April 19, 20242 yr Then we can bring up the bad D the switch and everything but that again would give more credit to a rookie DT over a veteran pass rusher
April 19, 20242 yr 56 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: I disagree obviously …thinking you are just taking Hassan Reddick for granted. But…that’s just my opinion. Reddick is a beast! So very underrated his whole career. Not really...Reddick 2022 was impact player... total of 8 fumbles recovered or caused.... Reddick 2023... one Cox and Carter were constantly double teamed. We're impactful during that 10-1 stretch stopping the run and vs the pass. Your not being honest about Reddick 2023 and his impact. Not like he was being doubled on the edge constantly either. Very likable guy..local. But we have to be honest here... liability isn't performance or impact.
April 19, 20242 yr 25 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: Then we can bring up the bad D the switch and everything but that again would give more credit to a rookie DT over a veteran pass rusher So you are naming Carter as our best defender last season also? He was actually a backup….but you can have your opinion. Carter definitely had a strong start. For me our best player was Reddick. Highest expectations this season still would have been placed on his shoulders…you know…if he was still around.
April 19, 20242 yr 27 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: Then we can bring up the bad D the switch and everything but that again would give more credit to a rookie DT over a veteran pass rusher Really makes any evaluation tough when considering the way the D finished. Will add at the end at least Patricia wasn’t dropping Carter back on coverage. About the only boneheaded stuff he didn’t try.
April 19, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said: So you are naming Carter as our best defender last season also? He was actually a backup….but you can have your opinion. Carter definitely had a strong start. For me our best player was Reddick. Highest expectations this season still would have been placed on his shoulders…you know…if he was still around. I just watched the games and Carter was always around the ball making plays. Carter started strong fell off when our entire D fell off. Reddick started slow and finished slow solid middle of the season
April 19, 20242 yr Just now, cunninghamtheman said: Really makes any evaluation tough when considering the way the D finished. Will add at the end at least Patricia wasn’t dropping Carter back on coverage. About the only boneheaded stuff he didn’t try. No was just changing terminology and assignments and what he was asking for players really tough on a rookie
April 19, 20242 yr Our D was terrible but if you going to ask me who made the biggest splash’s throughout the year it was definitely Carter. And honestly that a good thing hopefully moving forward if he can build on it
April 19, 20242 yr 11 minutes ago, joemas6 said: Not really...Reddick 2022 was impact player... total of 8 fumbles recovered or caused.... Reddick 2023... one Cox and Carter were constantly double teamed. We're impactful during that 10-1 stretch stopping the run and vs the pass. Your not being honest about Reddick 2023 and his impact. Not like he was being doubled on the edge constantly either. Very likable guy..local. But we have to be honest here... liability isn't performance or impact. No doubt pass versus the run differences. 2022 we played with a lead and the pass rush feasted. Every single game and moment was tight last season. Wasn’t tons of just very obvious known pin your ears back and rush opportunities. Still saw Reddick as our best defender. For you to state the very first game like Carter was massively facing double teams the whole time just isn’t accurate. I don’t believe Reddick was as crazy killing it in 2023 like he did in 2022…but he was our best guy..on that side of the ball. That’s with him on the down swing lower season even.
April 19, 20242 yr 4 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: I just watched the games and Carter was always around the ball making plays. Carter started strong fell off when our entire D fell off. Reddick started slow and finished slow solid middle of the season Reddick was injured and played through it early. It was noticeable..but even dealing with that he still was pretty darn good.
April 19, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said: Reddick was injured and played through it early. It was noticeable..but even dealing with that he still was pretty darn good. Zero sacks in 3 weeks to start the year mmmmmm
April 19, 20242 yr 5 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: No was just changing terminology and assignments and what he was asking for players really tough on a rookie It was insurmountable for rookie and vet alike…clearly!
April 19, 20242 yr Just now, cunninghamtheman said: It was insurmountable for rookie and vet alike…clearly! For a rookie sure not for a veteran or it shouldn’t they been around the adjust far quicker then a mid fresh from college
April 19, 20242 yr 2 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: Our D was terrible but if you going to ask me who made the biggest splash’s throughout the year it was definitely Carter. And honestly that a good thing hopefully moving forward if he can build on it You know he was the top guy on my draft board I talked about the entire season. It was really a 1A and 1B with him and Anderson. Wanted both those guys since the 2022 draft even.
April 19, 20242 yr Look I was fine with Reddick he was a good player a tier below elite if you ask me… honestly wanted to keep him Over sweat but we opted the other way
April 19, 20242 yr 2 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: Zero sacks in 3 weeks to start the year mmmmmm https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/eagles-haason-reddick-undergoes-surgery-for-thumb-injury-aiming-to-be-ready-for-week-1-per-report/amp/
April 19, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said: You know he was the top guy on my draft board I talked about the entire season. It was really a 1A and 1B with him and Anderson. Wanted both those guys since the 2022 draft even. Carter was arguably the best talent in the entire draft only reason we got him was the off the field stuff…. Question is will he keep his head on straight
April 19, 20242 yr Just now, cunninghamtheman said: https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/eagles-haason-reddick-undergoes-surgery-for-thumb-injury-aiming-to-be-ready-for-week-1-per-report/amp/ He still wasn’t playing bad or anything…just had that protective cast or whatever that he wasn’t finishing sacks with.
April 19, 20242 yr Just now, cunninghamtheman said: https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/eagles-haason-reddick-undergoes-surgery-for-thumb-injury-aiming-to-be-ready-for-week-1-per-report/amp/ Seen plenty of players play with there hands in a club and produce
April 19, 20242 yr 3 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: For a rookie sure not for a veteran or it shouldn’t they been around the adjust far quicker then a mid fresh from college It was an unavoidable train wreck. No amount of experience could overcome that situation Rosie created.
April 19, 20242 yr And this is only accounting for 1 part of his job and that’s as a pass rusher and Reddick was only avg. at best as a run defender top that with being less effective rusher he wasn’t that great. Last year can blame whatever but simple fact is he just wasn’t our best D player last season
April 19, 20242 yr 16 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: So you are naming Carter as our best defender last season also? He was actually a backup….but you can have your opinion. Carter definitely had a strong start. For me our best player was Reddick. Highest expectations this season still would have been placed on his shoulders…you know…if he was still around. Why do you have Reddick as best defender ... in 2023?
April 19, 20242 yr Just now, Bleedinggreen93 said: Honestly if it wasn’t for injuries thought Blank was playing great ball Injuries really troopered through by him also. You could tell several games he just didn’t have that extra gear needed. He’s not as slow as he appeared in a few very critical moments. Had me questioning his limitations at points.
April 19, 20242 yr 11 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: Our D was terrible but if you going to ask me who made the biggest splash’s throughout the year it was definitely Carter. And honestly that a good thing hopefully moving forward if he can build on it With Cox as the most consistent. They went downhill once he went out vs Buffalo.
Create an account or sign in to comment