July 25, 20242 yr Back to Kendal Milton though he’s a pure rushing back. So that’s his drawback it seems.
July 25, 20242 yr 2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: So clearly you are just dodging admitting Rosie was very clearly the one at fault. The 2019 and 2020 teams talent wasn’t anywhere near SB contending level. Yet the coach got fired for it. You know you are the one speaking about how great a look is for things and all that. This was a clear cut GM did a terrible job and scapegoated the coach for his mismanagement situation. Dude... from day one I blamed Howie for 2020... the roster and the injuries were his excuse... I said 5000 times if they were an excuse for him, then why weren't they an excuse for the coach and QB? Doug and Wentz took the blame for Hightower and JJAW being what they had to work with while 24 different guys started on the OL that season? I agree... I agree... I agreee... I agree BUT... ONLY LURIE'S OPINION MATTERS
July 25, 20242 yr 3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: Master plan is indeed in place. What it is we’ll disagree on. We disagree that if they win, that they make a change. you think regardless of what happens... Siri is done. I disagree. They need to fail first.
July 25, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, joemas6 said: Dude... from day one I blamed Howie for 2020... the roster and the injuries were his excuse... I said 5000 times if they were an excuse for him, then why weren't they an excuse for the coach and QB? Doug and Wentz took the blame for Hightower and JJAW being what they had to work with while 24 different guys started on the OL that season? I agree... I agree... I agreee... I agree BUT... ONLY LURIE'S OPINION MATTERS But I thought your point was it had to be a good look what they choose to do.
July 25, 20242 yr Just now, joemas6 said: We disagree that if they win, that they make a change. you think regardless of what happens... Siri is done. I disagree. They need to fail first. What’s your measure of fail?
July 25, 20242 yr 3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: Back to Kendal Milton though he’s a pure rushing back. So that’s his drawback it seems. Nah, he is what we had with Howard in 2021... the #4 RB. That can be used in certain short yardage and kill the clock situations if needed. That was missing the last 2 years, and really missing even the #3 last year. We throw 4 RBs in the mix ...with a stud legit bell cow as the #1. Big time impact to set the tone for the OL.
July 25, 20242 yr 3 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: But I thought your point was it had to be a good look what they choose to do. Yes... they could easily justify a crap year and the disagreement on the fix going forward as being a legit reason to fire Doug at the time. They can't fire Siri if they have a successful 2024 season and he does everything the front office wants and has the same plan going forward.
July 25, 20242 yr Goedert had a nice concise talk about motion. How it gets the LBs and S moving, giving ‘tells’ and makes it harder for the D to be gap sound against the run game.
July 25, 20242 yr 4 minutes ago, joemas6 said: Nah, he is what we had with Howard in 2021... the #4 RB. That can be used in certain short yardage and kill the clock situations if needed. That was missing the last 2 years, and really missing even the #3 last year. We throw 4 RBs in the mix ...with a stud legit bell cow as the #1. Big time impact to set the tone for the OL. Which I see as the needed complimetary type back for us. Even if looking at him as number three RB behind Saquan and Shipley.
July 25, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said: Which I see as the needed complimetary type back for us. Even if looking at him as number three RB behind Saquan and Shipley. Correct he can step up to #3 next year in 2025. For 2024, he can injury insurance or be used in some games in certain situations.
July 25, 20242 yr 2 minutes ago, joemas6 said: Yes... they could easily justify a crap year and the disagreement on the fix going forward as being a legit reason to fire Doug at the time. They can't fire Siri if they have a successful 2024 season and he does everything the front office wants and has the same plan going forward. Think the reasoning would be fairly simple even though not traditional. Just describe how they evaluated and decided to not lose Moore to another team being as he was deemed the main reasoning for O success this year and moving forward.
July 25, 20242 yr 3 minutes ago, joemas6 said: For 2024? Yes what was said Siri won’t be fired unless we fail. What is your measure for fail then?
July 25, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, joemas6 said: Correct he can step up to #3 next year in 2025. For 2024, he can injury insurance or be used in some games in certain situations. Could be now or looking to the future
July 25, 20242 yr Just now, cunninghamtheman said: Could be now or looking to the future Only second practice of TC. I’m going out on a limb to say much will happen between now and season end.
July 25, 20242 yr Shipley looks to be dynamic in the passing game. Milton could be a quality pairing to compliment him.
July 25, 20242 yr Just now, cunninghamtheman said: Think the reasoning would be fairly simple even though not traditional. Just describe how they evaluated and decided to not lose Moore to another team being as he was deemed the main reasoning for O success this year and moving forward. Why wouldn't the easy counter argument be... Siri hired Moore. you wanted Siri over Moore before as the head coach. You just made 2 SBs in 4 years under Siri, the 6th coach to ever make the playoffs his first 4 years (wonder how many made the SB twice in their first 4 years) Why wouldn't the easy argument be that they just find another OC? They did it twice already...and we both know Johnson was the outlier because he was Hurts childhood friend and promoted due to the potential of getting a comp pick. Do you expect offensive " genius" this year or just not the Brian Johnson offense of 2023? What if the Colts get 3rd place again... then how does that change the outlook for a guy like Steichen... losing that OC wouldn't look so bad would it. Another legit OC now makes Johnson the outleir. Now it's not Steichen carried Siri anymore. That's why I absolutely don't see Siri as a lock to get fired like you do.
July 25, 20242 yr What do you do as a new head coach for the Eagles... they want you to hire good coordinators.... but if you do, they will fire you because they don't want to lose the guy you hired? How does that make sense? Who would want the job?
July 25, 20242 yr 5 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said: Yes what was said Siri won’t be fired unless we fail. What is your measure for fail then? I obviously already think it’s pretty much done they just didn’t have a quality option this offseason so it had to be postponed to this offseason. Much of my opinion has been formed by how our players have seemed to feel and react to him.
July 25, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said: How much are we looking to grind on Saquan? A few games he could get 20-25 touches if needed. Others not so much in the blowouts
July 25, 20242 yr Just now, cunninghamtheman said: I obviously already think it’s pretty much done they just didn’t have a quality option this offseason so it had to be postponed to this offseason. Much of my opinion has been formed by how our players have seemed to feel and react to him. And again... " why did you fire Nick after this season" " well I fired him because of 2023" And you think that answer is going to be legit?
July 25, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said: I obviously already think it’s pretty much done they just didn’t have a quality option this offseason so it had to be postponed to this offseason. Much of my opinion has been formed by how our players have seemed to feel and react to him. See... I think the plan is in place .... IF THEY FAIL.
July 25, 20242 yr 3 minutes ago, joemas6 said: Why wouldn't the easy counter argument be... Siri hired Moore. you wanted Siri over Moore before as the head coach. You just made 2 SBs in 4 years under Siri, the 6th coach to ever make the playoffs his first 4 years (wonder how many made the SB twice in their first 4 years) Why wouldn't the easy argument be that they just find another OC? They did it twice already...and we both know Johnson was the outlier because he was Hurts childhood friend and promoted due to the potential of getting a comp pick. Do you expect offensive " genius" this year or just not the Brian Johnson offense of 2023? What if the Colts get 3rd place again... then how does that change the outlook for a guy like Steichen... losing that OC wouldn't look so bad would it. Another legit OC now makes Johnson the outleir. Now it's not Steichen carried Siri anymore. That's why I absolutely don't see Siri as a lock to get fired like you do. Yet we now know much more about how it was the Siri offense of 2023. So you meant just not the Siri O
July 25, 20242 yr 1 minute ago, cunninghamtheman said: I obviously already think it’s pretty much done they just didn’t have a quality option this offseason so it had to be postponed to this offseason. Much of my opinion has been formed by how our players have seemed to feel and react to him. Watch how the players would love him at the parade. He would optimize Kelce's speech with everyone talking trash on him... the city that loves the underdog. I mean why do you like Hurts and Doug... because they are underdogs. Your issue... similar to females... once you don't like someone that's it. That's emotional. that doesn't fly in the business world. But who specifically do you feel doesn't like Siri? Other than your boy?
Create an account or sign in to comment