March 21, 20241 yr 5 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said: 1) Pickett is the 2,where else would the competition be except for #3???? You keep saying :just get me the best players" yet when I lay it out it's not good enough. Like to see you post a mock. A round FIVE QB is something you need to worry about?? I'm not selecting one in round 2 here and he is the LAST round 5 pick. yes I liked what I saw from McKee,but it was so limited there is no real reason to know unless he gets into a real game during the season which is unlikely. Maybe Milton is better and one goes away? Or both work out and we have a trade piece??? But with the last 5 pick it's not worth the risk??? Please post a mock covering all picks not just "I like this guy". I'd like to see it. 2) whatever 3) Why can't we get a TE AND a slot WR? Is there some rule bout that? Again post your mock. Where do you take a D lineman. If you do that's fine but you're giving up talent in the back 7 and this is a great draft for that.A round 5 DL is going to make an impact? No different that a round 5 QB,except that QB's are worth more in a trade if they work out. Tell me where "later" is for your D line pick. How much later? GOod CB,S and LB class here,it's a good time to grab a couple. Find more DL guys in FA if that suits you I'm not posting a mock because I don't watch college nor really care. I still work and am raising two kids, no time to fiddle around with that. I was commenting on your reasoning for each pick. And giving you my ideas on that. The QB 4 is a luxury. We have holes on the roster. As you keep naming them. Basically EVERYTHING BUT QB. Why draft one... especially since we just used 3 picks and moved down with a 4th pick on our two backups. That's 4 picks...you want to invest a 5th pick for a #4 QB? How about use that pick and double down on a skill position guy...because we are thin at all of TE, WR and RB. I'd rather draft 3 RBs than a QB. At least it creates competition for a guy who would actually play in the game...not to be the backup to the backup. Maybe the pick ends up being a return specialist? A gunner? Anything thar contributes. Draft 2 LBs. Two TEs... 3 DBs... double down on both lines too...all of that makes more sense than another draft asset used on a 4th QB.
March 21, 20241 yr 4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said: I don't List them in order and which takes choose them
March 21, 20241 yr 6 hours ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: We have drafted a few guys high under Howie Eric Rowe is the name that comes to mind first obviously didn’t pan out for us…. Just invested a 3rd last year in Brown at S. Might not spend a 1st on a CB but definitely could see us getting a CB in rounds 2 or 3 maybe back to back Didn't we draft 2 CBs day two in 2017. The injured guy Sydney something and Razul Douglass? The last 3 second round picks were Hurts, Dickerson and our new starting C. Hard to complain there.
March 21, 20241 yr 4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said: Doubt four straight QBs That's what it seems like listening to a lot of these talk shows. Teams trade up for them. Are there any stud linemen this year that are can't pass up...usually that would be something to prevent the extended QB run to start.
March 21, 20241 yr 15 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: List them in order and which takes choose them So if there are 4 QBs selected first... trade ups will occur. Plenty of teams need QBs
March 21, 20241 yr 4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said: https://www.nfldraftbuzz.com/Player/Dallin-Holker-TE-BYU Interesting prospect with big upside Could snag this guy in 5 maybe and free up the 97 pick for something else.He needs work on blocking. He was a pass catcher all this time,so maybe he can learn the needed blocking skills. After the catch he moves like WR The Eagles don't have pick 98 any longer...was 97 then got bumped to 98 before they traded that pick to Pittsburgh to get Pickett.
March 21, 20241 yr Author 1 hour ago, joemas6 said: Why do you need competition for 3rd string QB...when there are other holes on your roster. You have all 3 QBs locked up...for multiple seasons.... you already liked the 3rd string QB, he should be looking to compete for the #2 job. Look at the roster and look past this year. You are going to lose 3 DL in your rotation...Graham, Sweat and Milton. Your OL is thin. You have one RB under contract past this year. Your two starting CBs are old. You need a slot WR. That's not even looking at LB or S. Drafting a QB to compete for #3... not the time for it. We have invested enough in the position. A pick last year, moving back in this years draft. 2 picks next year. We paid Hurts big $$. That's enough of an investment on QB. A couple OL... a couple DL.. TE , RB, WR... we need those. And again...that's not even mentioning LB, S or CB. I'm good without drafting a QB for a couple of years. What's the difference? Like they are bench riders who cares what the position is? They aren't going to play in a game so it really doesn't matter does it?
March 21, 20241 yr Author 1 hour ago, joemas6 said: I'm not posting a mock because I don't watch college nor really care. I still work and am raising two kids, no time to fiddle around with that. I was commenting on your reasoning for each pick. And giving you my ideas on that. The QB 4 is a luxury. We have holes on the roster. As you keep naming them. Basically EVERYTHING BUT QB. Why draft one... especially since we just used 3 picks and moved down with a 4th pick on our two backups. That's 4 picks...you want to invest a 5th pick for a #4 QB? How about use that pick and double down on a skill position guy...because we are thin at all of TE, WR and RB. I'd rather draft 3 RBs than a QB. At least it creates competition for a guy who would actually play in the game...not to be the backup to the backup. Maybe the pick ends up being a return specialist? A gunner? Anything thar contributes. Draft 2 LBs. Two TEs... 3 DBs... double down on both lines too...all of that makes more sense than another draft asset used on a 4th QB. Doesn't matter,none of them are going to play so whatever. A round 5 is not a big investment no matter who it is.I posted another mock you would like better,but lets harp on this QB gig.The Pickett trade was awful(and Pickett is awful) and we only have 1 more QB after that.If Jalen gets hurt week 1 and Pickett sucks,none of the other investments really matter.If I had to count on QB3 I at least want the best one,but lets just hand out the jobs with no competition. SF found out what happens when you run out of QB's
March 21, 20241 yr Author 1 hour ago, cunninghamtheman said: List them in order and which takes choose them https://www.nflmockdraftdatabase.com/big-boards/2024/consensus-big-board-2024 Now add McCarthy into the mix and you have your 4 QB's The Jets are going to need someone because Arod isn't playing forever(first he needs to survive week 1 lol)
March 21, 20241 yr Author 16 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said: https://www.nflmockdraftdatabase.com/big-boards/2024/consensus-big-board-2024 Now add McCarthy into the mix and you have your 4 QB's The Jets are going to need someone because Arod isn't playing forever(first he needs to survive week 1 lol) https://www.nflmockdraftdatabase.com/big-boards/2024/consensus-big-board-2024?pos=QB You could even add Nix in there,so possibly 5,but we'll see. I don't see him(Nix) beating out Harrison and a couple others
March 21, 20241 yr 6 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said: What's the difference? Like they are bench riders who cares what the position is? They aren't going to play in a game so it really doesn't matter does it? Sure it does...other positions you play multiple in a game. You don't need 4 QBs
March 21, 20241 yr 7 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said: Doesn't matter,none of them are going to play so whatever. A round 5 is not a big investment no matter who it is.I posted another mock you would like better,but lets harp on this QB gig.The Pickett trade was awful(and Pickett is awful) and we only have 1 more QB after that.If Jalen gets hurt week 1 and Pickett sucks,none of the other investments really matter.If I had to count on QB3 I at least want the best one,but lets just hand out the jobs with no competition. SF found out what happens when you run out of QB's Google " Eagles 5th round picks " goes back like 25 years to ND Kalu, Celek, Trent Cole a few RBs...Big V , Ike Reese etc. No need for 4th QB there I'd we can get one of those guys or some of the others who contributed.
March 21, 20241 yr 8 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said: The Pickett trade was awful(and Pickett is awful) and we only have 1 more QB after that. Which team is 4 QBs deep? Agree if any team loses their first two QBs...it's a big deal.
March 21, 20241 yr Author 4 hours ago, joemas6 said: Sure it does...other positions you play multiple in a game. You don't need 4 QBs SO a #5 LB will play?
March 21, 20241 yr Author 4 hours ago, joemas6 said: Google " Eagles 5th round picks " goes back like 25 years to ND Kalu, Celek, Trent Cole a few RBs...Big V , Ike Reese etc. No need for 4th QB there I'd we can get one of those guys or some of the others who contributed. Brady was a round 6, Maybe Milton is the next Brady and we don't know it
March 21, 20241 yr Author 3 hours ago, joemas6 said: Which team is 4 QBs deep? Agree if any team loses their first two QBs...it's a big deal. 3 QB's rostered 1 on the PS,alot of teams have this. Except SF who found out the hard way
March 21, 20241 yr Author https://www.nfl.com/news/2024-nfl-draft-what-we-learned-from-alabama-ohio-state-and-usc-pro-days
March 21, 20241 yr Author 1 hour ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: We signed Paris Campbell to a 1 year deal There we go,he can play slot pretty well. He is fast. He can BU Smith if he gets hurt. He was the outlet guy at OSU. He's good on the horizontal screen/bubble screen passes. I could see him working between the 20's then subbing in Parker in the slot near the GL. Happy with this pick-up. As I recall watching OSU he has good hands and is the "clutch" type that can covert 3rd downs
March 21, 20241 yr 17 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said: Except SF who found out the hard way Isn’t SF the entire reason there is an emergency QB rule in place because of the NFC championship against us?
March 21, 20241 yr Author Just now, Bleedinggreen93 said: Isn’t SF the entire reason there is an emergency QB rule in place because of the NFC championship against us? I believe so
March 21, 20241 yr For what it’s worth apparently Campbell was the player Howie/Joe Douglas wanted in the 2019 draft before Lurie used his owner card saying he wanted JJaw
March 21, 20241 yr Report also stated that we had medical concerns for Metcalf so he wasn’t likely on our board at all and we completely botched our evaluation of scary terry
March 21, 20241 yr Author 2 minutes ago, Bleedinggreen93 said: For what it’s worth apparently Campbell was the player Howie/Joe Douglas wanted in the 2019 draft before Lurie used his owner card saying he wanted JJaw The Colt connection is still alive
Create an account or sign in to comment