July 23, 20251 yr 20 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Right, Democrats have done such a good job controlling spending and reforming entitlements that they are a much better option.They've done better on reducing the deficit going back to Reagan.All you're focused on is spending. That's only half the equation when it comes to deficits, and frankly Republicans have not eliminated spending since the early 1990s. They're every bit the spenders Democrats are.
July 23, 20251 yr 1 hour ago, JohnSnowsHair said:They've done better on reducing the deficit going back to Reagan.All you're focused on is spending. That's only half the equation when it comes to deficits, and frankly Republicans have not eliminated spending since the early 1990s. They're every bit the spenders Democrats are.Very difficult to to stop "spending" when the bulk of it is it's mandatory interest and nobody on either side seems to be invested in legislating a solution. That being said, the numbers don't lie and Republicans have not been good either, I agree. Interestingly, however, the recent times of deficit reduction seem to have more correlation to a very strong economies than they do anything else. It will be interesting to see how the current strong economy affects the deficit....especially since revenues are projected to improve via tariffs, regulation reduction, low taxes and some onshoring.
July 23, 20251 yr 13 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Very difficult to to stop "spending" when the bulk of it is it's mandatory interest and nobody on either side seems to be invested in legislating a solution. That being said, the numbers don't lie and Republicans have not been good either, I agree.Interestingly, however, the recent times of deficit reduction seem to have more correlation to a very strong economies than they do anything else. It will be interesting to see how the current strong economy affects the deficit....especially since revenues are projected to improve via tariffs, regulation reduction, low taxes and some onshoring.I’d rather see a flat tax on income and very few deductions than a flat tax via VAT.
July 23, 20251 yr 3 minutes ago, DrPhilly said:I’d rather see a flat tax on income and very few deductions than a flat tax via VAT.Me too. But accountant's vote and have a strong lobby.
July 23, 20251 yr The idea that there is "no new spending" is absurd. ICE is getting 75 billion in new spending. Boarder enforcement in general is getting 170 billion in new spending. Justify it however you want. Do whatever mental gymnastics you need to do to convince yourself it isn't new spending, but it's more spending on things than were spent previously....aka new spending.
July 23, 20251 yr 26 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Very difficult to to stop "spending" when the bulk of it is it's mandatory interest and nobody on either side seems to be invested in legislating a solution. That being said, the numbers don't lie and Republicans have not been good either, I agree.Interestingly, however, the recent times of deficit reduction seem to have more correlation to a very strong economies than they do anything else. It will be interesting to see how the current strong economy affects the deficit....especially since revenues are projected to improve via tariffs, regulation reduction, low taxes and some onshoring.the total number of dollars we'll get from tariffs is still going to be a drop in the bucket compared to other revenue streams. the extension of the tax cut obliterates it. revenues do not go up when taxes are cut. the Laffer curve is not a line, it's a curve - and just like cutting the price on something will increase sales volume, at some point the cut is past the point of maximizing profits. based on history of tax cuts going back to Bush 43 it's quite clear that tax cuts do not increase revenues at current tax rates. it worked to some degree for Reagan because the tax rates being cut were much higher. but we've already gotten the most out of it we can and tax cuts now simply cut revenue without returning the growth that offsets the loss. so as I said: cut taxes if you so desire, but cut spending too - which means entitlement reform, which Republicans show no greater appetite for than Dems.
July 23, 20251 yr 1 minute ago, Gannan said:The idea that there is "no new spending" is absurd. ICE is getting 75 billion in new spending. Boarder enforcement in general is getting 170 billion in new spending. Justify it however you want. Do whatever mental gymnastics you need to do to convince yourself it isn't new spending, but it's more spending on things than were spent previously....aka new spending.Nobody said there was no new spending. The argument was about whether keeping the tax code static should be considered spending or not. And if you're upset about the money we now need to spend on border enforcement, you can thank Joe Biden.
July 23, 20251 yr 32 minutes ago, The Norseman said:the current strong economyInteresting. Did it only become strong recently or was it strong last year too?
July 23, 20251 yr 1 minute ago, JohnSnowsHair said:the total number of dollars we'll get from tariffs is still going to be a drop in the bucket compared to other revenue streams. the extension of the tax cut obliterates it.revenues do not go up when taxes are cut. the Laffer curve is not a line, it's a curve - and just like cutting the price on something will increase sales volume, at some point the cut is past the point of maximizing profits. based on history of tax cuts going back to Bush 43 it's quite clear that tax cuts do not increase revenues at current tax rates.it worked to some degree for Reagan because the tax rates being cut were much higher. but we've already gotten the most out of it we can and tax cuts now simply cut revenue without returning the growth that offsets the loss.so as I said: cut taxes if you so desire, but cut spending too - which means entitlement reform, which Republicans show no greater appetite for than Dems.Tax cuts by themselves may not, but simultaneously slashing regulations and favoring US business might. We shall see.
July 23, 20251 yr 1 minute ago, we_gotta_believe said:Interesting. Did it only become strong recently or was it strong last year too?Has been strong for quite some time. Nobody is assigning soul responsibility to Trump, so you can just calm down.
July 23, 20251 yr Just now, The Norseman said:Has been strong for quite some time. Nobody is assigning soul responsibility to Trump, so you can just calm down.
July 23, 20251 yr 53 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Tax cuts by themselves may not, but simultaneously slashing regulations and favoring US business might. We shall see.we 'slashed regulations' from 2017-2020 purportedly. where were all the new regulations strangling GDP growth under Biden?what remains to be seen is what the deep cuts to DOL, DOE, and the suspension of much research spend is going to cost us in the long term. I suspect especially the latter, which is surrendering the US position as the world's foremost nation in research & development and drawing talented individuals from around the world, is going to cost this nation dearly in the coming decades.but what does Trump care? he won't be here. as always he only cares about right now.
July 23, 20251 yr 1 hour ago, The Norseman said:Nobody said there was no new spending. The argument was about whether keeping the tax code static should be considered spending or not.And if you're upset about the money we now need to spend on border enforcement, you can thank Joe Biden.Right but it is most certainly "new policy". You agree with that don't you?
July 23, 20251 yr 59 minutes ago, JohnSnowsHair said:we 'slashed regulations' from 2017-2020 purportedly. where were all the new regulations strangling GDP growth under Biden?what remains to be seen is what the deep cuts to DOL, DOE, and the suspension of much research spend is going to cost us in the long term.I suspect especially the latter, which is surrendering the US position as the world's foremost nation in research & development and drawing talented individuals from around the world, is going to cost this nation dearly in the coming decades.but what does Trump care? he won't be here. as always he only cares about right now.I love it when you guys rag on the Republicans for not cutting spending but then, when they do, you predict calamity. Worthwhile R&D will happen regardless of how much of our tax dollars the government decides to pump into it.
July 23, 20251 yr 1 hour ago, DrPhilly said:Right but it is most certainly "new policy". You agree with that don't you?It's new legislation that is largely a continuation of existing policy. Happy?
July 23, 20251 yr so, when does the remainder of trump's great wall get finished? or isn't that so important this time around?
July 23, 20251 yr 15 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Worthwhile R&D will happen regardless of how much of our tax dollars the government decides to pump into it.Yes, you rube, but it'll happen slower and at the risk that another country makes discoveries that could've otherwise benefited our own economy including a smoother transition to the private sector when American companies partner with American universities and research firms.(D)ARPAnetGPSMRIsGLP-1 drugsCapacitive touchscreens EtcAll massively important advancements in science and tech, all spawned from research funded by the US government.
July 23, 20251 yr 1 minute ago, we_gotta_believe said:Yes, you rube, but it'll happen slower and at the risk that another country makes discoveries that could've otherwise benefited our own economy including a smoother transition to the private sector when American companies partner with American universities and research firms.(D)ARPAnetGPSMRIsGLP-1 drugsCapacitive touchscreensEtcAll massively important advancements in science and tech, all spawned from research funded by the US government.Anything that has potential for profit will develop on its own just fine
July 23, 20251 yr 18 minutes ago, The Norseman said:Anything that has potential for profit will develop on its own just fineRepeating it since you didn't read it the first time: but it'll happen slower and at the risk that another country makes discoveries that could've otherwise benefited our own economy
July 23, 20251 yr 1 hour ago, The Norseman said:It's new legislation that is largely a continuation of existing policy. Happy?Not really. The existing policy was defined to terminate. This is new policy happens to be similar or the same as the earlier policy but it is still new.
July 23, 20251 yr 1 hour ago, The Norseman said:I love it when you guys rag on the Republicans for not cutting spending but then, when they do, you predict calamity. Worthwhile R&D will happen regardless of how much of our tax dollars the government decides to pump into it."Worthwhile R&D" doesn't always show an immediate ROI, therefore no not all worthwhile R&D gets done if the private sector is the only patron.It was the US government that approached universities about leveraging their research capabilities with public funding, not the other way around. And initially universities were reluctant, because taking government money always comes with strings attached. In the decades following, a ton of publicly funded research - that never would have been greenlit by private sector firms - provided fertile ground for entire industries, with businesses built upon innovations that would be deemed too risky. Even so this research spending represents a tiny portion of the budget. The ROI for America measured in GDP and defining America as the best location for talented researchers to apply their skills is what separated us.Real spending cuts will only happen with entitlement reform. The attack on the US research apparatus by this administration is nothing more than performative BS that excites a base eager to see "elites" punished out of pure jealousy.
July 23, 20251 yr 5 hours ago, we_gotta_believe said:Repeating it since you didn't read it the first time:but it'll happen slower and at the risk that another country makes discoveries that could've otherwise benefited our own economyIt will happen faster now that the government is out of the way
July 23, 20251 yr 4 hours ago, JohnSnowsHair said:"Worthwhile R&D" doesn't always show an immediate ROI, therefore no not all worthwhile R&D gets done if the private sector is the only patron.It was the US government that approached universities about leveraging their research capabilities with public funding, not the other way around. And initially universities were reluctant, because taking government money always comes with strings attached.In the decades following, a ton of publicly funded research - that never would have been greenlit by private sector firms - provided fertile ground for entire industries, with businesses built upon innovations that would be deemed too risky.Even so this research spending represents a tiny portion of the budget. The ROI for America measured in GDP and defining America as the best location for talented researchers to apply their skills is what separated us.Real spending cuts will only happen with entitlement reform. The attack on the US research apparatus by this administration is nothing more than performative BS that excites a base eager to see "elites" punished out of pure jealousy.So I assume that you are just as furious at the Democrats for opposing any reforms to entitlements, right?
July 23, 20251 yr Just now, The Norseman said:So I assume that you are just as furious at the Democrats for opposing any reforms to entitlements, right?I'm not furious about lack of retirement reform.I'd like to see it, but my focus is deficit spending. Because irrespective of what benefits boomers or gen x or whoever receives right now, the interest on that deficit comes out of my kids' taxes.Boomers handed us an albatross. Those who support deficit spending that would make Carter blush are voting Republican.
Create an account or sign in to comment