July 21, 20251 yr 4 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Still chippin away!Dude, give it up. They said they would save 2T and all audits of their work puts it at about 50B. A massive marketing campaign and not much savings from a relative perspective. Instead, the BBB will add on 5T+ to the deficit. What a load of BS.
July 21, 20251 yr 44 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Still chippin away!The BBB pretty much destroys this effort. Played yourself again.
July 21, 20251 yr 2 hours ago, DrPhilly said:Dude, give it up. They said they would save 2T and all audits of their work puts it at about 50B. A massive marketing campaign and not much savings from a relative perspective. Instead, the BBB will add on 5T+ to the deficit. What a load of BS.And you said they were dead and would dissolve
July 21, 20251 yr 9 minutes ago, The Norseman said:And you said they were dead and would dissolveYes I did and I was right.
July 21, 20251 yr 39 minutes ago, The Norseman said:And you said they were dead and would dissolveWhat I said was that the work would grind to a pittance (I never said that the entity DOGE would be dissolved) and the key Musk whiz kids would be gone by the fall. Big Ballz resigned end of June. I don't know about the others but no way they stick around DOGE for long. In addition, clearly all the momentum of DOGE is gone.DOGE was a big success in terms of the shock and awe effect Trump was looking for early on. All that is dead and buried and with very minor actual numerical results to show for all the hype.
July 21, 20251 yr 47 minutes ago, The Norseman said:And you said they were dead and would dissolveOh yeah, they are really alive and kickin' alright. Look at those results! Undeniable.
July 22, 20251 yr 4 hours ago, Paul852 said:Oh yeah, they are really alive and kickin' alright. Look at those results! Undeniable.They saved $2 trillion!!!!
July 22, 20251 yr 14 hours ago, DrPhilly said:What I said was that the work would grind to a pittance (I never said that the entity DOGE would be dissolved) and the key Musk whiz kids would be gone by the fall. Big Ballz resigned end of June. I don't know about the others but no way they stick around DOGE for long. In addition, clearly all the momentum of DOGE is gone.DOGE was a big success in terms of the shock and awe effect Trump was looking for early on. All that is dead and buried and with very minor actual numerical results to show for all the hype.But it hasn't ground to a pittance. The structure they set up in the agencies continues and their efforts are being recorded on the Doge website daily. Contracts are being cancelled, fraud and inefficiencies are being identified and rooted out. The pace of savings looks to be about the same as it was before. Clearly they didn't hit their 2T target, but the initiative is alive and well.
July 22, 20251 yr 5 minutes ago, The Norseman said:But it hasn't ground to a pittance. The structure they set up in the agencies continues and their efforts are being recorded on the Doge website daily. Contracts are being cancelled, fraud and inefficiencies are being identified and rooted out. The pace of savings looks to be about the same as it was before.Clearly they didn't hit their 2T target, but the initiative is alive and well.Of course it has gone down to a normal level (pittance) of review. Do you think contracts were never reviewed/cancelled before DOGE? The speed and scope of the first few months is totally gone.
July 22, 20251 yr 24 minutes ago, DrPhilly said:Of course it has gone down to a normal level (pittance) of review. Do you think contracts were never reviewed/cancelled before DOGE? The speed and scope of the first few months is totally gone.Just because you keep saying a thing doesn't make it true. They've tacked on $10B since Musk left and each agency continues to post savings against their targets daily. Maybe it has slowed a little, but not by much. I'm sure contracts were cancelled in the past, but not nearly at the pace that they set up new ones.The initiative that was set up and institutionalized continues.
July 22, 20251 yr They took an existing agency that was already doing these things, slapped a meme name on it, paraded early cuts around like a win, savings revert to the norm and Elon bolts before the impacts of the early cuts are understood. #winning.
July 22, 20251 yr 15 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Just because you keep saying a thing doesn't make it true. They've tacked on $10B since Musk left and each agency continues to post savings against their targets daily. Maybe it has slowed a little, but not by much. I'm sure contracts were cancelled in the past, but not nearly at the pace that they set up new ones.The initiative that was set up and institutionalized continues.Again, the special part about DOGE was the speed and scale. There has always been a group working on cutting govt contracts and costs. There is absolutely nothing new at all about that.Overall, a left over advertised savings of 10B (more likely 2.5B if they continue with their 25% of real vs. advertised savings) after the initial shock&awe drive isn't representative of any furthered or continued advanced momentum. The more important topic is the overall picture where Trump adds trillions to the deficit while "saving" 10s of Billion. How you can't understand this is beyond me.
July 22, 20251 yr 4 hours ago, DrPhilly said:Again, the special part about DOGE was the speed and scale. There has always been a group working on cutting govt contracts and costs. There is absolutely nothing new at all about that.Overall, a left over advertised savings of 10B (more likely 2.5B if they continue with their 25% of real vs. advertised savings) after the initial shock&awe drive isn't representative of any furthered or continued advanced momentum. The more important topic is the overall picture where Trump adds trillions to the deficit while "saving" 10s of Billion. How you can't understand this is beyond me.Cementing the current tax rates and not letting them expire is not "new spending", despite what the CBO has led you to believe. And no, Doge set up a structure within each agency to cut waste and to publicly track their progress which was not in place before. That process will continue and I will regularly remind you of their ongoing efforts.
July 22, 20251 yr 56 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Cementing the current tax rates and not letting them expire is not "new spending", despite what the CBO has led you to believe. And no, Doge set up a structure within each agency to cut waste and to publicly track their progress which was not in place before. That process will continue and I will regularly remind you of their ongoing efforts.Where did I say anything about "new spending"? What I said was that the deficit would be increasing and that is not what Trump campaigned on and totally runs counter to any concept of DOGE savings having any real impact.You say you're an expert at managing company processes to align financial solvency so you surely understand the concept of adding to the debt by an amount that is 20x greater than the amount you say you are saving.
July 22, 20251 yr 24 minutes ago, DrPhilly said:Where did I say anything about "new spending"? What I said was that the deficit would be increasing and that is not what Trump campaigned on and totally runs counter to any concept of DOGE savings having any real impact.You say you're an expert at managing company processes to align financial solvency so you surely understand the concept of adding to the debt by an amount that is 20x greater than the amount you say you are saving.The CBO erroneously calls it "spending" because the tax cuts were set to expire. He campaigned on keeping the tax rates static, which he did. The fact that that deficit continues to increase has far more to do with our overruns on entitlements and current interest rates than it does our current tax structure.
July 22, 20251 yr 1 hour ago, The Norseman said:Cementing the current tax rates and not letting them expire is not "new spending", despite what the CBO has led you to believe. And no, Doge set up a structure within each agency to cut waste and to publicly track their progress which was not in place before. That process will continue and I will regularly remind you of their ongoing efforts.Making more permanent the tax cuts that were set to expire adds to the deficit and debt. Whether you call it spending or whatever, it means more debt. That debt represents a cost to the nation and the future.
July 22, 20251 yr 1 hour ago, JohnSnowsHair said:Making more permanent the tax cuts that were set to expire adds to the deficit and debt. Whether you call it spending or whatever, it means more debt. That debt represents a cost to the nation and the future.Keeping the tax baseline the same isn't an addition, the debt increases due to our unwillingness to cut spending.
July 22, 20251 yr 34 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Keeping the tax baseline the same isn't an addition, the debt increases due to our unwillingness to cut spending.It's a factor of both. Cut taxes if you want, but cut spending accordingly to reduce the deficit.To cut taxes and increase spending concurrently is reckless. And it's exactly what has happened the last three Republican administrations. It's not ok. And it's irresponsible to keep voting for it.
July 22, 20251 yr 2 hours ago, The Norseman said:The CBO erroneously calls it "spending" because the tax cuts were set to expire. He campaigned on keeping the tax rates static, which he did. The fact that that deficit continues to increase has far more to do with our overruns on entitlements and current interest rates than it does our current tax structure.When a contract ends it ends and a new contract starts should one choose to go that direction. There is no way you can logically argue that an extension isn't new spending. In any case, the fact remains that the deficit will increase under Trump and you can argue why until the cows come home.
July 23, 20251 yr 15 hours ago, DrPhilly said:When a contract ends it ends and a new contract starts should one choose to go that direction. There is no way you can logically argue that an extension isn't new spending. In any case, the fact remains that the deficit will increase under Trump and you can argue why until the cows come home.Well, its not new spending. In fact, it's not spending at all. And pretending like its some affront to our already out of control spending problem is partisan nonsense. Love it or hate it, he was elected on it and had to deliver.
July 23, 20251 yr 16 hours ago, JohnSnowsHair said:It's a factor of both.Cut taxes if you want, but cut spending accordingly to reduce the deficit.To cut taxes and increase spending concurrently is reckless. And it's exactly what has happened the last three Republican administrations.It's not ok. And it's irresponsible to keep voting for it.Right, Democrats have done such a good job controlling spending and reforming entitlements that they are a much better option.
July 23, 20251 yr Just now, The Norseman said:Well, its not new spending. In fact, it's not spending at all. And pretending like its some affront to our already out of control spending problem is partisan nonsense. Love it or hate it, he was elected on it and had to deliver.I can agree it isn't "spending" if that makes you feel good. It is most certainly new policy in any case. The old policy terminated.
Create an account or sign in to comment