4 minutes ago, Diehardfan said:

Once again...how dynamic and innovative did the Giants offense look? Third time I've asked, but it's obvious why you avoid answering.

How dynamic can the Giants look with such an awful roster? Offense was starting to look pretty dynamic this year when they had a QB, RB and WR before the injuries started happening.

Again, important note here that you seem unable to comprehend: Being a good coordinator doesn't necessarily translate into being a good HC. Look at Fangio. Denver was terrible with him as HC.

4 minutes ago, greend said:

Plus if our offense was so predictable wouldn't that cause the oline to look worse?

Absolutely.

I do think online injuries were a big factor but teams have injuries and still move the ball.

18 minutes ago, DaBirds said:

How do we know what Jalen does and doesn’t like doing? Jalen never says anything. About anything.

It was some report that he doesn't want to run anymore. I don't know if any reporter asked him about it

Stats show he doesn't throw to the middle but when he does.. he's often successful. So that's a strange stat

13 minutes ago, bpac55 said:

I just watched Eagle Eye Podcast and they thought his job should be safe, but then gave no context as to why. I agree with you, he should be the 2nd guy out and it can't happen soon enough.

-No improvement from any of the WR.

-Worst scramble drill group of WR in the NFL.

-Terrible blocking on screens.

-Very lazy route running on plays not designed for #1 target.

You can argue that a lot of those things have to deal with individual players, but the problem is, there's no accountability from the coach. If a WR is half assing his route, pull him to teach a lesson. If he's not blocking on a play coming to his side, put in someone who will. Just once I want to see him in the face of the WR after another failed scramble to say HELP YOUR QB.

Moorehead gotta go.

Right or wrong, the Eagles seemed to be high on their 2nd year WRs. Then they got hurt.

And then, there's the UDFA Cooper.

Im not sticking up for Moorhead but those guys may save him.

2 hours ago, Diehardfan said:

Yeah, he isn't my choice

I dont blame Daboll for Daniel Jones in NY. Jones had no OL and no weapons. That offense wasn't going to be good.

1 hour ago, bpac55 said:

I'm getting more and more on board with the Monken idea.

If he becomes the OC, I'd bet Isaiah Likely becomes FA target #1. I could even see them double dipping and bringing in Charlie Kolar too. The Eagles have 0 TE under contract. Not counting Latu or EJ Jenkins. TE was a strength for the Ravens. Bring them both in.

Both Likely and Pickard (FB) are both free agents. An offense centered around a running QB who runs, two good RB's, and good TE's is a formula for success paired with a great defense.

1 minute ago, Mike030270 said:

Stats show he doesn't throw to the middle but when he does.. he's often successful. So that's a strange stat

Yeah I never understood that either. He’s short for a traditional QB so maybe he doesn’t like not being able to see everything over the middle but it could also be because Sirianni thinks the middle of the field mean more turnovers.

You’re right though, when they do it they seem to be good at it. It is weird.

Also with the Daboll talk. Do people forget how awesome he was as the OC in Buffalo and how he helped Josh Allen develop into a stud when he was quite clearly a project coming into the draft? Monken and Daboll should be the top two priorities. McDaniel or Stefanski would be gone in a year for sure if they have success and while it would be intriguing I"m not sure Jalen fits well in a Shanahan style offense.

13 minutes ago, RememberTheKoy said:

How dynamic can the Giants look with such an awful roster? Offense was starting to look pretty dynamic this year when they had a QB, RB and WR before the injuries started happening.

Again, important note here that you seem unable to comprehend: Being a good coordinator doesn't necessarily translate into being a good HC. Look at Fangio. Denver was terrible with him as HC.

What you don't seem to comprehend is working with QBs doesn't translate into offenses looking good. You are arguing with yourself over the HC thing. Point is he was in charge of their offense and it looked horrible. How good did SB look with him and in Philly? Bottom line is if I'm taking a risk on a guy with a temper he better bring something to the table over the better options out there.

Is Greg Roman a guy anyone thinks could be another option that is uniquely suited for the Eagles?

1 hour ago, ManuManu said:

No.

Is he black?

12 minutes ago, T-1000 said:

Also with the Daboll talk. Do people forget how awesome he was as the OC in Buffalo and how he helped Josh Allen develop into a stud when he was quite clearly a project coming into the draft? Monken and Daboll should be the top two priorities. McDaniel or Stefanski would be gone in a year for sure if they have success and while it would be intriguing I"m not sure Jalen fits well in a Shanahan style offense.

It's also possible Josh Allen was just a stud and happened to develop regardless. It's not like he got worse when Daboll left. He won an MVP. But Daniel Jones got better the second he left Daboll and went to Steichen.

I'm not saying Daboll sucks, but certainly can't be a top two choice with the other names available. His offenses with the Giants were awful. He didn't have a ton to work with, but still shows he couldn't do more with less at the very least. And also is an abrasive personality.

1 hour ago, LeanMeanGM said:

Christian Parker couldn't even develop an immensely talented Kelee Ringo out of Georgia. You definitely don't want that guy running your defense @Joe Ball

Athleticism and talent are different things. When a guy with those athletic traits drops to the 4th round, there's a reason.

17 minutes ago, Diehardfan said:

What you don't seem to comprehend is working with QBs doesn't translate into offenses looking good. You are arguing with yourself over the HC thing. Point is he was in charge of their offense and it looked horrible. How good did SB look with him and in Philly? Bottom line is if I'm taking a risk on a guy with a temper he better bring something to the table over the better options out there.

It is utterly bizarre to me how you only want to look at the Giants offense, he was the HC and completely disregard the Bills offense when he was actually the OC. You have no argument at all.

And outside od Barkley's rookie year he had his best years with the Giants in Daboll's first year as HC when they went to the playoffs and win a playoff game despite having one of the worst offensive lines in the league.

20 minutes ago, HazletonEagle said:

Is he black?

Doesn't matter because he's just taking a coordinator job

4 minutes ago, shlo said:

Athleticism and talent are different things. When a guy with those athletic traits drops to the 4th round, there's a reason.

You aren't understanding the assignment

7 minutes ago, RememberTheKoy said:

It is utterly bizarre to me how you only want to look at the Giants offense, he was the HC and completely disregard the Bills offense when he was actually the OC. You have no argument at all.

And outside od Barkley's rookie year he had his best years with the Giants in Daboll's first year as HC when they went to the playoffs and win a playoff game despite having one of the worst offensive lines in the league.

Translated you are saying: I want to ignore his horrible time in NY, so let's go back to something that fits what I want it to fit vs reality that he isn't a dynamic mind or innovative but that if given amazing talent at QB he can make an offense look good.

I don't think he's a bad OC, but again, add in his temper and the other minds out there and they would do a better job IMO.

1 hour ago, Sack that QB said:

I think Cowboys would probably prefer a more experienced proven DC to fix that defense, but either way if Parker leaves I wonder if Eagles bring Dennard Wilson back as DB coach if he doesn't get a DC job elsewhere.

But also there were some rumblings Parker may want to stay if he thinks he's the heir apparent to Fangio.

I thought Wilson was great as a position coach and a solid candidate to take over for Gannon but he's been bad in Tennessee so could be the Peter principle at play.

Putting aside what the Eagles should do with AJ Brown, I wonder what trade value 2026 offseason AJ Brown has. Especially if they have to wait until after the draft to trade him.

8 minutes ago, Diehardfan said:

This is so dumb I don't even know where to start. But...the salary cap is a thing is all I will say.

45 minutes ago, DaBirds said:

Is Greg Roman a guy anyone thinks could be another option that is uniquely suited for the Eagles?

I do, but more of a last resort if we lose out on McDaniel, Monken, Kingsbury, etc.

Fred Johnson needs to be signed. Guy is valuable as a swing T. 

Hopefully Mann comes back 

Fine with DG being gone but they better have a replacement 

Phillips didn't do a ton to deserve the deal he'll probably get but they better have other options 

Dean sucks but he's always hurt and you can't pay him

Blank is fine but not worth the deal he'll get on the street. Better have a replacement. 

36 minutes ago, Sack that QB said:

It's not like he got worse when Daboll left. He won an MVP. But Daniel Jones got better the second he left Daboll and went to Steichen.

Preach

2 minutes ago, vikas83 said:

This is so dumb I don't even know where to start. But...the salary cap is a thing is all I will say.

I took it as a joke