March 23Mar 23 It’s a bar to measure things on about if Rosie traded Tanner for a third round pick. That direct example…if nothing else.
March 23Mar 23 6 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:Which way is spinning wheels?—- The holding on to the guy in the last year of his contract—- The moving from the one year contract player to the four year contract player with hopefully potential for even moreWe should have traded Sweat, Williams, Slay, CGJ, etc instead of winning the SUPERBOWL according to your logic?Yes..you get players and they play out their contract, especially when it's good value. That happens all the time. 3 years you couldn't wait to trade McKee... a cheap quality backup at the most important position. Even if he does not get into a game, the QBs quality play in practice all offseason, camp and weekly practice help the team. Why trade that away if you don't have to??
March 23Mar 23 1 minute ago, joemas6 said:We should have traded Sweat, Williams, Slay, CGJ, etc instead of winning the SUPERBOWL according to your logic?Yes..you get players and they play out their contract, especially when it's good value. That happens all the time.3 years you couldn't wait to trade McKee... a cheap quality backup at the most important position. Even if he does not get into a game, the QBs quality play in practice all offseason, camp and weekly practice help the team.Why trade that away if you don't have to??Are you suggesting we have a SB winning roster and team as things stand today?
March 23Mar 23 6 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:The optimistic thinking is we have our O mind in place with Mannion. So who is Mannion teaching his O to? Tanner? Or rookie with potential?We don't have a rookie yet...what happens if we don't get the rookie we want after trading McKee? Pretty stupid right?
March 23Mar 23 Just now, cunninghamtheman said:Are you suggesting we have a SB winning roster and team as things stand today?Are you suggesting that we trade away all the players on the last year of their deal? Every year except when it's a guarantee to you that the roster is Superbowl ready in March?
March 23Mar 23 Just now, joemas6 said:We don't have a rookie yet...what happens if we don't get the rookie we want after trading McKee? Pretty stupid right?Why? We have Dalton. Tanner isn’t any future most likely for us. One more season….that’s it. Maybe get us a comp pick would be highlight benefit if keeping him.
March 23Mar 23 2 minutes ago, joemas6 said:We don't have a rookie yet...what happens if we don't get the rookie we want after trading McKee? Pretty stupid right?Who is Mannion teaching his new O to we are relying on for our future?
March 23Mar 23 6 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:The more flexible he can be….the more advantageous scenarios tend to unfold.He is new at the job...you should call and give him pointers 🙄
March 23Mar 23 Author 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:Are you suggesting we have a SB winning roster and team as things stand today?Why not? We basically have the same players??? Hurts needs to pull his weight now, no BS side deals or he is GONE. A healthier O line, We have as good a shot as anyone else. Lost some nice players but we can add some nice players. it's always fluid,that never changes
March 23Mar 23 Just now, joemas6 said:He is new at the job...you should call and give him pointers 🙄Talking about options…which it seems you are being way too close minded about.
March 23Mar 23 1 minute ago, GreenbleedinNC said:Why not? We basically have the same players??? Hurts needs to pull his weight now, no BS side deals or he is GONE. A healthier O lineI can’t agree…long way to go yet.
March 23Mar 23 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:Who is Mannion teaching his new O to we are relying on fir our future?There is no new QB until we draft the one we want. If you trade away your backup QB...for pick 111 and you get a WR/ TE, DB, DL, OL, RB, S with that pick...and then you fail to get a QB in the draft....Then I can ask you the same question.
March 23Mar 23 2 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:Why not? We basically have the same players??? Hurts needs to pull his weight now, no BS side deals or he is GONE. A healthier O lineThis isn’t a playoff team…not from what I’m seeing. Not yet for sure.
March 23Mar 23 Author 2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:I can’t agree…long way to go yet.If you are a fan you BELIEVE, which apparently you are not a fan. What "long way to go" should be done if we have a QB who redefines the QB position(still waiting on that)
March 23Mar 23 Author 2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:This isn’t a playoff team…not from what I’m seeing. Not yet for sure. But the other 31 are???? How do you know until you PLAY THE GAMES? NOTHING gets decided on paper
March 23Mar 23 1 minute ago, GreenbleedinNC said:If you are a fan you BELIEVE, which apparently you are not a fan. What "long way to go" should be done if we have a QB who redefines the QB position(still waiting on that)Our pass rush is proven not good enough. Our K sketchy…that put us in that bad position against the Niners. How many more do I need to provide?
March 23Mar 23 Author 8 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:Why? We have Dalton. Tanner isn’t any future most likely for us. One more season….that’s it. Maybe get us a comp pick would be highlight benefit if keeping him.How do you know about Tanner? has he ever played full games with the 1's???? No it's always the 2's so you have ZERO idea how he would do with the 1's
March 23Mar 23 Author Just now, cunninghamtheman said:Our pass rush is proven not good enough. Our K sketchy…that put us in that bad position against the Niners. How many more do I need to provide?Oh, we're playing the 9ers in the past????? So we can't fix edge and K in the draft????
March 23Mar 23 1 minute ago, GreenbleedinNC said:How do you know about Tanner? has he ever played full games with the 1's???? No it's always the 2's so you have ZERO idea how he would do with the 1'sI believe he’s in the top 32 of QBs
March 23Mar 23 Just now, GreenbleedinNC said:Oh, we're playing the 9ers in the past????? So we can't fix edge and K in the draft????Exactly..we still need much more
March 23Mar 23 Author Just now, GreenbleedinNC said:Oh, we're playing the 9ers in the past????? So we can't fix edge and K in the draft????Actually would not shock me if we took 2
March 23Mar 23 Author Just now, cunninghamtheman said:I believe he’s in the top 32 of QBsHard to know,he's never started with the ones. Do you think AJ and Smitty are better than Gray and whoever else we stick outside for the 2's? Is Shipley on par with Barkley? Thats who tanner plays with
March 23Mar 23 Author Just now, GreenbleedinNC said:Hard to know,he's never started with the ones. Do you think AJ and Smitty are better than Gray and whoever else we stick outside for the 2's? Is Shipley on par with Barkley? Thats who tanner plays withLet's put Hurts with the 2's and see how he does
Create an account or sign in to comment