Jump to content

Black Monday: Who's on the Hot Seat in 2023? Who gets fired


Recommended Posts

 It's time for a new Black Monday thread.

So who will it be this season? 

Belichick?
Rivera?
Reid?
McCarthy?
Daboll?

Here's the list of those fired for the 2022 season:

On 8/11/2022 at 5:09 PM, VaBeach_Eagle said:

Matt Rhule Fired October 10th
Frank Reich Fired November 8th
Nathaniel Hackett Fired December 26th
Lovie Smith Fired January 8th
Kliff Kingsbury Fired January 9th

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/5/2023 at 1:12 PM, VaBeach_Eagle said:

 It's time for a new Black Monday thread.

So who will it be this season? 

Belichick?
Rivera?
Reid?
McCarthy?
Daboll?

Here's the list of those fired for the 2022 season:

McCarthy

McDaniels

Bowles

Are my top 3 with an honorable mention to Gannon getting fired in Year 1 🙂

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This could be a high turnover year. 

McCarthy if Dallas don't win a playoff game again 

Bowles feels like an obvious choice considering they thought he might get fired last off-season. 

Rivera if they don't make the playoffs is a given, although Josh Harris is to cheap to want to pay out his contract. 

Harbaugh has won 2 playoff games in 10 years so if they miss the playoffs I think the Ravens might move him on. Might be one of those relationships that has had a run and they need a mutual split.

Eberflus if the Bears win 4 games and Fields is god awful 

Staley if the Chargers capitulate and either don't make the playoffs or flame out in grand fashion during the first week

Dennis Allen because it's Dennis Allen. The Saints will be close to faves for that division and if they don't win it that could see him gone. 

Stefanski if the Browns are a middle of the road team

McDaniels is one that probably should go but I see him keeping his job because it's the Raiders. 

Saleh will be an interesting one, if the Rodgers move backfires and they're not a playoff team yet again, do they make a move with the HC? 

Belicheat is the one you would think has a golden ticket, but if they are really bad he might moved on. I don't know if they rebuild with him

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Eberflus could easily be gone before their bye. Their DC just randomly quit, Fields threw some coaches under the bus and they're showing 0 sign of improvement 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

26 minutes ago, dawkins4prez said:

The Giants & Bears need to cut bait on their GM's 2 years in.  Those rosters haven't improved an inch.

The Giants are 10-9-1 with a playoff win the last 1+ years.

The Bears are 3-16.

 

I'm not sure they are similar situations.

The Giants can't beat the Cowboys or Eagles. (0-6 the last 2 years vs 11-4-1 in all other games)

The Bears?

They beat the 2nd worst team last year 23-20 in Chicago. (Texans were the worst team from weeks 1-17)

They beat the Trey Lance 49ers on a post-monsoon slip-and-slide field. 

They did look like an actual good football team once in the other 17 games (stomped NE 33-14)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, SkippyX said:

The Giants are 10-9-1 with a playoff win the last 1+ years.

The Bears are 3-16.

 

I'm not sure they are similar situations.

The Giants can't beat the Cowboys or Eagles. (0-6 the last 2 years vs 11-4-1 in all other games)

The Bears?

They beat the 2nd worst team last year 23-20 in Chicago. (Texans were the worst team from weeks 1-17)

They beat the Trey Lance 49ers on a post-monsoon slip-and-slide field. 

They did look like an actual good football team once in the other 17 games (stomped NE 33-14)

 

In their last 4 games the Giants have been thrashed by the NFC's elite (Eagles/Cowboys/49ers) by a combined score of 108-19.  In between they needed a historical comeback against bottom feeder Arizona.  Daboll can stay, he's proven a capable coach if you give him a roster that competes.  But this roster is not competitive and 2 full offseasons is not a short time to move a roster in the right direction.  The Giants STILL can't block.  The defense is STILL thin at all 3 levels and their top weapon is STILL that RB Gettlemen picked in the top 5.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, dawkins4prez said:

 

In their last 4 games the Giants have been thrashed by the NFC's elite (Eagles/Cowboys/49ers) by a combined score of 108-19.  In between they needed a historical comeback against bottom feeder Arizona.  Daboll can stay, he's proven a capable coach if you give him a roster that competes.  But this roster is not competitive and 2 years is not a short time to move a roster in the right direction.  The Giants STILL can't block.  The defense is STILL thin at all 3 levels and their top weapon is STILL that RB Gettlemen picked in the top 5.

That just means in year 2 they are not a top 10 team.

The Bears are clearly and obviously a bottom 3 team both last year and this year.

I am glad the Giants paid Daniel Jones and I think their ceiling is 7th seed but coaches with a .500 record don't get fired in year 2. Coaches who are 3-16 get fired in October.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, SkippyX said:

That just means in year 2 they are not a top 10 team.

The Bears are clearly and obviously a bottom 3 team both last year and this year.

I am glad the Giants paid Daniel Jones and I think their ceiling is 7th seed but coaches with a .500 record don't get fired in year 2. Coaches who are 3-16 get fired in October.

I very clearly said Daboll can stay, the GM has to go.  Oh, and Washington will finish ahead of Giants, Giants are definitely not going back to playoffs.  THEY STINK!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, dawkins4prez said:

I very clearly said Daboll can stay, the GM has to go.  Oh, and Washington will finish ahead of Giants, Giants are definitely not going back to playoffs.  THEY STINK!

The GM in NY is also around .500 with a playoff win.

The GM in Chicago is also 3-16

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...