1 hour ago, cunninghamtheman said:

That’s a good idea of a name worth mentioning for the role

Yes - it would be nice to see Keegan and Scharping take all the snaps at Rag Sat so we can see what we have. We know what we have with Toth. 

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Thank you for the compliment. I appreciate it!

You are absolutely the guy that can take a simple thing that works...and  come up with an idea to make it more complicated. 

You think it makes you smart...and  want to take it as a compliment...by all means. 

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

He played RG before we moved him to LG. Played RG in college and High school unlike Keegan.

Double check Keegan

He played in high school... lol

2 minutes ago, eggs said:

Yes - it would be nice to see Keegan and Scharping take all the snaps at Rag Sat so we can see what we have. We know what we have with Toth. 

Yikes I forgot all about Scharping

11 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

More importantly why would a OL with those 5 have to have Dickerson at RG?

Just curious to hear this....expert football idea. 

Idea creation specialist 

Now let’s be clear….we don’t totally know for sure anything. So I’m not saying for sure this is the case. But all evidence so far does support this possible scenario. So I was just asking your thoughts on the subject. Especially when applying your known thoughts concerning doing similar with our Secondary players.

3 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Double check Keegan

If you have differing info then just share it, I read he’s played LG or LT the whole time.

13 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

So there are no "specialists",just good players who execute the plays called and/or poor defenses, so stop with the specialist drivel

Yes everybody is just a good player or they aren’t. None have areas they accel in more or deficient areas of weakness…of course. Just DeVonta Smiths or Quez Watkins players…nothing else. All CBs are good at Man and Zone equally also. All LBs are good versus the run and pass equally. Everything is just generic fitting nice and neat into job title on a depth chart. If you are labeled WR that means you are fast, great your runner, great catching passes, great blocker, great running with the ball in your hands, can play inside or outside…..every labeled WR all are exactly the same…except some are good and some are bad. That seems exactly like what I’ve noticed all these games I’ve seen. Everybody is the exactly the same according to job titles on a depth chart.

No such thing as a run stuffing specialist on D anywhere. Can’t possibly exist if it isn’t labeled somewhere in a depth chart you browsed.

No such thing as a RB that specializes in pass catching either. That position doesn’t exist on the depth chart. Just good or bad RBs according to your logic FL.

9 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Now let’s be clear….we don’t totally know for sure anything. So I’m not saying for sure this is the case. But all evidence so far does support this possible scenario. So I was just asking your thoughts on the subject. Especially when applying your known thoughts concerning doing similar with our Secondary players.

My thoughts....the playoffs will have Mailata, Dickerson,  Jurgens, Keegan and Lane as the OL.

21 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Call the plays and let the player execute it-jebus

Let’s just call a short YAC creation play for a slow guy that isn’t special with ball in his hands. Seems like winning football to me. According to you it doesn’t matter if it was Ertz or Goedert that ran the play. Even if you can look at all these plays where Goedert creates after the catch so well and Ertz gains very little.

10 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

If you have differing info then just share it, I read he’s played LG or LT the whole time.

You know how you tell me....watch the presser....just go watch his interviews.  I mean... the obvious unknown in the OL was RG...you don't think any beat reporter asked him this question? 

2 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

My thoughts....the playoffs will have Mailata, Dickerson,  Jurgens, Keegan and Lane as the OL.

So what if Keegan is our next best Oline but can’t play RG?

Just now, joemas6 said:

You know how you tell me....watch the presser....just go watch his interviews.  I mean... the obvious unknown in the OL was RG...you don't think any beat reporter asked him this question? 

So link to me his answer. I think it’s been so very apparent that there must be a reason Keegan is pretty much the only guy that hasn’t  tried at RG. 

I mean..." what up pimp" was a big deal...but the rest of the interviews with the rookies wasn't? 

Q, ceedee duece...and all the other nicknames from the stylish part of SF ...yet refuse to watch interviews from television rookies as they become Eagles?

But Siri said this..lol

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

So what if Keegan is our next best Oline but can’t play RG?

Keegan will play RG.   Stop acting like he could play LG in the NFL..to where you move the best in the league..but can't play RG at all.    Just ridiculous 

5 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

So link to me his answer. I think it’s been so very apparent that there must be a reason Keegan is pretty much the only guy that hasn’t  tried at RG. 

I would if it were anyone else....but your  arrogance and ignorance over the years when we ask you to give a simple and direct answer ... you do your own research..

 

Dickerson’s first play as an Eagles he faced the Niners and Erik Armstead. Hurts launched over 50 air yard bomb to DeVontaSmith for a huge play backed up at our own endzone.

6 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Keegan will play RG.   Stop acting like he could play LG in the NFL..to where you move the best in the league..but can't play RG at all.    Just ridiculous 

I didn’t say Keegan couldn’t play RG. I just posed the question about theoretically what if he couldn’t? There is some reasoning to actually believe this is a plausible scenario.

8 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Keegan will play RG.   Stop acting like he could play LG in the NFL..to where you move the best in the league..but can't play RG at all.    Just ridiculous 

This actually is the case with some players. Not every player can swing to either side. It’s not 100 percent universal. 

Even past some players can only play one side…some just are pretty drastically better on one side versus the other.

5 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

I would if it were anyone else....but your  arrogance and ignorance over the years when we ask you to give a simple and direct answer ... you do your own research..

 

And clearly I have done quite a bit of research. Stated the facts I’ve learned. But none of this is actually the point of the simple hypothetical question that I posed over a hypothetical scenario.

You had no problem with not playing our best CB outside because of team need and putting the best starting lineup out there. So I just asked if that also applies the same to our Oline.

I mean yes…I do actually question how you’d Keegan can be at RG versus LG. Something I wasn’t questioning nearly as much before this whole offseason has transpired like it has. But I never said Keegan can’t play RG. Just don’t know. But the coaching decisions really gave me wondering much more about it. 
 But none of these opinions is truely relevant to the hypnotic scenario question. I’m leaping out to say Keegan is the next best Oline to begin with anyway.