20 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

Used Arif Hassan’s consensus big board (he takes all the top analysts’ boards and combines them) and put the setting on difficult. I picked players among the top 10 or so available, and it seemed to always be the defensive players were better than on offense. It was a lot harder to find good players on day 3. 

i'd love a WR earlier than that but if the first 3 rounds bring us nearly half a starting defense of the future that's hard to argue.  

29 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

Used Arif Hassan’s consensus big board (he takes all the top analysts’ boards and combines them) and put the setting on difficult. I picked players among the top 10 or so available, and it seemed to always be the defensive players were better than on offense. It was a lot harder to find good players on day 3. 

pretty good. At least half of those guys will make the team. 3 first year starters. 2 major role players. Thats good results.

Which site is it? 

32 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

Used Arif Hassan’s consensus big board (he takes all the top analysts’ boards and combines them) and put the setting on difficult. I picked players among the top 10 or so available, and it seemed to always be the defensive players were better than on offense. It was a lot harder to find good players on day 3. 

Even though I like the top 4 picks, Lurie and his love of offense would have a fit if we go all defense on the first two days, lol 

33 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

Used Arif Hassan’s consensus big board (he takes all the top analysts’ boards and combines them) and put the setting on difficult. I picked players among the top 10 or so available, and it seemed to always be the defensive players were better than on offense. It was a lot harder to find good players on day 3. 

Love the Williams and Adams JR picks , I also think Franks will go earlier , I am guessing teams think more of him than fans do .

Lol that Value/Reach list has JJAW and Barnett as value picks. PFF level clownery. 

I used the same big board on difficult. Here's my results

6 hours ago, CaliEagle said:

 

 

Don't think you needed Dalman, having already got Kendrick Green (a natural long-term Kelce replacement). 

But, apart from that........

Spoiler

 

5 hours ago, The guy in France said:

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder

EAGLES HISTORICAL DRAFT PICKS

 

Reach/Value (R/V) Explained

The difference between where a player is selected in the NFL draft versus where the player was listed on the final Drafttek Big Board for the season in question.
Example: A player who was listed at #50 on the Big Board and was selected at #35 will be a "Reach" of -15. Alternately, a player listed at #35 on the Big Board who was selected at #50 is a +15 "Value".

Simply put: a positive number is a Value pick, a negative number is a Reach.

 

YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2020	1	21	Jalen Reagor	TCU	WRS	Reach	-21
2020	2	53	Jalen Hurts	Alabama	QB	Reach	-19
2020	3	103	Davion Taylor	Colorado	OLB	Value	+11
2020	4	127	K'Von Wallace	Clemson	S	Value	+13
2020	4	145	Jack Driscoll	Auburn	OT	Value	+0
2020	5	168	John Hightower	Boise State	WR	Value	+3
2020	6	196	Shaun Bradley	Temple	OLB	Value	+39
2020	6	200	Quez Watkins	Southern Miss	WR	Reach	-43
2020	6	210	Prince Tega Wanogho	Auburn	OT	Value	+102
2020	7	233	Casey Toohill	Stanford	EDGE	Value	+32
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2019	1	22	Andre Dillard	Washington St	OT	Value	+12
2019	2	53	Miles Sanders	Penn State	RB	Reach	-10
2019	2	57	J.J. Arcega-Whiteside	Stanford	WR	Value	+13
2019	4	138	Shareef Miller	Penn State	EDGE	Reach	-50
2019	5	167	Clayton Thorson	Northwestern	QB	Reach	-100
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2018	2	49	Dallas Goedert	S Dakota St	TE	Reach	-15
2018	4	125	Avonte Maddox	Pittsburgh	CB	Reach	-101
2018	4	130	Josh Sweat	Florida State	EDGE	Value	+65
2018	6	206	Matt Pryor	TCU	OT	Reach	-111
2018	7	233	Jordan Mailata	Australia	OT	Reach	-133
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2017	1	14	Derek Barnett	Tennessee	EDGE	Value	+7
2017	2	43	Sidney Jones	Washington	CB	Reach	-14
2017	3	99	Rasul Douglas	West Virginia	CB	Reach	-3
2017	4	118	Mack Hollins	North Carolina	WR	Value	+0
2017	4	132	Donnel Pumphrey	San Diego State	RB	Reach	-24
2017	5	166	Shelton Gibson	West Virginia	WR	Value	+6
2017	5	184	Nathan Gerry	Nebraska	S	Value	+18
2017	6	214	Elijah Qualls	Washington	DT	Reach	-5
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2016	1	2	Carson Wentz	North Dakota St	QB	Reach	-2
2016	3	79	Isaac Seumalo	Oregon St	OG	Reach	-52
2016	5	153	Wendell Smallwood	West Virginia	RB	Reach	-84
2016	5	164	Halapoulivaati Vaitai	TCU	OT	Reach	-38
2016	6	196	Blake Countess	Auburn	DB	Reach	-290
2016	7	233	Jalen Mills	LSU	S	Value	+164
2016	7	240	Alex McCalister	Florida	DE	Reach	-177
2016	7	251	Joe Walker	Oregon	ILB	Reach	-145
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2015	1	20	Nelson Agholor	USC	WR	Reach	-22
2015	2	47	Eric Rowe	Utah	CB	Value	+4
2015	3	84	Jordan Hicks	Texas	ILB	Reach	-23
2015	6	191	JaCorey Shepherd	Kansas	CB	Reach	-40
2015	6	196	Randall Evans	Kansas St	CB	Reach	-245
2015	7	237	Brian Mihalik	Boston College	DE	Reach	-158
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2014	1	26	Marcus Smith	Louisville	EDGE	Reach	-34
2014	2	42	Jordan Matthews	Vanderbilt	WR	Reach	-4
2014	3	86	Josh Huff	Oregon	WR	Reach	-46
2014	4	101	Jaylen Watkins	Florida	CB	Value	+10
2014	5	141	Taylor Hart	Oregon	EDGE	Value	+25
2014	5	162	Ed Reynolds	Stanford	S	Value	+27
2014	7	224	Beau Allen	Wisconsin	DL3T	Value	+73

 

 

Pretty interesting. Reading through this, what sticks out to me is how many "negative value" picks actually turned out to be good players and vice versa. I mean it's pretty much just proving what a crapshoot the draft is lol.

1 minute ago, HazletonEagle said:

I used the same big board on difficult. Here's my results

This scenario is more aligned with the values I’ve become familiar with (i.e, J.Cox and M.Williams lingering until the 3rd seems optimistic in the previous version). I wonder which DTs you had available at 123, usually it’s the UCLA guy who will likely go earlier or J.Marshall. I think GE99 liked the DE from Vandy in that slot.

10 minutes ago, HazletonEagle said:

I used the same big board on difficult. Here's my results

Nico Collins was a miss for me. I took Cox hoping he’d fall to the next third round pick. He was gone so I went Williams. 

4 minutes ago, Waiting4Someday said:

This scenario is more aligned with the values I’ve become familiar with (i.e, J.Cox and M.Williams lingering until the 3rd seems optimistic in the previous version). I wonder which DTs you had available at 123, usually it’s the UCLA guy who will likely go earlier or J.Marshall. I think GE99 liked the DE from Vandy in that slot.

yeah cox was gone. I had Werner available at the top of the board, but went down to the bottom of the board for McGrone.

I dont remember the DTs. Im pretty sure I watched Odigizuwa go off the board though.

5 hours ago, The guy in France said:

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder

EAGLES HISTORICAL DRAFT PICKS

 

Reach/Value (R/V) Explained

The difference between where a player is selected in the NFL draft versus where the player was listed on the final Drafttek Big Board for the season in question.
Example: A player who was listed at #50 on the Big Board and was selected at #35 will be a "Reach" of -15. Alternately, a player listed at #35 on the Big Board who was selected at #50 is a +15 "Value".

Simply put: a positive number is a Value pick, a negative number is a Reach.

 

YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2020	1	21	Jalen Reagor	TCU	WRS	Reach	-21
2020	2	53	Jalen Hurts	Alabama	QB	Reach	-19
2020	3	103	Davion Taylor	Colorado	OLB	Value	+11
2020	4	127	K'Von Wallace	Clemson	S	Value	+13
2020	4	145	Jack Driscoll	Auburn	OT	Value	+0
2020	5	168	John Hightower	Boise State	WR	Value	+3
2020	6	196	Shaun Bradley	Temple	OLB	Value	+39
2020	6	200	Quez Watkins	Southern Miss	WR	Reach	-43
2020	6	210	Prince Tega Wanogho	Auburn	OT	Value	+102
2020	7	233	Casey Toohill	Stanford	EDGE	Value	+32
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2019	1	22	Andre Dillard	Washington St	OT	Value	+12
2019	2	53	Miles Sanders	Penn State	RB	Reach	-10
2019	2	57	J.J. Arcega-Whiteside	Stanford	WR	Value	+13
2019	4	138	Shareef Miller	Penn State	EDGE	Reach	-50
2019	5	167	Clayton Thorson	Northwestern	QB	Reach	-100
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2018	2	49	Dallas Goedert	S Dakota St	TE	Reach	-15
2018	4	125	Avonte Maddox	Pittsburgh	CB	Reach	-101
2018	4	130	Josh Sweat	Florida State	EDGE	Value	+65
2018	6	206	Matt Pryor	TCU	OT	Reach	-111
2018	7	233	Jordan Mailata	Australia	OT	Reach	-133
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2017	1	14	Derek Barnett	Tennessee	EDGE	Value	+7
2017	2	43	Sidney Jones	Washington	CB	Reach	-14
2017	3	99	Rasul Douglas	West Virginia	CB	Reach	-3
2017	4	118	Mack Hollins	North Carolina	WR	Value	+0
2017	4	132	Donnel Pumphrey	San Diego State	RB	Reach	-24
2017	5	166	Shelton Gibson	West Virginia	WR	Value	+6
2017	5	184	Nathan Gerry	Nebraska	S	Value	+18
2017	6	214	Elijah Qualls	Washington	DT	Reach	-5
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2016	1	2	Carson Wentz	North Dakota St	QB	Reach	-2
2016	3	79	Isaac Seumalo	Oregon St	OG	Reach	-52
2016	5	153	Wendell Smallwood	West Virginia	RB	Reach	-84
2016	5	164	Halapoulivaati Vaitai	TCU	OT	Reach	-38
2016	6	196	Blake Countess	Auburn	DB	Reach	-290
2016	7	233	Jalen Mills	LSU	S	Value	+164
2016	7	240	Alex McCalister	Florida	DE	Reach	-177
2016	7	251	Joe Walker	Oregon	ILB	Reach	-145
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2015	1	20	Nelson Agholor	USC	WR	Reach	-22
2015	2	47	Eric Rowe	Utah	CB	Value	+4
2015	3	84	Jordan Hicks	Texas	ILB	Reach	-23
2015	6	191	JaCorey Shepherd	Kansas	CB	Reach	-40
2015	6	196	Randall Evans	Kansas St	CB	Reach	-245
2015	7	237	Brian Mihalik	Boston College	DE	Reach	-158
YEAR	RD	PK	NAME	SCHOOL	PSN	R/V	RV Val
2014	1	26	Marcus Smith	Louisville	EDGE	Reach	-34
2014	2	42	Jordan Matthews	Vanderbilt	WR	Reach	-4
2014	3	86	Josh Huff	Oregon	WR	Reach	-46
2014	4	101	Jaylen Watkins	Florida	CB	Value	+10
2014	5	141	Taylor Hart	Oregon	EDGE	Value	+25
2014	5	162	Ed Reynolds	Stanford	S	Value	+27
2014	7	224	Beau Allen	Wisconsin	DL3T	Value	+73

 

 

Anything or anyone that had Derek Barnett as #7 is crazy.

Just now, ManuManu said:

Nico Collins was a miss for me. I took Cox hoping he’d fall to the next third round pick. He was gone so I went Williams. 

You did well, the mock is optimized (I hope the real world big board is similar).

2 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

Nico Collins was a miss for me. I took Cox hoping he’d fall to the next third round pick. He was gone so I went Williams. 

I could have had Tylan Wallace at the top of the board there, but I went lower for Nico. 

I think he may be a primary WR target for us to match some of the size Indy had at their WR position opposite the smaller guys. 

9 minutes ago, HazletonEagle said:

I could have had Tylan Wallace at the top of the board there, but I went lower for Nico. 

I think he may be a primary WR target for us to match some of the size Indy had at their WR position opposite the smaller guys. 

Are Simi or Scary Terry still considered 7th round picks? I’m thinking of a fall back if the more highly regarded Xs go off the board ahead of 37 (T.Marshall) or 70 (N.Collins).

I didn't read the DraftTek analysis any further after it scored Davion Taylor a value pick in the 3rd round.  He was a worse pick than Hurts for the slot the Eagles took him.

21 minutes ago, bbabraham said:

Pretty interesting. Reading through this, what sticks out to me is how many "negative value" picks actually turned out to be good players and vice versa. I mean it's pretty much just proving what a crapshoot the draft is lol.

Yup - a reach according to whom, right?  Hits and misses are what is important. Seumalo isn’t my favorite player, but I can care less that he’s -52 reach. 

6 minutes ago, Waiting4Someday said:

Are Simi or Scary Terry still considered 7th round picks? I’m thinking of a fall back if the more highly regarded Xs go off the board ahead of 37 (T.Marshall) or 70 (N.Collins).

no. I wanted Fehoko but I picked Hamilcar first and then he was gone. I settled for Stevenson.

Terry went around there too, but was off the board for my pick.

 

I was intrigued by Collins and Fehoko to have two 6'3''-6'4'' fast WRs. But it didnt happen.

9 minutes ago, Alphagrand said:

I didn't read the DraftTek analysis any further after it scored Davion Taylor a value pick in the 3rd round.  He was a worse pick than Hurts for the slot the Eagles took him.

If you kept reading they had JJAW a value pick as well 😄

3 minutes ago, 315Eagles said:

If you kept reading they had JJAW a value pick as well 😄

Was it yesterday Scheffter tweeted the Tobin opinion of Mel Kiper.  Yeah, the guy has had a very successful career as an entertainer - but if he was shooting even 50% he’d had job in the NFL.

6 minutes ago, 315Eagles said:

If you kept reading they had JJAW a value pick as well 😄

Well, there was value in the pick...

 

 

 

 

 

... for JJAW.

2 to TB , hopefully he can be the 3rd , PJ Fleck has done a heck of a job with the gophers 

1 minute ago, bpac55 said:

These things are addicting and fun once you start.  First attempt. 

 

  

 

 

Ah yeah - glad you only got addicted the week of the draft😳

1 minute ago, Waiting4Someday said:

Ah yeah - glad you only got addicted the week of the draft😳

I deleted the post because I couldn't figure out how to get the duplicates out of there.  Quick work!

14 minutes ago, bpac55 said:

I deleted the post because I couldn't figure out how to get the duplicates out of there.  Quick work!

Now it’s out there for posterity - I will be hailed as a hero for my fast reflexes. (I didn’t care about the dups)

Also, that would an awesome haul.