Howie has played the 1st round perfectly. I'm shocked. 

The giants really did want Smith. They bailed right away. 

Just now, 4for4EaglesNest said:

Giants reach for Toney.  Wow.   With all the receivers they have?   Sheesh.  

Gettelman making Howie look smart. 

Still think the Giants weren't going to take DeVonta?

2 minutes ago, 315Eagles said:

😄 NYG fans are like " who the F*** is that?"

Shame on them.

Just now, jwill2420 said:

There ya go. NYG would have taken Smith if the Eagles didn’t trade up. They did what they had to do. 

I still don’t think it’s worth giving up the other pick, why not just stay put and Draft Terrace, Marshall or Rashid Bateman in the second and keep that pick

 

6 minutes ago, Wentz_Era said:

I'm catching up...looking for people I know who can talk intelligently.  That's why I replied here, wasn't sure if you were condemning the pick.

I like the pick. I hate the trade up. 

Just now, ToastJenkins said:

So when does JOK go?

I know the Eagles don’t do first round LB....but man would I love that trade up

Just now, ToastJenkins said:

So when does JOK go?

He's a guy without a position.  He's an average safety with elite LB skills.

2 minutes ago, jwill2420 said:

There ya go. NYG would have taken Smith if the Eagles didn’t trade up. They did what they had to do. 

They made a great trade at 11 with the Bears but then screwed it up by drafting Toney at 20. I would’ve taken Bateman or Marshall over him if i were going WR which they really shouldn’t have been. I’d have gone darrisaw tbh

Just now, schuy7 said:

Still think the Giants weren't going to take DeVonta?

I still think they were taking the trade. 

Just now, Iggles_Phan said:

Shame on them.

Based on the posts you see on this message board, are you really that shocked?

75% of fans don’t know crap about other teams players or anything about college players

So far we made 2 good trades and a good pick. Very happy about it.

1 minute ago, schuy7 said:

Still think the Giants weren't going to take DeVonta?

some people will cry about everything.

Ya, we 100% did the right thing.

1 minute ago, ManuManu said:

I still think they were taking the trade. 

How could you pass on a trade offer like that

Just now, ManuManu said:

I like the pick. I hate the trade up. 

You wanted the 3rd - I get that - but you agree that they needed to make the trade if they wanted Smith, right?

1 minute ago, ManuManu said:

I still think they were taking the trade. 

If Smith was there they weren't making that trade.

For the record, I am criticizing Devonta Smith because we just made him a top 10 pick.  Every aspect of him that deviates from perfection deserves to be dissected.

I'm fine with the pick overall, given the way the board broke.

I liked Waddle better, but I'd take the 1st.

1 minute ago, e-a-g-l-e-s eagles! said:

They made a great trade at 11 with the Bears but then screwed it up by drafting Tony at 20. I would’ve taken Bateman or Marshall over him if i were going WR which they really shouldn’t have been. I’d have gone darrisaw tbh

Eagles wrecked NYG’s round 1. Awesome!!!! 

3 minutes ago, RLC said:

Toney has character issues (wanting to be a musician in a city like NY) and is an AWFUL fit in the Garrett offense.

Yeah he kind of reminds me of Tavon Austin.  I remember when the Cowboys signed him and there was hype all summer how he was going to be a major factor in their offense and he was a total non-factor in that Garrett offense. 

2 minutes ago, schuy7 said:

Still think the Giants weren't going to take DeVonta?

Right? They were going to do it regardless if they needed one or not. 

Just now, bbabraham said:

You wanted the 3rd - I get that - but you agree that they needed to make the trade if they wanted Smith, right?

Not necessarily. 

2 minutes ago, ManuManu said:

I like the pick. I hate the trade up. 

Well you just saw the reason why bud.

5 minutes ago, 4for4EaglesNest said:

Wait.  You were just in here crying about others opinions.  Get a dog Nancy.  
 

Of course we want him to do great.  I don’t hate the player.  Just didn’t want another WR.  And don’t like his size.  Not that a rationale position means much to a knuckle dragger like yourself.  

hahaha a knuckle dragger because I support the fact that we traded down, gained an additional 1st rd pick next year and traded an extra 3rd to draft the best f'n player in the country.  Go cry somewhere else.  Everybody is tired of all the negative cry baby BS year after year.