May 4, 20251 yr 3 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:See and this is where most here prop Siri up as the greatest. They can point to making the playoffs every season and wins. So his teams have done well. Thing is….they haven’t been maximizing. Clearly been a super gifted O that’s been actually held back. A few here loved Siri pulling back our O playing not to lose. But I’m making the case completely against that. That we’ve had the same O pretty much this whole time. They should have been killing opponents scoring 50 plus under a quality O mindYou and I will have to agree to disagree. The choice of game plan is effective risk mitigation.
May 4, 20251 yr 3 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:I obsess over Eagles football clearly. Collaborating is when we receive the best results.So, why are you arguing that Howie and Fangio shouldn’t/don’t collaborate?
May 4, 20251 yr 3 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:Not saying there is any solution. Just not understanding why it’s not on anybody else’s mind around here. Giants just were gifted an elite pass rushing wrecking ball.They weren’t gifted. They earned. The Draft choices in reverse order of record has been a fixture for decades.
May 4, 20251 yr 3 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:You know….that doesn’t bother meDoesn’t bother me either.
May 4, 20251 yr 22 minutes ago, mattwill said:You and I will have to agree to disagree. The choice of game plan is effective risk mitigation.Choice of gameplan lead to a stacked O scoring the least of any O in the league. Not sure you have any grounds to disagree on
May 4, 20251 yr 20 minutes ago, mattwill said:So, why are you arguing that Howie and Fangio shouldn’t/don’t collaborate?I’m totally agreeing that this should have been the way the whole time. Don’t be scared to hire a coach well qualified. Give up some of the power and control makes Rosie even better
May 4, 20251 yr 21 minutes ago, mattwill said:So, why are you arguing that Howie and Fangio shouldn’t/don’t collaborate?Rosie had some bad philosophies holding us back. He’s a heck of a GM. But everytime he steps into the football wisdom areas we struggle.
May 4, 20251 yr Think about all Rosie has believed. Don’t pay the RB. Don’t value LB and S. He went exactly against all his core philosophies and we won it all.
May 4, 20251 yr Fangio was unbelievably on point first year here. His decisions of what he needed were spot on. Rosie even noticed Baun….but as an Edge. He just isn’t a football guy like that. Obviously loves the game….but never could see him playing it.
May 4, 20251 yr Rosie gave the keys over to a qualified hired coach. All things he wouldn’t do before.
May 5, 20251 yr Rosie already signed Bradberry and over CGJ negotiations. Rosie had to prove he was right. He understood the market very well. But that wasn’t what our organization needed. We needed Ceedy Duce at S. Switching over to pay Bradberry much more proved a very terrible decision.
May 5, 20251 yr Same thing with Reddick. Rosie was correct about reading the market. So he proved it. Year ahead of actually dealing with the situation Rosie already was planning for who to replace Redick with. Huff was a bad decision. Had all the signs of he was puffed up with surrounding cast and system coaching.
May 5, 20251 yr Rosie completely ignored the S room. It was so flagrant he actually was forced to make a trade for CGJ. Got to the SB. Being correct about Ceedy market lead to our problems. Got a S back and we go to the SB again. Proves how much his flaws have been holding us back.
May 5, 20251 yr Wouldn’t ever hire coaches that had earned power. Always wanted puppets. Rosie’s ego really got in the way.
May 5, 20251 yr 43 minutes ago, mattwill said:You and I will have to agree to disagree. The choice of game plan is effective risk mitigation.Gameplan was clearly our weakest area. Started games terribly. I mean seriously…this O being the worst scoring team was an absolute failure
May 5, 20251 yr 5 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:Gameplan was clearly our weakest area. Started games terribly. I mean seriously…this O being the worst scoring team was an absolute failureReally is just further evidence of how much Siri has just been holding our O back
May 5, 20251 yr Sure the playing not to lose approach worked out. That isn’t any proof of just unleashing our gifted O wouldn’t have worked just the same.
May 5, 20251 yr All evidence points to back up everything I’m saying. I just wanted our O to achieve what I knew they could. Finally unleashed at the end it happened. How would unleashing such a powerful O not have been as successful?
May 5, 20251 yr Took an O that should be scoring over 50 and dialed it back playing not to lose. I wasn’t a fan of it. I don’t care at all about stats. Our high character QB and WRs only way our team pulled that idea off. Can’t think of another WR or QB that goes for any of that.
May 5, 20251 yr It took hiring just a decent tier O mind in Moore to get there finally. What a huge leap forward. Just more clear evidence of what we’ve been missing under Siri.
May 5, 20251 yr How could you have watched those final playoff games and still deny what our O was capable of the whole time?
May 5, 20251 yr 4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:Why would I want to change our arguably biggest advantage?You have just argued that it is unfair that the NFL Rules for the Draft have gifted Abdul Carter to the Giants. Were you just complaining rhetorically or did you really believe that unfairness ought to be remedied.
May 5, 20251 yr 4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:Sometimes in a fight you observe the trainer lays out a perfect gameplan that leads to one sided slaughterAs Mike Tyson famously said, "Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the face."
May 5, 20251 yr Everything was setup perfectly for the giants to totally screw up and reach for QB Sanders. They actually resisted and had a solid draft. Kind of sucks.
Create an account or sign in to comment