But Rosie screwing around with Gannon and losing Fangio while also making a terrible decision losing Dennard also wasn’t the only major obvious flaw in Rosie’s job performance last season. Oh..nope. He screwed up so much more. Only plan for a starting LB was a draft choice that is questioned for durability and couldn’t even grab any playing time his rookie season. Complete disregard for the middle second level of our D. Even if NaKobe panned out…on the most optimistic view…it still was a complete GM botched job in the LB room. His plan was to bring in a guy that was looking into becoming a plumber. That’s how much Jack understood his career was over. 

Or how about the choice to hard ball CGJ? Completely was a cheap player in the overall scheme of NFL players pay. But Rosie just walked away from negotiations and doing what he needed to for Ceedy Duce to be retained. Yes Rosie was correct on reading the market that CGJ wasn’t going to receive a better offer than what Rosie was offering by that point. But Rosie’s ego on being right cost us. We are the ones that suffered, 31st ranked pass D last season. CGJ has the attitude our D lacked and needed so very badly. Botching that deal was bad enough to nail Rosie down so very badly over one of his main issues performing his job. He had to prove how right he was…over getting done what our team needed. Rosie ego comes before the Eagles franchise.

Just so terrible the coaching decisions were handled by Rosie. So terrible the constant obsession to prove he was right cost us the confident S out terrible Secondary needed so barely, 31st pass D! Terrible. His ignoring the whole off ball LB room putting it in the hands of Dean was just fool hearty…even if you try to be optimistic. But in proving how right he was about the CGJ contract he walked away from working out retaining him….just so he could choose to pay Bradberry so much more and over multiple years. In hindsight there isn’t even any debate how bad this was. He paid so much more for an old washed up Bradberry who absolutely stunk. But not just temporary one year rental. We are stuck paying Bradberry holding up our future as well. 

CGJ got injured early last season…who knows how it played out if he still was here. Bradberry stunk terribly. Desai wasn’t horrible…but Rosie still tried to pin things on Desai enacted his plan alll along of turning to Patricia. A plan Rosie needed badly to blame anybody but himself. No off ball LBs. A 31st ranked pass D but you only can look to blame our pass rush. Like it’s possible for any rusher to generate more pressure with zero coverage to force any hesitation for opponents QBs. Heck bad coverage that at least disrupted the receivers at the line would have been preferred to give the pass rush the chance. They didn’t just not cover well….they gave big cushions to not even challenge receivers. Pass rushers were the last ones to place blame on for what occurred last season. 

But you laughed off the Niners stealing Hargrave from us. Record pace sack team we provided in 2022 fell off. You act like you’re shocked and surprised. All along I completely told you and expected the results. Eagles 11 wins ….Niners SB. Not even should come off as me bragging about calling it so much. It was just that obvious. For those of us not trying to spin agendas away from Rosie being anything but brilliant and the greatest. He screwed the whole situation up.

What player has ever produced more than 35 sacks in 38 games in his Eagles career? Oh yes did Reddick have actual just stat production….even with you trying to ignore all other pertinent factors.

48 minutes ago, joemas6 said:

You are so naive.  

Naive is you actually buying into such a clearly manufactured reasoning Rosie felt forced to create surrounding his handling of Hassan Reddick.

5 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Naive is you actually buying into such a clearly manufactured reasoning Rosie felt forced to create surrounding his handling of Hassan Reddick.

The guy ignored his smart business decision leverage after 2022 just to try and work things out and remain an Eagles. He didn’t gripe and create a media scandal over him being so obviously underpaid. He never demanded a trade…ever. That was all Rosie’s doing. Reddick just wanted to be an Eagles more than anything. Did whatever was asked of him…to trust in our organization repaying his professionalism and loyalty. Even had Rosie flip the D to Patricia so disgustingly…just all to cover up Rosie’s mistakes. I remember Patricia had the brilliance of having our elite pass rusher drop back into coverage. Reddick’s wasn’t stat chasing and being selfish. He was screwing himself for our team. I saw Reddick drop back in pass coverage. It happened. Terrible Gm-ing and coaching created that…but Reddick the player did what he was told. Factually what actually occurred. On tape even.

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

At what position and job? Pretty important part of any equation of adding a player. You are fighting and arguing to add him…but can’t even define for what role.

Isn't that WTH we pay Fangio to decide? 15 pages(and counting) of dodging a direct question of which 7 teams we lose to

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

I’m actually trying to throw you a bone here on this. I’ve been assuming and we’ve been talking about him as an Edge player. The answer is no for that. But if the discussion is about a rotational pass rushing interior Dline position I could actually be more willing to discuss that. The answer would still be no…but at least more worthy of discussing and considering.

Isn't that what we pay Fangio for??? TO make decisions? Oh I forgot,he needs Ham's approval first,my bad

4 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

If he’s not an option for 2025 and moving forward on a rebuilding team and D then there isn’t much point in discussing him then…not anywhere near at this point especially.

Just clueless

3 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Funny how even the Hurts Hater makes the mistake of referring to the rest of our players as Hurts supporting cast. Very telling of just how forced your agenda has become. 

Every QB has a supporting cast,where ya been?

3 hours ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Still zero acknowledgement over coaching and playcalling

Still zero acknowledgement for which 7 teams we will lose to

2 hours ago, joemas6 said:

I'd love to spend one hour on your planet.   Just for pure entertainment.  

You can check out anytime you want...but you can never leave

1 hour ago, cunninghamtheman said:

What player has ever produced more than 35 sacks in 38 games in his Eagles career? Oh yes did Reddick have actual just stat production….even with you trying to ignore all other pertinent factors.

We played vs powerhouse O lines the last 2 years?(easy schedule 3 years in a row really). What year did we play many teams with BU QB's or hurt O lines? Maybe his demands were too high to stay?  Maybe he wanted to try something new? Maybe he didn't mesh with the culture? Maybe Fangio didn't want to mess with him at this time? Maybe he didn't fit Fangios schemes? So many factors go into these decisions

1 hour ago, cunninghamtheman said:

The guy ignored his smart business decision leverage after 2022 just to try and work things out and remain an Eagles. He didn’t gripe and create a media scandal over him being so obviously underpaid. He never demanded a trade…ever. That was all Rosie’s doing. Reddick just wanted to be an Eagles more than anything. Did whatever was asked of him…to trust in our organization repaying his professionalism and loyalty. Even had Rosie flip the D to Patricia so disgustingly…just all to cover up Rosie’s mistakes. I remember Patricia had the brilliance of having our elite pass rusher drop back into coverage. Reddick’s wasn’t stat chasing and being selfish. He was screwing himself for our team. I saw Reddick drop back in pass coverage. It happened. Terrible Gm-ing and coaching created that…but Reddick the player did what he was told. Factually what actually occurred. On tape even.

Both Reddick and Sweat we both on the blocks very early last year

How is that list of 7 coming?

4 hours ago, GreenbleedinNC said:

Isn't that WTH we pay Fangio to decide? 15 pages(and counting) of dodging a direct question of which 7 teams we lose to

He’s in charge of saying who he needs for exactly what roles. We don’t need to just add players to force on Fangio to try and make work. He needs to build his D with the pieces we have. He clearly got his wishes on getting the young draft picks he wanted. He chose Baun as a FA to be that cheap guy he thinks he can make work.

At this point it’s time to just let Fangio work on building and developing. Let him go to work. By the end of this season he needs to have a good read on all his players and what he can put together with this personnel. So in this offseason he needs to judge what are the final crucial pieces are needed. 

Can’t expect everything to work out perfect in one offseason. But can’t screw around on figuring out what he has …and what are the missing pieces. 

Rebuild and develop while giving as much reps to everybody Fangio can. Use this first season to get all the leg work out if the way. Have his D established with the building blocks he identifies. Rather take some bad hits this season figuring out what each guy can do and if he fits. Year two and going forward we need this D rocking!

Going to take lumps with the whole team learning a new scheme anyway. Things gotta start out fairly basic at first. Fangio gotta have all these players learn what he wants out of them in each scenario. You know each playcall having everybody adjusting and moving reading things his way according to each O that coverage faces. Learn how they deal with any motion and so on.

Got a few key pieces on just one year contracts. So gotta figure out if he needs them as a fit longer term or next year target those positions to invest in.

Sweat,Milton, Baun,Rodgers  and Devin White mostly. Slay won’t be around. He’s just here for this last season. Be that vet mentor to show all these young kids how to be a pro on all levels. 

2 minutes ago, cunninghamtheman said:

Sweat,Milton, Baun,Rodgers  and Devin White mostly. Slay won’t be around. He’s just here for this last season. Be that vet mentor to show all these young kids how to be a pro on all levels. 

Tyler Hall possibly. Maddox probably gone. Tuipoluto might be a keeper actually.