August 18, 20214 yr 7 hours ago, 4for4EaglesNest said: Wait! What?? You haven't seen it? It must be all over this forum and if not then it'll be on twitter or Insta.
August 18, 20214 yr 9 minutes ago, downundermike said: But he was the QB coach from 71-75, and you know, he did develop the offense that Anderson played in, the offense that revolutionized the NFL. Also, if you look at the Bengals coaching history, they did not have an official offensive coordinator until 1982. I will assume that seeing as Bill Walsh developed an entirely new ground breaking offense, he would have been by default the offensive coordinator. https://pro-football-history.com/franchise/2/cincinnati-bengals-coaches Well then the OC of SF under Walsh should get the credit for Montana no??? Look like I said I'm not suggesting that Walsh wasnt a great developer of qbs maybe the greatest ever. Heck even when he wasnt coaching he watched tape of Jeff Garcia just watched his feet and said this dude can play, he had an eye for the position for an offense he designed. Reid has a similar eye for qb talent and reputation for being able to develop qb. I'm not saying Reid was better than Walsh I'm saying the argument could be made and it has and will continue to do so. And again if one doesn't want to concede that Reid has developed qbs then there's not much to discuss on the matter
August 18, 20214 yr 5 minutes ago, Ace Nova said: Is tomorrow's game televised nationally? NFL network
August 18, 20214 yr 3 minutes ago, Utebird said: Well then the OC of SF under Walsh should get the credit for Montana no??? Look like I said I'm not suggesting that Walsh wasnt a great developer of qbs maybe the greatest ever. Heck even when he wasnt coaching he watched tape of Jeff Garcia just watched his feet and said this dude can play, he had an eye for the position for an offense he designed. Reid has a similar eye for qb talent and reputation for being able to develop qb. I'm not saying Reid was better than Walsh I'm saying the argument could be made and it has and will continue to do so. And again if one doesn't want to concede that Reid has developed qbs then there's not much to discuss on the matter Your mental gymnastics are astounding. We are talking about the guy who invented the offense, and saw a guy in college that completed 52% of his passes and had a 1:1 TD-INT ratio and new he could develop him to fit perfectly into his system. Once again, Reid has an eye for talent, and developed QB's. As the Eagles coach, he drafted Mcnabb, Feely, Kolb and Kafka. Please tell us all about the massive development that happened under Reid with these 4 QB's. Show me statistically the continued improvement of these players.
August 18, 20214 yr Just now, downundermike said: Your mental gymnastics are astounding. We are talking about the guy who invented the offense, and saw a guy in college that completed 52% of his passes and had a 1:1 TD-INT ratio and new he could develop him to fit perfectly into his system. Once again, Reid has an eye for talent, and developed QB's. As the Eagles coach, he drafted Mcnabb, Feely, Kolb and Kafka. Please tell us all about the massive development that happened under Reid with these 4 QB's. Show me statistically the continued improvement of these players. My mental gymnastics??? You're the one that came up with eleventy billion qualifiers to meet your criteria and continue to do so. As for the rest no thanks it's played out.
August 18, 20214 yr 14 hours ago, WentzFan11 said: Now he’s giving away MVP editions? Kid has an ego. Kid is doing a promo for Madden and cashing the check. Good work by his agent.
August 18, 20214 yr 2 minutes ago, Utebird said: My mental gymnastics??? You're the one that came up with eleventy billion qualifiers to meet your criteria and continue to do so. As for the rest no thanks it's played out. No, I clearly showed statistically that the QB's drafted by Reid did not develop. I clearly showed statistically that Mike Vick regressed from his 1st year every year under Reid. You have yet to show me a statistical progression of any QB under Reid with the Eagles.
August 18, 20214 yr 3 minutes ago, downundermike said: No, I clearly showed statistically that the QB's drafted by Reid did not develop. I clearly showed statistically that Mike Vick regressed from his 1st year every year under Reid. You have yet to show me a statistical progression of any QB under Reid with the Eagles. I did ,you chose to not to view that as development So like I said it's played out.
August 18, 20214 yr 3 minutes ago, Utebird said: I did you chose to not to view that as progression. So like I said it's played out. Keep telling yourself that.
August 18, 20214 yr 12 minutes ago, downundermike said: The plot thickens. FBI investigating Watson accusers for extortion. I mean the FBI might be a more reliable source than Hardin.
August 18, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, downundermike said: Answers above. I consider developing a QB as making him better every year over his career. You have yet to show me that with any QB Andy Reid drafted. Are you really trying to suggest Reid didn’t develop a freeze option QB into a top NFL QB based on college completion percentage. Yikes.
August 18, 20214 yr 5 minutes ago, downundermike said: No, I clearly showed statistically that the QB's drafted by Reid did not develop. I clearly showed statistically that Mike Vick regressed from his 1st year every year under Reid. You have yet to show me a statistical progression of any QB under Reid with the Eagles. I am starting to wonder what you are down under.
August 18, 20214 yr 3 minutes ago, ManuManu said: Are you really trying to suggest Reid didn’t develop a freeze option QB into a top NFL QB based on college completion percentage. Yikes. 2 minutes ago, NCiggles said: I am starting to wonder what you are down under. Then show me the massive development in a QB drafted by the Eagles under Reid.
August 18, 20214 yr 1 minute ago, downundermike said: Then show me the massive development in a QB drafted by the Eagles under Reid. Now it's " massive" I'll give you this,the progression of your qualifiers is unquantifiable...
August 18, 20214 yr 1 minute ago, downundermike said: Then show me the massive development in a QB drafted by the Eagles under Reid. See McNabb. Reid sorta developed him into a Pro Bowl QB and at one point a fringe HoF candidate. Serious question: Are you old enough to remember watching McNabb’s entire career or are you basing this only on stats?
August 18, 20214 yr 1 minute ago, Utebird said: Now it's " massive" I'll give you this,the progression of your qualifiers is unquantifiable... It’s called sarcasm, there is not even minimal development
August 18, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, Utebird said: If it's like the storm we had 2 days ago it's gonna be a swamp on the field, hopefully if that's the case Siriani doesn't throw it 60 times...☹️ Why not? It's preseason
August 18, 20214 yr 5 minutes ago, downundermike said: Then show me the massive development in a QB drafted by the Eagles under Reid. Foles won a Super Bowl Just stirring your pot...I'm exhausted by my job. Vacation starts tomorrow at 5pm. Here is a joke from an 80 year old man told to me today: Why do Scottish men wear kilts? No zipper to alert the sheep
August 18, 20214 yr 8 minutes ago, downundermike said: Then show me the massive development in a QB drafted by the Eagles under Reid. Dude, give it up. If you develop any quarterback from college into a probowl quarterback it's massive. What do you want? Reid to scour the country for the worst college quarterback and win 15 super bowls with him.