Dont blame doug for challenging but i think he is down

And there goes another TO.  Bad challenge.  Metcalf's knee was down.  Not conclusive to overturn.

 

Just now, Mike030270 said:

Oh F

He’s going to lose that

That last angle, looked like the ball was only sticking to his body because he was falling on top of it... not sure he had 'control' of it, even though it doesn't appear to be moving... just Newton's laws in action.  Ball continued in its path, and his body was moving the same way... but they won't overturn this.

Just now, ToastJenkins said:

Dont blame doug for challenging but i think he is down

He has a better shot at it being ruled incomplete. 

Just now, eaglesflyers#1 said:

5 good consecutive games until the Eagles got Alshon back...

Fulgham is the best WR on this team.

Being the best WR on this team doesn't make him good.

2 minutes ago, eagle45 said:

Eagles fans missed the mark on Fulgham.  He had 5 good games and everyone thought he was a high end NFL WR.  Teams figured him out.  He's not that good.

Everyone did no such thing. I think you need to ad the word hope in there

2 minutes ago, Iggles_Phan said:

Gonna lose the challenge.  I think it was close, but not nearly clear enough to reverse it.

Did he challenge the catch or being down?

2 minutes ago, LeanMeanGM said:

That’s not a catch 

That may be but I think they will give it to him

3 minutes ago, eagle45 said:

Eagles fans missed the mark on Fulgham.  He had 5 good games and everyone thought he was a high end NFL WR.  Teams figured him out.  He's not that good.

Regardless... I want to see HIM out there, not Alshon.

Just now, Iggles_Phan said:

That last angle, looked like the ball was only sticking to his body because he was falling on top of it... not sure he had 'control' of it, even though it doesn't appear to be moving... just Newton's laws in action.  Ball continued in its path, and his body was moving the same way... but they won't overturn this.

If anything it’ll stand but no way it gets overturned. Whoever told Doug to challenge it failed

3 minutes ago, eagle45 said:

Eagles fans missed the mark on Fulgham.  He had 5 good games and everyone thought he was a high end NFL WR.  Teams figured him out.  He's not that good.

Regardless... I want to see HIM out there, not Alshon.

1 minute ago, ManuManu said:

Not everyone. Let’s settle down. 

We're trusting the team that played Peters over Mailata about young player evaluation?

Just now, ManuManu said:

Did he challenge the catch or being down?

Why not both

Just now, NCiggles said:

That may be but I think they will give it to him

TBF, I have no idea what a catch is 

Dont blame doug for challenging but i think he is down

That screen play has a lot to dissect.

No one knew what their assignment was, so everything broke down.

Nitpicking here, but Wentz knew where the pressure was coming from pre-snap.  The Seahawks tipped that.  That's where Peyton Manning sits at the LOS, points at them, puts the defense on their heels, and audibles into something else.

That's it beat the ish outta him

3 minutes ago, eagle45 said:

Eagles fans missed the mark on Fulgham.  He had 5 good games and everyone thought he was a high end NFL WR.  Teams figured him out.  He's not that good.

Regardless... I want to see HIM out there, not Alshon.

 

 

 

 

12 men in the offensive huddle... should have been a 5 yard penalty.

Just now, Iggles_Phan said:

Regardless... I want to see HIM out there, not Alshon.

I agree with that.

1 minute ago, eagle45 said:

Eagles fans missed the mark on Fulgham.  He had 5 good games and everyone thought he was a high end NFL WR.  Teams figured him out.  He's not that good.

I disagree. He hasn't been targeted once tonight. Seen him on the field maybe twice. 2 games prior to this one he wasn't targeted until the 2nd half. 10 target's total last 3 games after this one. Piss poor game planning personnel wise. Jeffery shouldn't be starting over him

I'm sure that only having one timeout left won't come back to haunt us at all.

Seattle throwing screens to David Moore is like us throwing screens to Greg Ward. Wasted plays. 

Just now, RLC said:

We're trusting the team that played Peters over Mailata about young player evaluation?

I don’t think many in here were saying Fulgham was a high-end WR, let alone "everyone.”

2 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

Did he challenge the catch or being down?

Doesn't matter.  They review the whole play, as I recall.

 

NRC actually made a good play