, but I doubt it. IMO a bit of a poor analogy for what’s happening in France now. I tend to agree with Bill somewhat. France always loves a revolution, but this is mostly by their citizens.
October 19Oct 19 14 minutes ago, Phillyterp85 said:I assumedYou would think that when so many of your assumptions are being proven false lately, you'd stop and consider why that might be happening.
October 19Oct 19 8 minutes ago, Talkingbirds said:You’re talking about the 60’s, different times then. I’m sure there were a few Confederate flags and maybe some white hooded goons rioting and burning. Maybe a Cuban, Puerto Rican, Viet Cong or the Red power flag for Native Americans, but I doubt it. IMO a bit of a poor analogy for what’s happening in France now. I tend to agree with Bill somewhat. France always loves a revolution, but this is mostly by their citizens.My point is that it's perfectly plausible to see people protesting their own government while not actively waving the flag of that very same government. It's really not that big a leap. And it certainly doesn't automatically equate with those protestors being "large groups of migrants" as was being claimed. As I said to Terp, if you or @Bill has some credible reporting that proves this claim to be true, then let's see it.
October 19Oct 19 2 hours ago, Alpha_TATEr said:more promises kept !!!that's a nice shirt @Procusc'mon @Procus, don't act like you wouldn't. considering how much you fire off knuckle children over obama, there's a -1000000000000% chance you don't dream of downing some daddy juice.
October 19Oct 19 2 hours ago, we_gotta_believe said:My point is that it's perfectly plausible to see people protesting their own government while not actively waving the flag of that very same government. It's really not that big a leap. And it certainly doesn't automatically equate with those protestors being "large groups of migrants" as was being claimed. As I said to Terp, if you or @Bill has some credible reporting that proves this claim to be true, then let's see it.My last sentence "France always loves a revolution, but this is mostly by their citizens.” Maybe I misread Bill’s comment, but just about any demonstration nowadays there’s going to be flags and banners representing Palestine, Iran, Mexico or the country of choice for that week. None of which has any ties to what the protest is about.
Create an account or sign in to comment