2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

A pass rushing interior Dline?

How was he used in Miami? We haven't seen Fangios scheme yet

Where is the list of the 7 teams we lose to?

I see us as needing a top outside pass rusher and a run stopper inside as biggest needs along the Dline. We really have so much relying on Davis as our run stopping Nose. Hard for me to feel but so comfortable on him. The pass rusher outside situation feels like it has to be answered with one of our young guys we’ve lined up. Fangio has to get these guys clicking. Just seems like about the only answer there at this point. I don’t see us trading for Judon or a move like that.

2 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

How was he used in Miami? We haven't seen Fangios scheme yet

You want to add him. For what job? 

Frankly I don’t understand the whole logic of positions going on. I was accustomed to a Nose with two DE beside him and two OLB outside them….in a 3-4. Clearly not how they are labeling our defenders. Carter, Davis, Milton …so on…are labeled DT. Huff came in as DE. Sweat moved to OLB. BG is only other DE. 

6 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

You want to add him. For what job? 

Relief/rotational BU or whatever Fangio wants him for. where is the list of 7, coming soon?

Just now, GreenbleedinNC said:

Relief/rotational BU or whatever Fangio wants him for. where is the list of 7, coming soon?

At what position and job? Pretty important part of any equation of adding a player. You are fighting and arguing to add him…but can’t even define for what role.

3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

At what position and job? Pretty important part of any equation of adding a player. You are fighting and arguing to add him…but can’t even define for what role.

I’m actually trying to throw you a bone here on this. I’ve been assuming and we’ve been talking about him as an Edge player. The answer is no for that. But if the discussion is about a rotational pass rushing interior Dline position I could actually be more willing to discuss that. The answer would still be no…but at least more worthy of discussing and considering.

1 hour ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

1)Ogbah 1 year,cheap contract,what is your issue???? 2) he is not here in 2025

If he’s not an option for 2025 and moving forward on a rebuilding team and D then there isn’t much point in discussing him then…not anywhere near at this point especially.

2 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Doesn’t seem too wise to add a 30 pass rusher. We just shipped out a top 30 year old pass rusher and paying him to play elsewhere.

Not paying Reddick a dime.  

2 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Podcast ranks Hurts as QB #11

If that's the case then we are in good shape with the rest of the offense.  #11 QB in the world.. . With this supporting cast....we should have a dominant offense!  

6 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Not paying Reddick a dime.  

 

6 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Not paying Reddick a dime.  

From all my so deep and thorough investigations(actually just took one peak at Over the Cap) I find we are paying him over 21.5 mil on our 2024 teams salary cap. That makes him BY Far our highest paid player according to official salary cap dollars we are spending on our 2024 Philadelphia Eagles squad. 

3 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

If that's the case then we are in good shape with the rest of the offense.  #11 QB in the world.. . With this supporting cast....we should have a dominant offense!  

Funny how even the Hurts Hater makes the mistake of referring to the rest of our players as Hurts supporting cast. Very telling of just how forced your agenda has become. 

2 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Upset paying to lose our best player on D?That just seems obvious. But then if we already are making decisions to go the rebuild route and get younger…then why bring in a 30 year old after? Doesn’t make much sense. Not until we had injuries effect and change our situation. We already have BG. Personally and selfishly is really love to see him go out with a bang having a good season. It’s so clearly his last year. So ride him until the wheels fall off this season. This all just comes second to developing our young core. Grow a team we can build on in the future

Dude... You didn't watch the Eagles defense last year.   Reddick was no where near the best player on D in 2023. But you do this.

You fall in love with a player for one year...then that's it. He can do no wrong.  You ignore all the reports about him as a selfish player, looking to get his stats...etc. 

2022 was one fluke year for Reddick...in the impact of making big plays.  Getting a sack basically every other game with one turnover all season ...not doing much vs the run.   That's not your best player.

3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

 

From all my so deep and thorough investigations(actually just took one peak at Over the Cap) I find we are paying him over 21.5 mil on our 2024 teams salary cap. That makes him BY Far our highest paid player according to official salary cap dollars we are spending on our 2024 Philadelphia Eagles squad. 

We aren't paying him anything  He will earn zero dollars from the Eagles.

4 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

If that's the case then we are in good shape with the rest of the offense.  #11 QB in the world.. . With this supporting cast....we should have a dominant offense!  

Still zero acknowledgement over coaching and playcalling…much less the obvious synergy that any O is tied to the performance of their D. Which is just glaring red flag of such a lack of a quality understanding of how the game of football works. Just like how you have held steadfast in how we actually won out one Lombardi was based solely on superior personnel. Completely watched the whole magical experience u gold in front of your eyes and missed the absolute beauty that transpired and contributed to making it such an incredibly unique experience.

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Funny how even the Hurts Hater makes the mistake of referring to the rest of our players as Hurts supporting cast. Very telling of just how forced your agenda has become. 

Why is that a mistake?   The QB has his supporting cast...that's how it works. 

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Still zero acknowledgement over coaching and playcalling…much less the obvious synergy that any O is tied to the performance of their D. Which is just glaring red flag of such a lack of a quality understanding of how the game of football works. Just like how you have held steadfast in how we actually won out one Lombardi was based solely on superior personnel. Completely watched the whole magical experience u gold in front of your eyes and missed the absolute beauty that transpired and contributed to making it such an incredibly unique experience.

Are you saying there aren't 10 guys that wouldn't do extremely well as the 2024 Eagles QB?    Lol.  

3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Still zero acknowledgement over coaching and playcalling…much less the obvious synergy that any O is tied to the performance of their D. Which is just glaring red flag of such a lack of a quality understanding of how the game of football works. Just like how you have held steadfast in how we actually won out one Lombardi was based solely on superior personnel. Completely watched the whole magical experience u gold in front of your eyes and missed the absolute beauty that transpired and contributed to making it such an incredibly unique experience.

I'd love to spend one hour on your planet.   Just for pure entertainment.  

3 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Dude... You didn't watch the Eagles defense last year.   Reddick was no where near the best player on D in 2023. But you do this.

You fall in love with a player for one year...then that's it. He can do no wrong.  You ignore all the reports about him as a selfish player, looking to get his stats...etc. 

2022 was one fluke year for Reddick...in the impact of making big plays.  Getting a sack basically every other game with one turnover all season ...not doing much vs the run.   That's not your best player.

He averaged almost a sack every game in his two years he played for us. Yes he started last year with an injury. Pretty much contributed to him not locking down more than one early season sack. But sacks just isn’t the only metric to judge by. If it was his what 35 sacks in like 38 games can’t even be reasonably argued against. I didn’t witness a selfish player. Looked like the opposite to me. He so clearly was a top ten defensive playmaker in 2022. So he massively outplayed his contract. At his age….and after such an absolutely brilliant 2022 season…there is no better leverage and negotiating position a player, especially him, would have been in. Selfish and all you allude to against him would have been the obvious if him forcing a raise…or some contract reworking to reflect his production in 2022. Instead he sucked it up. Heard early on before the 2023 season he understood how much he was underpaid. A blind fan that barely follows the game could easily have understood how underpaid he was. Not just random BS production either. Not grabbing multiple sacks in the fourth quarter of a blowout. Not that fluff stats you ate up with Gainwell racking up in the fourth quarter of the giants blowout victory after their team had completely given up. Reddick made the biggest most important play of our 2022 season. Not even arguable! He crushed Purdy and ended the Niners chances in that NFC Championship game. Our whole 2022 season was destined to be defined by just beating the Cowboys…then beating our only real NFC competition in the Niners. Niners were so clearly the only team that could challenge us and keep us from reaching the SB. I believe we could have won without Reddick’s huge play. Reddick made the crushing sack that eliminated Purdy from having any chance at being effective to stop out SB run. He sacked him…took him out. Wasn’t really a team effort. Wasn’t our whole Dline converting on Purdy. Wasn’t coverage forcing him to hold the ball. Wasn’t some other pass rusher forcing Purdy into Reddick. He single handed provided a lightning fast pass rush and crushing legal blow to Purdy that punched out SB to ticket.

16 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Dude... You didn't watch the Eagles defense last year.   Reddick was no where near the best player on D in 2023. But you do this.

You fall in love with a player for one year...then that's it. He can do no wrong.  You ignore all the reports about him as a selfish player, looking to get his stats...etc. 

2022 was one fluke year for Reddick...in the impact of making big plays.  Getting a sack basically every other game with one turnover all season ...not doing much vs the run.   That's not your best player.

He should have held out and forced us to give him a raise. At least forced added incentives. But instead Reddick made like one mention of how he so clearly was massively underpaid then bit his lip last season. I didn’t hear any talks or show of him holding out. Would have been completely understandable with such overwhelming leverage for any player at 29 to force his way to grabbing his huge payday. Most any player would have. Heck business wise it was the clear cut smart move. Instead Reddick sucked it up and played his butt off. Didn’t hear one peep from him about being disgruntled over Rosie hard balling him and ripping him off. Reddick instead did the total opposite of what you accuse of him. He showed how trusting he was in our organization. He wanted to be an Eagles more than anything else. He wasted his massive leverage of having such a dominant playmaking season that was highlighted by the highest of highs delivering us to the SB in our biggest most important victory of our year. 

Then even after losing his leverage displaying his unselfish professional behavior to prove his all out bleeding Eagles green….he even balked at the idea of Rosie telling him he had to look for a trade partner this offseason. Was so very clearly never his idea. This player didn’t force his way off our team being selfish. His reward for just wanting a reasonably fair market consideration after sucking up last year unselfishly to remain a part of our franchise was a stiff boot in the arse.

Our whole team fell off. Kelee Ringo is the only player I could even argue performed better at the end of the season. No idea how you can even try to seperate and single out Reddick in that situation?

Reddick was clearly our best defenders both seasons he was here. Some how you even try to knock his production some how. Which was 35 sacks(just from memory) in 38 games played. Unbelievably incredible production!

Your constant witch hunt to blame Hurts and now you so clearly proving your only agenda based opinion by trying to knock Reddick just closed any case of you providing any objective opinions. Get your head out of your butt and just face reality …FOR ONCE! It was Rosie that screwed up and created the situation. So much more than any other individual.