33 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

He’s in charge of saying who he needs

You need to stop there. He will decide the roles. As a BU it's not the big deal you are making it out to be it's a very MINOR move. He has already played under Fangio in Miami. Waiting on the list of 7(still)

4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Just clueless

That’s the way I view your thinking. All about week one and stats. Very small importance to our franchise bigger picture

4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Every QB has a supporting cast,where ya been?

Yeah I see things as the best player then the rest are considered the supporting cast

4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Every QB has a supporting cast,where ya been?

Like in basketball ….is the PG always the leader and the rest the supporting cast? No, it’s the best player that is surrounded by the supporting cast.

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

Yeah I see things as the best player then the rest are considered the supporting cast

In basketball....in football it's the QB and the supporting cast. The whole game is designed around the QB.... protecting him, getting open for him...rushing him, confusing him...etc.

I would say the supporting cast around Hurts and Purdy are the best in the league.

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Like in basketball ….is the PG always the leader and the rest the supporting cast? No, it’s the best player that is surrounded by the supporting cast.

The pitcher and the QB...have a supporting cast.  

4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

We played vs powerhouse O lines the last 2 years?(easy schedule 3 years in a row really). What year did we play many teams with BU QB's or hurt O lines? Maybe his demands were too high to stay?  Maybe he wanted to try something new? Maybe he didn't mesh with the culture? Maybe Fangio didn't want to mess with him at this time? Maybe he didn't fit Fangios schemes? So many factors go into these decisions

Rosie had already decided to boot him before this offseason. C’mon you don’t see how Rosie works and moves? He would have worked something out with Reddick last season if he had any plans on making him happy to stay.

Is the best actor always in the leading role?    The leading role on a football team is the QB.   Same with pitcher in baseball.  

 

4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Both Reddick and Sweat we both on the blocks very early last year

Neither seemed to fetch anything worthwhile to trade them for. I can see hearing offers. I can even see trading pretty much any player for the right price that is good for our franchise. But we just ate it and gifted the Jets Reddick..

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Rosie had already decided to boot him before this offseason. C’mon you don’t see how Rosie works and moves? He would have worked something out with Reddick last season if he had any plans on making him happy to stay.

If Reddick was worth the money...he would be an Eagle.   The Eagles are not afraid to overpay for anyone they value.  

4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

How is that list of 7 coming?

Cant say I feel confident in us clearly beating any of our first five games opponents. If we are fairly even with half the league…nowhere close to dominating our way to a one seed with 12 wins.

1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Neither seemed to fetch anything worthwhile to trade them for. I can see hearing offers. I can even see trading pretty much any player for the right price that is good for our franchise. But we just ate it and gifted the Jets Reddick..

That should tell you something....that Reddick couldn't fetch a decent offer in your mind.... personally I like the day 2 pick for a dude who took a big time dive that my new DC prefers to move on from. 

20 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

You need to stop there. He will decide the roles. As a BU it's not the big deal you are making it out to be it's a very MINOR move. He has already played under Fangio in Miami. Waiting on the list of 7(still)

You keep harping on adding a player you can’t even identify for what role or position. Give it up man. If you like to add somebody to help the team in a specific way? Great. But you just throwing out names with zero plan….zero idea how theyl’ll even help our team improve.

22 minutes ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

You need to stop there. He will decide the roles. As a BU it's not the big deal you are making it out to be it's a very MINOR move. He has already played under Fangio in Miami. Waiting on the list of 7(still)

Lets add an over 30 year old to be the sixth or lesser option….yeah great plan FL…next

7 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

In basketball....in football it's the QB and the supporting cast. The whole game is designed around the QB.... protecting him, getting open for him...rushing him, confusing him...etc.

I would say the supporting cast around Hurts and Purdy are the best in the league.

I like Burrows. I like Goffs. Browns too. Cowboys got it setup. I see us as the 10…11th best roster. But Purdy so clearly way ahead with his supporting cast. He has Shannahan.

7 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

Is the best actor always in the leading role?    The leading role on a football team is the QB.   Same with pitcher in baseball.  

 

Flacco won the SB with his supporting cast? No. Ray Lewis lead that team. Flacco was just playing his role.

6 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

If Reddick was worth the money...he would be an Eagle.   The Eagles are not afraid to overpay for anyone they value.  

He’s been our best defender the two years he played for us. What else makes a guy worth the money?

7 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

If Reddick was worth the money...he would be an Eagle.   The Eagles are not afraid to overpay for anyone they value.  

Eagles are totally exactly afraid to overpay anyone. It’s more about Rosie winning the on paper ego wars than putting together a championship team. He butted heads with Ceedy Duce. Wasn’t even that expensive.?But Rosie had to show everybody he won the negotiations. But our team paid the price for it.

7 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

That should tell you something....that Reddick couldn't fetch a decent offer in your mind.... personally I like the day 2 pick for a dude who took a big time dive that my new DC prefers to move on from. 

No idea what Fangio believes. Rosie screwed up having him coach Reddick to even see how it would have worked.

8 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

That should tell you something....that Reddick couldn't fetch a decent offer in your mind.... personally I like the day 2 pick for a dude who took a big time dive that my new DC prefers to move on from. 

It’s been very obvious Reddick has always been misunderstood and underrated.

Just now, cunninghamtheman said:

It’s been very obvious Reddick has always been misunderstood and underrated.

Takes people who can think outside the box. He doesn’t fit that prototype mold.

10 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

That should tell you something....that Reddick couldn't fetch a decent offer in your mind.... personally I like the day 2 pick for a dude who took a big time dive that my new DC prefers to move on from. 

Bad GM job on the whole way things were played.

12 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

That should tell you something....that Reddick couldn't fetch a decent offer in your mind.... personally I like the day 2 pick for a dude who took a big time dive that my new DC prefers to move on from. 

You prefer Jalyx Hunt in the second over Reddick? Or you are saying Rosie made a great trade getting a three years from now third rounder for our best defender?

I can totally understand the business side of things. Viewing our team rebuilding in new schemes and not contending right now choosing to not pay and move on from Reddick is understandable. Clear cap. Build off a new young core that can be a foundation for years to come.

Blew the call on coaches. Steichen proved himself as the real O mind. Shouldn’t have let him get away. Fired Siri and promoted Steichen was the tough….but correct call.