If it’s not an All In season my logic would be to clear future cap. GM in the unique positioning not forced to put up ‘just a good show selling tickets.’ Rosie given can make the hard best organizational decisions instead of complete short term….most GMs face with so much priority being on personal job security.

All In or not… gotta protect the QB. Oline looking so much lesser to be optimistic about currently. O needs attention bad. WR, TE along with multiple Oline. All will aid extending QB1s career. Can take some lumps rebuilding in other areas…can’t create the Hurts takes a brutal beating season.

Is anybody naive enough to believe our passing game and O will be humming first half of the season? Maybe beyond super optimistic nicer way to look at beyond any reasonable expectations.

Shannahan/McVay O completely different world from Siri’s. What would be a larger more time consuming switch up than what our guys will attempt to do? Teaching completely different concepts by the least experienced coach to do so.

Part of me wants to believe in Mannion. Even that scenario mostly looking at him in as a developmental O coach. He hasn’t done any of this before. I can believe in him enough to have potential to become a HC. Nothing concrete or proven enough to back up any of that ever happens though. Purely optimistic point of view really.

Most likely scenario sadly the situation is a trainwreck this upcoming season. Such a long list of reasons weighing on the negative side of the scales.

2 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Goedert 1 more year I'm grabbing Stowers(93's pick) in 2 whatever it takes because he can be our primary TE for 4 years at least. 1 year of good coaching will get him primed to take the reins. Proctor or Lomu should have the talent to take over for Lane. Jacas is a beast. NP with Lawrence if he's the consolation prize. Lance, big possession type, start him in the slot on rotation with Darius Cooper and Wilson, but he can move outside when we are ready. Farmer would be fine sitting a year at RG behind Steen. Black will be a nice RB in time. Tough kid. Payne has talent, needs coached

Isn't Jacas more a 4-3 DE or 3-4 3T not an OLB like we want. I love his strength and ability to rush the passer but from what I've read that is more his role.

Mannion has to just "Add To” Siri O. Additionally the odds stacked towards Siri getting heavily involved over the O quickly. Inexperienced in a plethora of ways coach trying to add in totally foreign concepts to our players…with his supporting coaches on O mostly far from knowing Mannion’s O themselves…-add in Siri’s. First TC doing the job, putting together the O he’s running on the fly, first time playcaller, not familiar with his personnel and the organization.

4 minutes ago, DownwithDallas said:

Isn't Jacas more a 4-3 DE or 3-4 DE not an OLB-EDGE

What D will we be running in 2027? 2028…

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

What D will we be running in 2027? 2028…

Obviously Rosie will lead towards sticking towards Fangio knockoff DC replacement. That based on quickest easiest transition for multiple reasons…not least of which being D personnel we are locked into.

Could there be consideration to run last year’s first round pick on the Edge? Spin things towards getting a LB along with even relying on Trot and Smael. Not the most obvious decisions. Believe the less boxed in on options the better the results tend to prove out.

Campbell at Edge and DeJean at S. Two potential key changes that could flip the situation fairly drastically. Not out of consideration decisions to make.

Maybe Carter year two under Fangio here is ready to serviceably man the Slot.

Maybe change things up on D by instead of Nickle favoring three S combinations.

Maybe have Fangio identifying a quality draft prospect. S, Slot CB…or both. Fangio completely transformed our coaching, as well as personnel. Fangio great at identifying talent and how to utilize it. Round four quality S and round five underrated Slot CB prospects….could solve so many difficulties this team currently faces. Be great if true.

3 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Pretty sure we take a WR, maybe 2. Nice class

Ok here is your WR draft took your first 2 picks too. 2 OLB edge rushers that drop in coverage too.(both from Michigan not on purpose) Nwaiwu can play both gaurd spots and Eastern because I decided to take a DT for once.

All proof pointing towards DeJean not ready to play outside. Not sure he really should. Been my sticking point ever since TD favored drafting him round one. I asked could he play outside? Always been my biggest doubt and questioning with DeJean. Slot CB he’s proven his quality. I believe in his ability at S. Think a good coach could utilize him in so many multiple ways. SS that is….not really a FS. Key being can handle his half the Cover Two responsibilities in the area towards FS. Not stating he’d be terrible in the FS role…more thinking it would be a waste of his best talents.

15 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Maybe Carter year two under Fangio here is ready to serviceably man the Slot.

I read maybe S for Carter

5 minutes ago, DownwithDallas said:

Ok here is your WR draft took your first 2 picks too. 2 OLB edge rushers that drop in coverage too.(both from Michigan not on purpose) Nwaiwu can play both gaurd spots and Eastern because I decided to take a DT for once.

Losing Stout ,our elite OLine identifying presence along with elite OLine developer, raises red flags all over with a top OLine prospect choice. If you put it in percentages just how much of a dropoff rate would you put towards a high draft choice Oline succeeding? Thriving? Busting? Drastic difference in my confidence change. Trusted Stout like no other. Bust percentages skyrocketed this draft. Not just losing those two most important factors Stout will be missed with in a high draft selection Oline. Specific long term Oline we’d be looking for question marks. Oline replacement coach questionable…at the very least. Length Oline coach, OC and HC with the organization not sure you could even consider higher than fifty percent….heck that’s just to even be a factor for a second season with our Oline needs.

13 minutes ago, DownwithDallas said:

I read maybe S for Carter

Fangio identified Carter as an option for him at S and Slot always. I’m actually almost even more to consider Carter at Slot the more we hear about him at S…in some ways. It’s BS season. The more the rest of the league is expected us to draft different than are actual plans the better. Just consider Fangio, Rosie and Siri track record history. It’s exactly the kind of thing they do every time almost.

"The Eagles do have a below-average passer at the quarterback position in Jalen Hurts, and if Philly plans on keeping him as their starter for years to come. General Manager Howie Roseman will need to continue restocking this offense with legitimate talent." Per NFL spin zone (who thinks) we take Boston at 23. But yeah none of us on here know what we're talking about LOL

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

That isn’t going to happen. But sticking through these times under Siri have been very trying. Without context seems so ideal. But knowing what all Eagles should understand…that we’ve been really setup to make our best ever dynasty run….being sidetracked by Siri. Losing that SB in 2022 more on Gannon and the league offices lead by Goodell. Still was so much there to have made it happen. But 2023 totally worst collapse of such quality roster by Siri. 2024 Siri actually mostly just held back a much greater team than what we saw on the field most of the regular season. Won the SB….so…got the job done. Even Siri manipulating getting in the way so much still couldn’t derail that squad. I’m not one looking for style points as much as I championships… so Siri gets full credit as good enough. Then 2025 just the most predictable trainwreck Siri responsible for.

You're full of crap-CHOCK full. Just clueless LMAO

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

That isn’t going to happen. But sticking through these times under Siri have been very trying. Without context seems so ideal. But knowing what all Eagles should understand…that we’ve been really setup to make our best ever dynasty run….being sidetracked by Siri. Losing that SB in 2022 more on Gannon and the league offices lead by Goodell. Still was so much there to have made it happen. But 2023 totally worst collapse of such quality roster by Siri. 2024 Siri actually mostly just held back a much greater team than what we saw on the field most of the regular season. Won the SB….so…got the job done. Even Siri manipulating getting in the way so much still couldn’t derail that squad. I’m not one looking for style points as much as I championships… so Siri gets full credit as good enough. Then 2025 just the most predictable trainwreck Siri responsible for.

Man, I had 1/2 your suitcase packed(sigh)

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

What more pressure on Hurts? Doesn’t even make any sense. Rosie was the one that was flailing and failing to get that other piece besides Smitty. Hurts went straight to AJ and recruited him to come in the first place. Wouldn’t have been here otherwise.

AJ didn’t deliver in the playoff game so crucial in the repeat attempt. Was a liability instead. Delibrate tank job to force his trade out.

DELUSIONAL, repetitive BS. But if that was the case(which is isn't) then your boy is responsible for quitting on the guy he supposedly recruited. Therefore, Hurts is TOTALLY RESPONSIBLE for deliberately sabotaging this team by bringing in the "infiltrator" Either way your boy is at fault. Live with that ALL Hurts fault if you believe your own BS

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Over and over ask you this same question you delibrately have to avoid because you can’t answer it with any real meaningful point. Over and over you bring up stat chasing. Even the failure of stat accumulation for nothing much more than just style point reasoning…was the fault of Siri weakest O.

IDK you are responding to your own post, so I have no idea what the question is I didn't answer. You are the one who never answers questions, just take a day off,then go into a new(old) topic we have been over 50 times already. SO here's a question for you. Players get paid based on statistical performance? yes/no I await your answer. Yes or no and why you answered the way you did

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

If there is pressure on Hurts it would be revolving more around unacceptable HC decision making surrounding our best ever franchise QB. Funny part is it was Hurts that saved his job to even make it through that first season at the helm. Impossible! But that’s what Hurts accomplished. Should the pressure be all on Hurts to do the GM job securing our best WR weapon aways as well? Not his job…above and beyond…that’s on top of the so many numerous duties Hurts already performs otherwise.

Yeah wow, that first season was OFF THE CHARTS(horrible) I already posted that link.