@RememberTheKoy

3 minutes ago, ToastJenkins said:

He got way too heavy

Hes always been big. Hes just a real big guy whose had a ton of injuries since college

He didnt play poorly because hes fat or out if shape, he played poorly because his body is broken, knees held together with duct tape lead to bad hips and backs and everything else.

His body is wrecked, this was a guy that at 330 was doing cartwheels in interviews in college, now I doubt he can touch his toes, not because hes fat but because hes mostly super glue and duct tape, maybe some twine...☹️

Dude shouldnt have been on the field this year at least not to start after he hurt his knee again in summer.

Watching that replay, he runs down the field saying get off the field. get off the Fing field. And then he goes up to him and looks like he’s saying something to aj that Aj didn’t like and that sent Aj over. I tend to believe it’s not the get off the Fing field part that probably pissed off AJ Brown. Then again AJ Brown can’t be sulking and not getting himself off the Fing field.

3 minutes ago, Sack that QB said:

Sirianni giving up influence on the offense is even more important than not fighting the firing of Patullo. As long as Nick has influence, it will hold back the new OC

Actual OCs with whatever Nick's influence is have been good. Can't deny teo Super Bowl runs in that situation.

I love Dean, but I think you have to let him walk. He's not quite as good as Milton Williams (and won't get that kind of money), but it's a similar situation. Davis and Ojomo got to shine and the money just wasn't there.

Campbell is a first round pick. That money needs to be spent elsewhere. Davis, Carter, Mitchell, Dejean all need to get paid. And I'd like to keep Nolan Smith and Hunt.

I think the defense is going to have to subtract Phillips, Dean, and Adoree Jackson. Maybe find a reliable CB2 in FA.

And they need to draft a brand new OL+TE...no room to draft defensive players this year.

4 minutes ago, Mike31mt said:

Any qualified coaching candidate would A. see that this is 1 out of 32 of these jobs on the planet and B. also see that Sirianni is incompetent and carried by a great roster.

I didn't say they'd have trouble getting candidates. Just that it would be a bad look.

You don't fire coaches when all they do is win and win a SB, regardless of a talented roster or not. Unless said coach is a problem behind the scenes which I mentioned Lurie and Howie know what he does or doesnt do.

You fire coaches when they lose games and fail to make the playoffs.

But like I said, I could care less. I dont get attached to players or coaches. If they feel like moving on from him is the right thing to do then I'm behind it. Would seem strange but I'd be behind it.

Just now, ManuManu said:

Strange because a really smart guy from the great state of West Virginia told me that the Niners offense was inept.

10 minutes ago, HazletonEagle said:

is it simple? Or is Purdy, despite his lack of an arm just smart enough to process it all well? Its a lot of quick throws that requires processing speed Hurts will never have.

That’s the biggest requirement in a Shanahan offense at QB. Brains.

3 minutes ago, we_gotta_believe said:

He also began to walk away, only to turn back around several seconds later, and continued to berate an already temperamental player. That speaks to an impulsive person who lost control of his emotions like he has a pattern of doing. AJ is guilty of the exact same thing, but a head coach should be held to a higher standard.

And at its most basic level, a head coach is primarily a communicator, and he just does a really poor job of it at times. You can argue that a head coach should have the "right" to express his vision of the team in any way he chooses, but that's obviously gonna come across as some Chip Kelly type shìt and it'll eventually wear thin with some guys in the locker room.

Sirianni is a lot of things but AJ was in the wrong there. After all the crap he'd put out there to give that performance was shameful, and to yell at anybody else is ridiculous. As much as anyone else, including Patullo, AJ lost them this game. And then he goes and hides post-game. Coward.

Just now, ManuManu said:

It’s not just Purdy. It’s Mac Jones, Jimmy G and even Nick Mullens. Darnold was a bumbling mess before Shanahan and is now playing well in a Shanahan spinoff.

I dont know enough about Mullens, but Im not shocked Jones or Jimmy G executed the scheme. They were true QBs with QB skills.

SF has a great system that doesnt ask much. But it does require processing, timing, and accuracy. If this were Madden, Hurts probably has a 0 in each of those required categories.

Hurts was a system QB in a system that allowed/required him to run.

Youre never going to put him in to any passing scheme and get those results. You can give him McVay, Shannahan, Ben Johnson, anyone. He will suck even worse than he does now. There is a very obvious reason Sirianni changed from what his offense was during his time in Indianapolis, and why every OC has had to change from what their offense was. They scrap all their good stuff when it quickly becomes clear that Hurts cant run it.

1 minute ago, ManuManu said:

Shanahan with our roster would hang 40-50 a game

4 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

It’s not just Purdy. It’s Mac Jones, Jimmy G and even Nick Mullens. Darnold was a bumbling mess before Shanahan and is now playing well in a Shanahan spinoff.

To be fair, Shanahan picked his QBs carefully, as shown by how fast he launched Trey Lance into space.

AJ Brown is an absolute loser. Three big drops in a playoff game and one of them on a deep ball where he clearly alligator armed it because the safety was coming over. Then he sneaks out of the locker room without talking afterwards, lol. After all of the ishe he talked all year and all of the drama he caused to have a half assed performance like that in a playoff game is pathetic.

Also, EVERYONE is responsible for the KP problem which includes Lurie, Roseman, etc. NOBODY should be left off the hook. Shanahan got more out of Demarcus FN Robinson and a FB in this game against a secondary with two all pro corners than Patullo was able to get from Brown and Smith against a horrible defense. Sirianni is a moron too. They take a timeout and with their season on the line and a 4th and 11 they run four verticals. Utterly pathetic. Pathetic pathetic pathetic. Not only should Patullo be fired it had better happen within 24 hours. There needs to be a clear statement made to Nick that he needs to get out of the way or get out himself.

4 minutes ago, we_gotta_believe said:

He also began to walk away, only to turn back around several seconds later, and continued to berate an already temperamental player. That speaks to an impulsive person who lost control of his emotions like he has a pattern of doing. AJ is guilty of the exact same thing, but a head coach should be held to a higher standard.

And at its most basic level, a head coach is primarily a communicator, and he just does a really poor job of it at times. You can argue that a head coach should have the "right" to express his vision of the team in any way he chooses, but that's obviously gonna come across as some Chip Kelly type shìt and it'll eventually wear thin with some guys in the locker room.

yup...ok...I understand passion under pressure but he absolutely should not have gone back and re-engaged. someone has to be the adult....that was an embarassment

Just now, Iggles_Phan said:

Sirianni is a lot of things but AJ was in the wrong there.

Sirianni was in the wrong and AJ Brown was in the wrong. Both can be true.

Just now, ToastJenkins said:

Shanahan with our roster would hang 40-50 a game

As long as he could teach Hurts the scheme, yes. Because he's probably the second best offensive coach in the league, who just happens to be legendary at choke jobs.

I still don't know why the designer runs for Hurts were not in the playbook. I mean Hurts without the threat of run is not much a more consistent thrower of the ball than Justin Fields.

11 minutes ago, RememberTheKoy said:

That didnt lose the game, next olay hurts hit goedert for a first down.

Bad drop but not a game killer.

That was the first slant run the whole game, with under 2 minutes left...😒

1 minute ago, we_gotta_believe said:

Sirianni is in the wrong and AJ Brown was in the wrong. Both can be true.

I guess it comes down to which act is more grating to each person. Ajs off field stuff and drops today take the top spot for me... because I wanted to yell at him too, so I give Sirianni more of a pass there. Jason Avant did too, for whatever that is worth. AJ is a big baby. Sirianni is a moron. But the moron yelling at the baby made me feel better.

To be fair, Patullo calls a good game in the red zone, but look at this. I don’t recall ever seeing a Texas route from that alignment. Perfectly schemed up because it’s long developing and gives the QB an option late in the down if the initial reads are covered up.

7 minutes ago, we_gotta_believe said:

He also began to walk away, only to turn back around several seconds later, and continued to berate an already temperamental player. That speaks to an impulsive person who lost control of his emotions like he has a pattern of doing. AJ is guilty of the exact same thing, but a head coach should be held to a higher standard.

And at its most basic level, a head coach is primarily a communicator, and he just does a really poor job of it at times. You can argue that a head coach should have the "right" to express his vision of the team in any way he chooses, but that's obviously gonna come across as some Chip Kelly type shìt and it'll eventually wear thin with some guys in the locker room.

Not only that when you watch the replay of it, he says something to him as he’s walking up to him. It wasn’t the get off the field. And then he engaged in a spat on the sideline. AJ Brown is 100% in the wrong. AJ Brown was a jackass for doing it. Especially after he played as poorly as he did. And frankly, he should’ve had to talk to the media, like everyone else did.

That said my head coach does not need to be getting into verbal spats on the sideline. If AJ’s gonna be a jackass, let him be a jackass. You don’t have to stoop down to his level, say something to continue to escalate the situation. Walk away. Furthermore, I also don’t like when my head coach talk crap to our own fans about barely winning a game against the Browns last year. Or the fact that he runs off the field talking crap to other teams fans when his offense failed to complete a pass in the second half of a game.

17 minutes ago, 315Eagles said:

Let me just say that I dont care if they were to fire Sirianni after this loss. I dont get attached to players or coaches like some of you do.

However it would be an incredibly bad look for the Eagles if they did fire a HC after 5 straight years of playoffs, back to back division titles, 2 SB appearances and a SB title. You dont normally fire a coach when all they do is win. It sucks we cant win the Superbowl every year but such is life. For those that say he only wins because he has a talented roster..........well doesnt just about any coach that wins alot of games and wins a SB have a talented roster?

If this franchise were trending downwards and struggling whie losing games consistently then you have a case for firing the HC.

Bottom line is there will be changes. To coaches and the roster. They've done it before and its worked.

I trust Howie and Lurie know what they're doing. If they feel Sirianni isnt the guy anymore and a change is needed, they will make it. They know first hand what he does as a HC. If they feel he doesnt do anything or offer anything, they'll move on.

There’s 0% chance he gets fired. We are at the "Eagles FO forces the OC hire and you better make it work” stage. Hopefully for Sirianni, whoever they get is better than Scangarello and Mornhinweg.