June 11, 20242 yr I'd really like to check out the Topher Grace edit: he cut the first three movies down to 85 minutes and it was apparently pretty good. but he won't release it. episode one is cut down to literally just the light saber battle and Obi-wan getting stuck with Anakin. from what I've read basically all the podracing, politics, and clone storyline was cut to focus just on Anakin's journey from kid to sith lord
June 11, 20242 yr 1 hour ago, VanHammersly said: true They almost all suck. IV was good and V was excellent. The rest can go into a wood chipper. Also, South Park was right. *I never saw one of the stand alones like Rogue One or Solo.
June 11, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, paco said: They almost all suck. IV was good and V was excellent. The rest can go into a wood chipper. Also, South Park was right. *I never saw one of the stand alones like Rogue One or Solo. That's madness. 4-6 are fantastic. Even if there are too many Muppets in 6. 1-3 are such utter dog sheet that they barely even qualify as movies. Lucas had a number of world class actors in there and I still could've made more believable Star Wars movies shooting exclusively in the living room of my college apartment. 7 was good. 8 was bad. 9 was ok. Rouge One is fantastic. Solo was good. Rankings go: 5, 6, Rogue One, 4, Solo, 7, 9, 8.....who gives a F
June 11, 20242 yr Just now, VanHammersly said: That's madness. 4-6 are fantastic. Even if there are too many Muppets in 6. 1-3 are such utter dog sheet that they barely even qualify as movies. Lucas had a number of world class actors in there and I still could've made more believable Star Wars movies shooting exclusively in the living room of my college apartment. 7 was good. 8 was bad. 9 was ok. Rouge One is fantastic. Solo was good. Rankings go: 5, 6, Rogue One, 4, Solo, 7, 9, 8.....who gives a F Not sure how it's madness. We agree on just about everything. You like 6 more a lot more than I do. Then other than that you like 9 a bit more than I did and you like 7 which I see as a shameless nostalgic cash grab. Too many Muppets in 6, and it's absolutely better than 1-3 and 7-9. But it's still not good. 1-3 is dog s 7 was somehow both predictable and a mess. Schmoopie and I got into an argument because I predicted Han dying, she thought I saw a spoiler. But it was obvious as hell before even going into the movie: Ford is cast but is also like 90. 8 was terrible 9 was really bad too. So, 6, 5 and then don't waste my time with any of the others.
June 11, 20242 yr 51 minutes ago, paco said: Not sure how it's madness. We agree on just about everything. You like 6 more a lot more than I do. Then other than that you like 9 a bit more than I did and you like 7 which I see as a shameless nostalgic cash grab. Too many Muppets in 6, and it's absolutely better than 1-3 and 7-9. But it's still not good. 1-3 is dog s 7 was somehow both predictable and a mess. Schmoopie and I got into an argument because I predicted Han dying, she thought I saw a spoiler. But it was obvious as hell before even going into the movie: Ford is cast but is also like 90. 8 was terrible 9 was really bad too. So, 6, 5 and then don't waste my time with any of the others. Maybe madness was a little harsh. But you really should see Rouge One. Honestly, you could make a case that it's the best of all the movies, considering I saw the originals when I was a kid, so I can't separate the nostalgia, but Rouge One had to hold up to the scrutiny of an adult me.
June 11, 20242 yr Just now, VanHammersly said: Maybe madness was a little harsh. But you really should see Rouge One. Honestly, you could make a case that it's the best of all the movies, considering I saw the originals when I was a kid, so I can't separate the nostalgia, but Rouge One had to hold up to the scrutiny of an adult me. Rogue One is just below Empire for me, but I can see the argument for it. It's a great movie.
June 11, 20242 yr Just now, mikemack8 said: @VanHammersly Rouge = a kind of makeup Makeup for what? 7?
June 11, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, mikemack8 said: @VanHammersly Rouge = a kind of makeup Oh, sheet. I got it. I never get that Fing word right
June 11, 20242 yr 6 hours ago, Dave Moss said: @Arthur Jackson ??? I'll bet you a jar of pickled herring he's a hemophiliac
Create an account or sign in to comment