1 minute ago, Godfather said:

Penix

I’m not as high on him as others. Frankly i don’t see them taking one with the amount of other needs they have. Plus have McKee as the backup. I do think if hurts looks closer to 2023 and 2021 in 2024 then there’s a chance if a Qb is there they like in rounds 2-3 they’d take the Qb. They’ve shown they are willing to do that even if they are paying a big amount to their top Qb. 

Just now, e-a-g-l-e-s eagles! said:

I’m not as high on him as others. Frankly i don’t see them taking one with the amount of other needs they have. Plus have McKee as the backup. I do think if hurts looks closer to 2023 and 2021 in 2024 then there’s a chance if a Qb is there they like in rounds 2-3 they’d take the Qb. They’ve shown they are willing to do that even if they are paying a big amount to their top Qb. 

@EaglePhan1986 already has a Penix Eagles jersey hanging in his closet next to his zipper mask

9 minutes ago, Godfather said:

Better then Cooter and Reich

Not Cooter. I'd take him over Smith. 

Bo and Berman were very interested in Bieniemy. He was one of their favorite candidates. Hard to feel strongly about him considering that's Reid's offense and he didn't do anything noteworthy in a bad situation in Washington. Also there was talk about him clashing with Mahomes. So would he with Hurts?

1 minute ago, Sack that QB said:

Bo and Berman were very interested in Bieniemy. He was one of their favorite candidates. Hard to feel strongly about him considering that's Reid's offense and he didn't do anything noteworthy in a bad situation in Washington. Also there was talk about him clashing with Mahomes. So would he with Hurts?

Bieniemy still wants to be a head coach.  If the offense gets back to 2022 form he'll want to bolt.  That only works if you bring in a QB coach who is more upwardly mobile than Brian Johnson to take over the offense.  

Lol

 

1 hour ago, NOTW said:

Stats like this are why I don't buy this idea that the team is "completely driven by analytics." When the analytics show they should be changing and they're not, what analytics are driving every decision?

The ones that they want to use... 

Did Adrian Griffin sleep with the owner's wife or something?

2 minutes ago, Iggles25 said:

Did Adrian Griffin sleep with the owner's wife or something?

That’s what I’m trying to figure out. They have the second best record in the NBA and they fired their coach. So there must be something going on behind the scenes that nobody knows about. Because I can’t imagine having that record that they’re like you know what you’re not good enough and we’re just gonna fire you three months into your contract to hire doc 

Honest NFL hates Sirianni's offense lol.

Jacob Harris should be an early favorite for the 2024 Nasty Nate watch.

14 minutes ago, e-a-g-l-e-s eagles! said:

I’m not as high on him as others. Frankly i don’t see them taking one with the amount of other needs they have. Plus have McKee as the backup. I do think if hurts looks closer to 2023 and 2021 in 2024 then there’s a chance if a Qb is there they like in rounds 2-3 they’d take the Qb. They’ve shown they are willing to do that even if they are paying a big amount to their top Qb. 

If he’s completely healthy, I take penix in a heartbeat. Big arm actually goes through progressions hes probably more quicker than Hurt running the ball. Hes gonna need some time to develop but I like his upside  

 

3 minutes ago, Sack that QB said:

Honest NFL hates Sirianni's offense lol.

It’s circular blame system.  Don’t blame Hurts, blame the coaching.

Dont blame Siri, blame losing both coordinators.

Dint blame the OC, blame Siri.

And so it goes.

2 minutes ago, Sack that QB said:

Honest NFL hates Sirianni's offense lol.

hes just an emotional fanboy as well. He supposedly was a former scout. He wasnt with the team at all in the siriani era so he has no idea what the dynamic is among the coaching staff and who is responsible for what.

He also didnt criticize it at all during their super bowl run. Now he wants to pretend there are no pre-snap checks (which is entirely opposite of what an RPO is), and that it is all Siri's scheme as if the OC plays no part. But if thats true, then it was Siri's scheme last year as well and that OC played no part either. 

Guy is making no sense right now and sounds no better than a bunch of you. Which explains why he is a former scout.

4 hours ago, RLC said:

If Hurts has the exact same 2023 season we're a SB contender with a league-average defense.

Was a league average defense going to hold the Bucs to 8 points?

2 minutes ago, Sack that QB said:

Honest NFL hates Sirianni's offense lol.

Hate stuff like this.

Everyone on here was sure Lurie would talk to the players, and that would decide Sirianni's fate.  Then there was reporting Hurts didn't see eye-to-eye with Brian Johnson.  Well, if Lurie did indeed talk to his players then Jalen Hurts would have been one of the guys he talked to (I have 255M reasons to assume this).  So this "Honest NFL" stooge figures after talking to Jalen Hurts, Lurie decides he'd better fire the family friend of the Hurts family -- just so Sirianni has a scapegoat.

Absolute garbage.  

27 minutes ago, Godfather said:

QB1 leads? 

No, he didn't lead an offense that scored the most pts in franchise history. That was a collective fever dream we all had.

4 minutes ago, HazletonEagle said:

hes just an emotional fanboy as well. He supposedly was a former scout. He wasnt with the team at all in the siriani era so he has no idea what the dynamic is among the coaching staff and who is responsible for what.

He also didnt criticize it at all during their super bowl run. Now he wants to pretend there are no pre-snap checks (which is entirely opposite of what an RPO is), and that it is all Siri's scheme as if the OC plays no part. But if thats true, then it was Siri's scheme last year as well and that OC played no part either. 

Guy is making no sense right now and sounds no better than a bunch of you. Which explains why he is a former scout.

I suspect since he doesn't put his name to his account he was likely a waterboy instead of a scout.

Just now, we_gotta_believe said:

No, he didn't lead an offense that scored the most pts in franchise history. That was a collective fever dream we all had.

I know you think you are clever with this strawman going back to 2022 (when in reality no one complained that year), but in doing so you prove yourself wrong because Siri was good then. OC was different. New OC sucked and Hurts regressed.

1 minute ago, Alphagrand said:

I suspect since he doesn't put his name to his account he was likely a waterboy instead of a scout.

possible. I like when he breaks down x's and o's. It was nice when he told us all the fantastic things Desai was going to do. Although it ended up not being true.

Now, hes trying to pass himself off as some sort of insider when hes clearly just as emotional with misplaced anger like all of the TATErs in here.

4 minutes ago, HazletonEagle said:

I know you think you are clever with this strawman going back to 2022 (when in reality no one complained that year), but in doing so you prove yourself wrong because Siri was good then. OC was different. New OC sucked and Hurts regressed.

It's not a strawman at all. Either we ran a "real NFL offense" last season or we didn't. Pick one, please.

9 minutes ago, Alphagrand said:

Hate stuff like this.

Everyone on here was sure Lurie would talk to the players, and that would decide Sirianni's fate.  Then there was reporting Hurts didn't see eye-to-eye with Brian Johnson.  Well, if Lurie did indeed talk to his players then Jalen Hurts would have been one of the guys he talked to (I have 255M reasons to assume this).  So this "Honest NFL" stooge figures after talking to Jalen Hurts, Lurie decides he'd better fire the family friend of the Hurts family -- just so Sirianni has a scapegoat.

Absolute garbage.  

I don't think anything he said is unfair. It's a common sentiment among people who've broken down film of the Eagles offense. That it's simplistic and had an impact on Hurts regression. I think being unfair would be to blame him for everything, when he did not.

12 minutes ago, eagle45 said:

Jacob Harris should be an early favorite for the 2024 Nasty Nate watch.

Non sequitur - is Josh Jacobs going to be affordable?  He had the 300+ carries in 2022, so the decreased productivity this season makes sense... but he might be primed for at least a dead cat bounce..

5 minutes ago, we_gotta_believe said:

It's not a strawman at all. Either we ran a "real NFL offense" last season or we didn't. Pick one, please.

lol how stupid of you to ignore the part where NFL defenses caught on to the college style offense Hurts relies on to be successful. 

You couldnt see that in his indecisiveness this year when he couldnt figure out whether to hand the ball off, or keep it to run or throw? The RPO is supposed to single out a defender and put him in a no win situation. This year defenses took that defender and gave a pre-snap look that was different than what he was going to do. Hurts couldnt figure that part out. It screwed up his entire RPO plan.

23 minutes ago, Sack that QB said:

Honest NFL hates Sirianni's offense lol.

So do I. I don’t blame BJ, Siriani is the HC who decided not to call plays. We still had many league leaders and statistic success, just the adjustments and flow were nothing.